3 ms·
Now if only they'd wield this power in relation to OEM's who seem intent on crapping up good phones with horrible addon software (MOTOBlur, I'm looking at you..
by Karunamon 14y ago
Now if only they'd wield this power in relation to OEM's who seem intent on crapping up good phones with horrible addon software (MOTOBlur, I'm looking at you...)
- Steko 14y agoThe idea that only pure android phones are worthy and that carrier ui layers are the only thing holding them back is silly. Many people like them and ICS replicated many of the things from carrier skins for this reason. Telling partners they can't differentiate is radically hypocritical and likely would just drive more to fork Android.
- Karunamon 14y ago..carrier ui layers are the only thing holding them back is silly There's also market fragmentation, but I'd say carrier dumbassery is almost a worse problem. This "differentiation" or "branding" or "experience" or whatever buzzword-compliant term chosen to describe it almost always makes the device less useful and less functional. Not just by being ugly, slapdash-looking "let's slap our identity all over this" abominations, but by harming performance. The canonical example was MOTOBlur on the Droid 2. The hardware was decent, it was an incremental upgrade over the original Droid, but it's made almost unusable by the preloaded Moto garbage. Compare a Droid 2 stock vs a Droid 2 running the AOSP version of the same Android release and try to say they're even remotely comparable. Worse battery life, sluggish performance.. Jellybean all on its own is a beautiful system. A fantasy of mine is that, for the next major release, Google enforces the kind of UI requirements being imposed by Microsoft - how much carrier dickery do you think will appear on Windows phones?
- nilsbunger 14y agoThe OEMs and carriers want to differentiate in SW too, not just in hardware. They don't want to be dumb pipes or just the "boxes" that android ships in. They happen to suck at SW and screw up the android experience. Without the opportunity to mess with it, Android wouldn't be as attractive to them.
- Steko 14y ago"Jellybean all on it's own" is a non sequitor because Jellybean didn't spring into being all on it's own and fully formed. It incorporated (and ICS before it) a lot of features from non-Google skins.
- Karunamon 14y agoCould you point out a few? Somehow I doubt Google is taking cues from badly designed carrier overlays.
- nvmc 14y agoI really can't think of a single good addon UI. Every single one I've used (TouchWiz, Blur, Sense) has been slower, uglier, and less functional than vanilla. The only reason why my old ass GSM Hero is still usable is because it's running a vanilla ROM.
- joelhaus 14y agoA quick fix: Google could force OEM's to give users an option to turn off the skin (sans root). Unfortunately, the carrier duopoly (i.e. lack of competition) is the underlying cause of this problem. Due to the subsidies and pricing power that their market position permits, carriers are able to dictate what devices they offer. If devices from HTC and LG are only differentiated by hardware, in the carrier's eyes, it makes no economic sense to give consumers the choice when they can limit costs by using only one vendor. The only long-term solution will be a fundamental restructuring of the regulatory regime surrounding wireless spectrum, however, the incumbents are so flush with cash that Washington is having too much fun lining their pockets.
- Zigurd 14y agoThe problem is there is carriers' money at stake. The carriers, and sometimes the OEMs, get paid to place crapware on phones.
- Karunamon 14y agoThe OEM UI's? I know they get paid to include apps (Going back to the Droid 2, there were a couple of non-uninstallables like Blockbuster), but there's money changing hands for the privilege of a custom UI?
- Zigurd 14y agoWhile it is unlikely that there is actual cash-per-tweak in handset look and feel, Samsung got a lot of business with Verizon by providing an iClone-ish Android product. So even when the carrier isn't getting paid to place an app, the carrier controls the channel (in the US), subsidizes the handset, and dictates what the OEM puts on their phone.