4 ms·
Bill would require camera phones to make a sound
- jws 18y agoI hope someone amends the bill to also include: - a mandatory 'flash', do it after the shot if not artistically desired. - periodic beeps while shooting video (use specific tones, people can then sell software to mask them in the resulting works, mostly.) - periodic beeps while video chatting, the guy on the other end could be recording. - ALL cameras make a sound - Include professional gear, especially the undercover sort. Lots of people have their privacy invaded by PIs and television news folks. - Require a taser sort of effect on the speaker grill while the shutter noise plays to prevent people from masking it. (It will probably also need some sharp spikes to protrude to keep people from simply putting a piece of paper or tape over their finger to avoid the shock.) As long as we are at it, expand the bill to make ALL devices be incapable of illegal use.
- kwamenum86 18y agoOverly broad and probably ineffective. Although I can't imagine a time when this would be harmful any effective click would prove annoying.
- enomar 18y agoGreat. Those wanting to break the law simply need to break their phone's speaker while the rest of us have to live with annoying phones that beep uncontrollably when we want to take pictures.
- iigs 18y agoYeah. Prior to discovering the configuration option buried deep in my phone's menus I was looking for a place to embed a compact slider switch. I have a feeling if something like this were to ever pass that we'd see hacked firmware for common phones ASAP.
- tlrobinson 18y agoWhich brings up an interesting point: would open source firmware/software on camera phones be illegal, since you can trivially modify it to disable the noise?
- cabalamat 18y agoI'm sure there are people who would want to ban open source if they understood the idea. Fortunately, they are mostly too stupid to get it. Just as there are vested interests who would love to go back in time and kill the Internet (e.g. the music industry), but fortunately 15 years ago when the Internet was small enough to kill these vested interests didn't understand its importance.
- rscott 18y agoIt won't go anywhere, don't worry too much.
- thwarted 18y agoBy the time you've heard the click, it's too late.
- patio11 18y agoIt might be too late to stop the pervert from taking the picture, but it is not too late to summon the authorities and prevent him from fleeing. (This is the Japanese use case for this law. I have to assume the American one is similar, right?)
- dimitar 18y agoThe article says that a mandatory "click" is already in place in Japan and I am almost certain that its the same in the EU. I cannot turn off the loud click or turn down its volume on my phone and many of my acquaintances have also tried with no success. While not very nice from a philosophical viewpoint it is actually a good measure. Those phone cameras can get pretty annoying and very disturbing. Now with the clicking sound I can identify the offender and become aware that I had my picture taken. There is a downside, too - when I am in the library or during lectures taking dozens of pictures of some paperwork can be very unpleasant for others. I think the privacy of the individual is a lot more valuable than the "freedom to not make a clicking sound" ;-).
- gravitycop 18y agoI think the privacy of the individual is a lot more valuable Individuals have, or can have, privacy in public?
- dimitar 18y agoIs there a reason there are "you are monitored by CCTV" signs? Do people only take pictures in public?
- gravitycop 18y agoIs there a reason there are "you are monitored by CCTV" signs? CCTV signage is in place to discourage shoplifting. http://www.google.com/search?q=discourage+shoplifting+cctv+signs http://www.google.com/search?q=discourage+shoplifting+cctv+s...
- electromagnetic 18y agoAn individual out in public doesn't necessarily have a right to privacy, however there's been many cases where an individual has a right not to be photographed - in many countries this is ignored for celebrities, however I know France doesn't tolerate it; IIRC no newspaper or magazine in France is allowed to publish unsolicited photographs (taken within France) also I believe paparazzi from other countries can be arrested on re-entry to France if they took a photo in France and left to sell it overseas. Also, there was a recent case of a man being fined £100 back home in the UK. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/scotland/edinburgh_and_east/7651107.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/scotland/edinburgh_and_ea... He took her photo without permission, and in most circumstances it would probably have been a slap on the wrist and told to delete the photo, however she was in a compromised position at the time which is why the police pressed for a fine. I remember reading of a similar case in Canada. A man took a photograph of a girl (IIRC I think she was like 17 and in her bikini at the time) without her permission, she called the police and he was taken in. I believe the police took his cameras memory card as evidence pending trial. I don't think anything was done except the photo was deleted, but I believe the outcome would have been a lot different if he'd known she was 17 when he took the photo. So yes, individuals in public have a right to not be photographed.
- herval 18y agoactually some manufacturers (like Siemens - R.I.P.) already comply with that 'rule' for a while, for that exact reason..
- narag 18y agoI own a Motorola U9 for a month. I've been unable to find out how to disable the click. Next thing is flashing it. I can't stand the very loud noise.
- gaius 18y agoGood. As a photographer I am in two minds about camera phones. On the one hand, putting the tools in the hands of the masses is great. On the other hand, camera phone users are such twats. I do a bit of wedding photography, you scout out the church, sort out your shots (say the bride entering the church with her father) then you come to take the shot and some moron is leaning out into the aisle with his stupid little phone. What, he's not even composing, the shot is going to be shit, and where's it going, onto Facebook or into an album that the bride will show her granddaughter one day? Or you're shooting the formals and in every shot at least one member of the two families is actually looking at some fool trying a camera phone shot instead of into the camera. If every camera phone gave the user a small electric shock with every picture, or would lock up completely for 30 minutes after every shot, that would go a long way. </rant>
- mhb 18y agoMaybe just make the quality of camera phone pictures so crappy that no one will want to look at them. Oh wait.