4 ms·
Unlike in athletics, academics isn’t necessarily a zero sum game. While in a race there is necessarily a winner and a loser, nobody in academics is held back if
by stephengillie 14y ago
Unlike in athletics, academics isn’t necessarily a zero sum game. While in a race there is necessarily a winner and a loser, nobody in academics is held back if another student is better able to retain their information.
No, but the doped student's advantage could cause her to be selected over another (undoped) student in college entrance exams, program entrance exams, and other educational competitions.
Does this mean we'll soon see articles about how the Ivy League and most hacker dens dope more than the Tour de France?
- matznerd 14y agoThere are already many students who are prescribed Ritalin, Concerta, Adderal etc, and these drugs give those students an unfair edge. How are normal students supposed to compete with their peers who are on amphetamines?
- makmanalp 14y ago> A study in Nature found that an average of 7% (with a range up to 25%) of US college students have used a nootropic at some point in their careers. http://singularityhub.com/2009/10/06/should-students-be-tested-for-brain-enhancing-drugs/ http://singularityhub.com/2009/10/06/should-students-be-test... What would you bet that ivys have a higher rate than average too? :)
- ConceptJunkie 14y agoSeeing as how the article considers (and rightly so) caffeine as a nootropic, I'd say the numbers are probably more like 70% rather than 7%.
- huhtenberg 14y agoSo what? Sports are essentially about competing, so the playing field being leveled is important. Academics is about the advancement of science. If doping helps a student to find a cure for cancer, I see no reason to object.
- krisoft 14y agoUnless it's side-effect free, it could pose an ethical dilemma. Would you take a pill wich makes you a prodigy but shortens your expected lifetime with 5 year? What would you think about the same decision if the former prodigy level becomes the new average in your field because of the widespread use?
- Permit 14y ago>Would you take a pill wich makes you a prodigy but shortens your expected lifetime with 5 year? Absolutely. Perhaps it's the naivety of youth speaking, but I'd gladly trade 5 of the worst years of my life to improve the rest of them. > What would you think about the same decision if the former prodigy level becomes the new average in your field because of the widespread use? I'd argue the world would be a much better place if this was the case. The real question you might want to ask is what if these drugs become expensive and only the upper class can afford them. It might lead to a sort of catch 22 by which no one was interested in hiring less intelligent or less capable people who couldn't afford such drugs.
- DanBC 14y ago>>Would you take a pill wich makes you a prodigy but shortens your expected lifetime with 5 year? >Absolutely. Perhaps it's the naivety of youth speaking, but I'd gladly trade 5 of the worst years of my life to improve the rest of them. Yes. I agree. (I'm 42 - does that make a difference?) Maybe I'd have to think about it if the deal was genius level prodigy but with severe life-long pain. (Either mental anguish, or physical severe arthritis or whatever.) (I'm reminded of Aronofsky's PI.)
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ggwicz 14y agoWho cares if thinkers use drugs? They have since the dawn of time, and it's helped all of us by letting already brilliant people get an extra boost. Whether it's psychedelics, marijuana, or nootropics, we know substances can not-insignificantly impact our creativity and inspiration. Nevermind what a specific college or professional sports organization has to say about this; maybe someday they'll start thinking themselves, perhaps with the help of some substances, and realize that maybe the "college entrance exams, program entrance exams, and other educational competitions" are themselves a bit silly in the context of trying to truly find important ideas.
- whalesalad 14y agoLife is a competition. May the best man win. Remember Darwin? The strongest will survive. I'm not going to proactively try and injure someone else or hold someone else back, but you can bet i'll do whatever I possibly can get get the leg up. It's a dog eat dog world. High school prepares you for college, and college ultimately, cough somewhat sarcastic, prepares you for the real world. People are too concerned with playing by the rules in those environments. While we do have rules (read: laws and codes) in the real world, there are also 'no rules'
- zmjones 14y agoNo the "strongest" don't necessarily survive. Evolution is only about individual survival insofar is a longer lifespan may result in more reproduction. The best adapted species in an particular environmental niche will outlast competitors.
- illuminate 14y ago"Remember Darwin? The strongest will survive." "Social Darwinism" has very little to do with Darwin.
- intended 14y agoThis was the most self serving, disingenuous, logically unsound sentence I've read in the past few days. Firstly - "isn't necessarily a competition". A half truth. The rest of the time it is a competiton and is bloody damned important. In classes graded on a curve? Percentile based rankings? What about a country like India or Japan or any country where competitive exams determine your chance to gain an extremely competitive seat? This becomes more pernicious in a country which is trying to build an educated populace. Who is going to have access to these drugs in a third world country? Aside from a few outliers, let's agree that that subset of people with the means and knowledge won't be the chap who doesn't get three square meals a day. it entrenches older families/competitors with money unfairly
- stephengillie 14y agoThe rest of the time it is a competiton and is bloody damned important. Exactly. The academic system has much competition, and some professors teach through competition. Have you ever had a prof who failed the entire class then graded on a curve? So your 32% grade in the class translates to a grade of 3.6? Who is going to have access to these drugs in a third world country? Get ready to see articles about the "Nootropic Divide" between the more and less advantaged people of the world. Better, how long until employers start drug-testing for these, to make sure you're getting a sufficient dose to maximize your performance? I could see EA doing that.
- aaronblohowiak 14y agoYou're conflating Malthus with Darwin.
- danneu 14y agoWhenever the topic of nootropics comes up, especially when comments come critique, people seem to forget about the second most traded commodity in the world. The majority of people reading these very words are doped up on stimulants, probably from the ubiquitous stimulant machine down the hall.
- tryitnow 14y agoYes. Both critics and proponents of nootropics give caffeine short shrift. Critics don't want to admit to chemical enhancement of mental function and proponents are always eager to propagandize the latest fad nootropic. This is true in general. I haven't noticed these behaviors among the brighter critics and supporters (e.g. many comments here on HN are pretty thoughtful).
- loup-vaillant 14y agoEven more unfair than drugs, there are native abilities. Some lucky ones are born athletes, others… well. A good body is a totally unfair advantage. Yet this is not cheating. Similarly some people are just brighter, smarter and less lazy than others. They will breeze through while others must sweat tears and blood if they ever hope to enter college. This is even more unfair, yet it is still not cheating. The reason dope is officially cheating in sports is because they are a breach of explicit rules. It is the same as removing an enemy pawn when no one is looking. You could perfectly have sports where the use of dope were permitted (I'm not sure I would endorse it though: it may have unhealthy consequences —oh, wait it did). Now college entrance exams are about selecting students smart enough to make it through the curriculum, and make a worthy career afterwards. Ideally, you'd want to select those most likely to succeed. My take is this: any way to deceive that predictor is cheating. Anything else is not. By this analysis, nootropics are cheating only to the extent they deceive the predictor. My bet is that someone willing to take such drugs to go to college will probably continue to do so later (permanently or when needed). In this case, the drug doesn't fool the predictor, it actually helps being a little smarter in the long term. What would be cheating would be to take the drugs for a short term benefit, then never or rarely do that again. Finally, this really is not a zero-sum game. Even if only an elite 1% take those drugs, even if it does make things even more unfair than they already are, those people may solve problems faster for the rest of us, so we all benefit. And boy do we have problems that need solving. Starting with Death.[1] (One last detail: nootroopics also have to work and not have nasty side effects. Personally, I'm still a bit afraid.) [1] I work from naturalistic assumptions. For those who believe in an afterlife: imagine your soul being destroyed instead of living happily ever after. I don't want that either.