3 ms·
Firstly, the authors still found a difference in effect depending on the severity of the depression of the presenting patient. Which is exactly what one would
by jacques_chester 14y ago
Firstly, the authors still found a difference in effect depending on the severity of the depression of the presenting patient.
Which is exactly what one would expect.
Second, this paper is not without its critics (just look in the comments):
"Huedo-Medina et al report that decreasing placebo response with increasing baseline severity of depression is their paper’s “unique contribution”. However, it is clear that this is an artefact of using the standardised mean difference. Analyses using the raw HRSD scores reveal that mean placebo response remains constant with greater response to antidepressant treatment with increasing baseline severity".
Thirdly, you do a disservice to psychologist and psychiatrists if you believe they are further behind on their reading than either you or I.
- lutusp 14y ago> Firstly, the authors still found a difference in effect depending on the severity of the depression of the presenting patient. Yes, and they came to the same conclusion that I stated in my original post -- for the majority of people, antidepression medications do not work. This is a fact that's being kept out of the public's view the the degree possible. But those efforts seem to be eroding: http://www.usatoday.com/news/health/2008-02-26-depression-study_N.htm http://www.usatoday.com/news/health/2008-02-26-depression-st... A quote: "Given these results, there seems little reason to prescribe antidepressant medication to any but the most severely depressed patients unless alternative treatments have failed to provide a benefit." > Second, this paper is not without its critics ... And that is the way it should be. But until the critics perform their own studies of equal quality, the result stands. This is how science works -- authority means nothing -- evidence trumps eminence. > Thirdly, you do a disservice to psychologist and psychiatrists if you believe they are further behind on their reading than either you or I. Believe me when I tell you, based on my voluminous correspondence with psychiatrists and psychologists, they aren't very well-read at all on this topic. That is how they justify writing all those prescriptions for ineffective drugs.