3 ms·
> You can wish for those jobs to come back all you want. It is not happening in any significant numbers It started happening with batteries and energy infrastr
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> You can wish for those jobs to come back all you want. It is not happening in any significant numbers
It started happening with batteries and energy infrastructure. Then the GOP killed that because its base prefers to own the libs.
- alephnerd 1y agoIMO, the barrier to entry for battery and power systems manufacturing has been Capex moreso than the IP. Innovating new battery chemistries or a new BMS is hard, but cell, module, and pack assembly is fairly straightforward. Basically, my opinion is our blocker in the space wasn't lack of IP or domain knowledge, but the extremely high upfront costs to start, which is what IRA helped remediate. With significant portions of the tech industry, it's the other way around - we may have coders, but we increasingly don't have the domestic domain experience at the entry and mid-level.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> the barrier to entry for battery and power systems manufacturing has been Capex moreso than the IP Yes. The CHIPS Act and IRA provided avenues to that capital, directly and indirectly.
- alephnerd 1y agoAbsolutely - and I'm a big booster of industrial policy a la CHIPS/IRA! But a CHIPS or IRA style policy wouldn't work if trying to bring services or IP-first industries back to the US. In my vertical (cybersecurity/DevSecOps) much of the domain experience has been hollowed out domestically for almost 10-15 years now. If you're offshoring for the sake of R&D and IP generation, cost isn't a significant pressure (eg. Top Cybersecurity talent in Israel can demand US level salaries, and similar talent in India can demand EU level salaries). There's a much larger pipeline and skills problem in several subdomains in the tech industry that are highly underestimated by HNers.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> CHIPS or IRA style policy wouldn't work if trying to bring services or IP-first industries Totally agree.