3 ms·
> If the market grows in size and you’re able to grow revenue and profit, reduced market share in and of itself doesn’t matter. The Tesla story and its high va
by Aurornis 1y ago
> If the market grows in size and you’re able to grow revenue and profit, reduced market share in and of itself doesn’t matter.
The Tesla story and its high valuation were based on the idea that Tesla had won the car market, others couldn’t catch up, and Tesla was going to be doing laps around the competition with all of their additional business lines that grew out of their class-leading EV business.
If their EV business is losing market share, that really is a problem for the narrative. They could be fine as an EV company, but they’ve sold themselves as something far more.
> Tesla's overall annual revenue has continued to grow from $11.75 billion in 2017
2017 was forever ago in technology and economic terms. The most important problem right now is that their revenue isn’t growing while everyone else is getting better at EVs.
- DoesntMatter22 1y agoMost of the issue is that their competitors are selling at a big loss. Ford admitted so recently and are starting to make fewer cars. Rivian and lucid are also hemmoraging money. Without the tax credit these companies may cease to exist or stop making evs in the case of Ford. It's likely they will have fewer competitors soon
- andsoitis 1y ago> If their EV business is losing market share, that really is a problem for the narrative. They could be fine as an EV company, but they’ve sold themselves as something far more. Long-term growth is pinned on success in AI, robotics, robotaxis, and autonomous services.
- toast0 1y ago> The Tesla story and its high valuation were based on the idea that Tesla had won the car market, others couldn’t catch up This story never made sense. They sold about 1.8 million cars in 2024 (and also in 2023), VAG sold 9 million. Tesla is no where close to winning the car market. Until recently, Ford regularly sold more F-Series than Tesla sold cars. Sure, for quite some time, Tesla was selling a lot more EVs than anyone else. But, building EVs is supposed to be easier than building ICE cars, and some of the old guard auto manufacturers have been building cars for hundreds of years... Once they decide to build EVs and figure out the logistics of batteries, they're going to have no trouble building EVs or selling them, and then Tesla is left with the moat of the Musk Reality Distortion Field which seems to be weaker now than ever. When nobody else was making competent EVs, Telsa's market value was clear. Now, I don't know. There are so many to choose from, but what does a Tesla give you that some other EV doesn't?