3 ms·
I drive on roads, I use libraries, I have police and fire protection. My children go to school. My city and state provide services to me and fellow citizens. Th
by toomuchtodo 1y ago
I drive on roads, I use libraries, I have police and fire protection. My children go to school. My city and state provide services to me and fellow citizens. This is no different, and we pay for it with taxes.
I like taxes, with them I buy civilization (which I also am fond of).
(The evidence also shows economic benefits of enabling parents to work when they want to by providing childcare)
https://illumine.app/blog/how-much-childcare-costs-by-state-in-usa https://illumine.app/blog/how-much-childcare-costs-by-state-...
https://childcaredeserts.org/ https://childcaredeserts.org/
https://research.upjohn.org/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1064&context=up_policybriefs https://research.upjohn.org/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1064...
- Isamu 1y agoI’m also fond of civilization. I like your point that enabling parents to work helps drive the economy to everyone’s benefit.
- defen 1y agoPortland OR is trying to do something similar ("Preschool for all") and is running into the exact problems OP identified, to the point that the Democratic governor is sending warning messages to the county: https://www.opb.org/article/2025/06/26/kotek-multnomah-county-fix-preschool-for-all/ https://www.opb.org/article/2025/06/26/kotek-multnomah-count... They aren't just theoretical concerns.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoI will find time to build an inventory of every example of where subsidized childcare works and reply with said inventory.
- hedora 1y agoYes, but can you find any that work well when the branch of the government that’s running it refuses to process paperwork from daycare providers or issue checks to pay those providers, and where its leader has prioritized getting the system shut down on the grounds that it’s “broken”? (Not strawmanning; just summarizing the situation in Oregon, according to that linked article.)
- toomuchtodo 1y agoGovernance is hard. People are hard. I can show you examples across the world where policy works, and where it doesn't. Success is not assured, but if we're not willing to try, why even get up in the morning? If it sucks in Oregon, my apologies; states are where experiments can take place, and there are 49 other states we can give it a go in.
- hedora 1y agoNo, clearly, if it doesn’t work when 100% of the people administering it are intentionally sabotaging it from within, it must be a bad idea. /s (I didn’t link the Oregon article, and don’t know much about it other than what the article says. Just pointing out it might not be the best case study to generalize from.)
- evantbyrne 1y agoAs someone who grew up homesteading and seeing the benefits of it, I find it wild that people want to not only send their kids away to school full-time but also institutionalize them afterwards just so they can spend seemingly excessive amounts of time at work. The economic machine demands sacrifices apparently.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoSixty percent of Americans cannot afford a basic quality of life on their income in the US [1] [2]. Half of American renters are cost burdened [3]. I find it wild someone thinks "Why don't you just stay home with your kids?" looking at the macro. Can't all just live on a farm and homestead to raise kids in an unfavorable, punishing macro. Parents work because they have to work. To work, they need childcare and flexible work arrangements. > "The economic machine demands sacrifices apparently." Indeed. Is the solution to sacrifice for it? Or tax it to care for the human? [4] We can make better choices, as New Mexico shows. I'm tired of hearing its impossible. It isn't, it's just a lack of will and collective effort in that direction, based on all available evidence. [1] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/cost-of-living-income-quality-of-life/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/cost-of-living-income-quality-o... [2] https://lisep.org/mql https://lisep.org/mql [3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43119657 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43119657 [4] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=paaen3b44XY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=paaen3b44XY (I am once again asking to think in systems)
- evantbyrne 1y agoNobody said homesteading is the solution. Allowing a parent of young children to care for them is not a radical idea though. It should not be hard to imagine a society that is more flexible to childcare being performed by parents, because that was the norm for all of human history prior to industrialization. People should seriously consider the ways in which their imaginations on this subject (and others!) are constrained by their post industrial upbringing, and importantly, why the current norms exist and who they benefit.
- toomuchtodo 1y ago
- qgin 1y agoI don't understand how many other developed countries are able to avoid the supposedly unavoidable perils of social services, but we act like this is a wild experiment that has never been tried anywhere in the world aside from the USSR or something.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoAmericans have been brain washed, these are deeply rooted belief systems like religions, that have an immune response when challenged. Steep climb ahead.
- mothballed 1y agoThere are bad public services and fairly good public services. There are also some great private services and some bad ones. There's no public roads where I live. They're all private easements, but you can pass through them no problem for miles and miles and get most the way to town without ever touching a taxpayer dime. I first built my bit of the road with a shovel , a 4x4 truck, and a hatchet which blows away what it would have cost my neighbors in taxes. If I tried to explain this to someone with no real concept of anything but a public road system their brain would probably explode trying to understand how this works out better than even many public road systems. There are a lot of people with exploding brains who can never get to the point of realizing our private road system is working as well as public road systems, and other exploding brains not realizing the public roads are working as well as their private roads. The main pain point I have tends to be that when the option for peaceful voluntary trade is available, I strongly prefer it over the violence of forcing others via taxation. Therefore I much prefer the situation of my community -- i.e. basically no police/fire, no public roads, and no public utilities. It works great but the pride point is the very low level of violence / involuntary funding necessary to make it happen.