2 ms·
It's a good post, but I think it sells short the other participants in the discussion. It is entirely the wrong kind of anecdotal evidence, dominated by the le
by nkurz 14y ago
It's a good post, but I think it sells short the other participants in the discussion.
It is entirely the wrong kind of anecdotal evidence, dominated by the least experienced people, under the worst possible circumstances: Pseudo-anonymous debate where you win points for getting people to click a little up-arrow and you have zero emotional investment in what people do with their lives.
Perhaps, but this diverges from the point you started with, which is that many people with whom one disagrees act as they do because they are trying to offer their insights for the benefit others. And for the most part, their intentions _are_ good. It's offensive (and I think wrong) to say that those who dominate are the least experienced or not genuinely concerned by how others will be affected.
I think that bad_user's comment about concentrating on the self and not properly considering the effect on others has merit, and should be discussed. I read Seligman's Learned Optimism based on the recommendations of you and others here, and felt I must be missing something. I went to a half dozen group CBT therapy sessions, and felt that I never connected with it or the group. The sense of "selfishness" I got from it concerned me, and was part of what turned me off.
I think CBT is probably effective for many, and probably could be for me as well if I could get beyond feeling that for it to work I would have to toss aside too many of my moral values. Rather than becoming more perceptive of my thought process, I felt that I would need to desensitize myself to self deceit, and give up my sense of truth. So for better or worse, I stopped going, but continued with the medications.
Still, I appreciated (and still appreciate) your recommendation of the book, and your willingness to share some of the ways it benefited you. I'm glad I read it, as it gives me greater understanding of the thought process behind CBT. Had I started with just the therapy, I probably wouldn't have bothered with the book. And I wouldn't have read it if you hadn't made clear that you were recommending it very strongly.
Which brings us back to the start. I read your post, I evaluate your recommendation, and I choose to act. I presume that you are acting with good will and in good intent. If instead I presume you are acting with ulterior motive and lack of concern for others, I miss the benefit of the discussion. And if you hang back and let the loudest dominant, I miss the benefit of your insight.
Engagement between different parties with different viewpoints, each offering their own solution, is the goal, not something to lament. What works for one doesn't work for all. bad_user may be wrong, but the best we can hope for is that his intents are good. It's when we stop assuming that that the communication and learning stops.
- raganwald 14y agoI may not have expressed myself very well, but what I would hope is that people do as you say and after reading something in a forum, go to more credible sources. That applies to positive recommendations as well as negative criticisms. So if that one comment struck you as having some merit, what I hope is that you say, "Hmm, there's something to look into" rather than "Aha! Obviously it's bad."