4 ms·
>If you can't send updated schedules or emergency alerts through the system, I also don't want service started. In the days before systems existed for publishi
by zahlman 1y ago
>If you can't send updated schedules or emergency alerts through the system, I also don't want service started.
In the days before systems existed for publishing such schedules and emergency alerts, should public transit service not have been attempted at all?
> Trains by definition need to share the same tracks with catastrophic consequences for getting it wrong.
Just because it uses the same rail gauge as intercity freight doesn't require it to run on the same set of tracks. But if it did, I assume "local-first" entails other traffic just being excluded when an emergency in the local system necessitates it.
- gjsman-1000 1y agoOur modern transit system has no correlation to the complexity of transit service previously. Enjoy fewer schedules, more delays, and higher costs; pick three. Edit, for the pedantic: There's a huge difference between horizontal complexity (i.e. variety of transit options) and vertical complexity (complexity of a particular option). We have less horizontal complexity than we used to; but vertical complexity of a modern railroad is obscene compared to historical standards. > But if it did, I assume "local-first" entails other traffic just being excluded when an emergency in the local system necessitates it. No dice; as consider just 14 hours ago: https://x.com/SFBARTalert/status/1963772853947355630?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcamp%5Eserp%7Ctwgr%5Etweet https://x.com/SFBARTalert/status/1963772853947355630?ref_src... How does a local-first train safely operate if it could go through a police zone? You need communication, by definition, not local-first.
- MangoToupe 1y agoThere's a fourth factor here: labor costs.
- op00to 1y agoI don’t understand what you’re trying to say. Is it that we have more or less complexity? The public transit system was far more complex in the past. Between trolleys, inter urbans, and passenger trains, we’ve lost a LOT of routes.
- privatelypublic 1y agoTheres things police could/can attach to the rail to signal trains to stop. I think our over reliance on the telecom network has lead to safety issues- mostly in terms of "what to do when the telecom goes down." Because on the whole, its astoundingly reliable.
- tjwebbnorfolk 1y agoI think it's perfectly reasonable for us to have higher standards for quality and safety than we did 100 years ago. > Just because it uses the same rail gauge as intercity freight doesn't require it to run on the same set of tracks Building a replica set of tracks that runs parallel to the current tracks just to avoid sharing doesn't strike me as a good use of anyone's time/money. > "local-first" entails other traffic just being excluded And how are you going to notify them that they are excluded when the network is down?
- wrs 1y agoYou can go down a very deep rabbit hole learning about the history of train signaling. Trains and subways have had centralized signaling for…I’d have to look it up, but 100 years surely? It’s the only way to safely have more than one train running at a time (i.e., sharing the track) with a dense schedule. The “local first” procedure when it fails is to radically reduce service and slow down the trains. Wikipedia has a good survey [0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railway_signalling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railway_signalling
- jsmith45 1y agoBlock based automated signaling can technically be implemented as a primarily local system. Each block needs to know if there is a train in itself block (in which case all block entrance signals must show stop, and approach signals indicate that they can be entered, but the train must be slowing, so it can come to a stop by the block entrance signal). It must also know about a few preceeding blocks for each path leading into it, so as to know which contain trains that might be trying to enter this block, so it can select at most one to be given the proceed signal, and others to be told to brake to stop in time for the entrance signal. While it is nice if it knows the intended routes of each train so it can favor giving the proceed indicator to a train that actually wants to enter it, but if it lacks that information, then giving the indication to a train that will end up using points to take a different path doesn't hurt safety, just efficiency. Of course, centralized signaling is better, allowing for greater efficiency, helps dispatch keep track better track of the trains, makes handling malfunctioning signals a lot safer, among many other benefits. But it doesn't mean local signaling can't be done.
- wrs 1y agoYes, block based signaling is what I interpreted “local first” to mean in this context. It works, but it slows everything way down. I don’t know, but I would imagine, there’s still a block based setup as a failsafe backup in most or all modern rail systems.
- stickfigure 1y agoYeah, we literally invented positive train control because trains crashed too often.
- daveguy 1y agoThe very first transcontinental railroad included telegraph communications infrastructure. [0] The dependence is necessary because it's so critical for safety and scheduling. The US congressional committee that recommended construction of the railroad was called the "Select Committee on the Pacific Railroad and Telegraph". So it seems very early it was decided that no, rail transit systems should not be built without communications/publishing infrastructure. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_transcontinental_railroad https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_transcontinental_railroa...
- jonathanlb 1y ago> Just because it uses the same rail gauge as intercity freight BART has a non-standard rail gauge size that precludes it from interoperability with other rail networks. https://www.bart.gov/news/articles/2022/news20220708-2 https://www.bart.gov/news/articles/2022/news20220708-2
- badc0ffee 1y agoI was going to say, it just happens to be one of the handful of systems in the entire continent that does not use standard gauge. Other ones I'm aware of are Washington DC's metro, and Toronto's subway and streetcars.
- bluGill 1y agoBart is india broad guage - a common enough standed that anyone making train parts will supply what you need. You can's share tracks with other trains but realisticaly you wouldn't do that anyway. If bart isn't running a train on some track it should be closed for maintenance not given to someone else.
- jcranmer 1y ago> Just because it uses the same rail gauge as intercity freight doesn't require it to run on the same set of tracks. We're talking about BART, which uses a track gauge of 5'6" instead of the standard US rail gauge of 4'8.5". They can't run on the same tracks. (Actually, this is generally true even for those systems that do use 4'8.5" gauge track--I suspect that the standard US freight car envelope doesn't actually fit on most subway systems.)
- leeter 1y agoThey would not, the term you're looking for is "Loading Gauge"[1]. The US freight loading gauge is one of the larger ones. That said there are other reasons a subway could end up being subject to Federal Railroad Administration[2] rules. I will note that I'm not an expert on those rules. But, generally passenger rail systems in the US are subject to Positive Train Control[3] or equivalent. It appears BART is actually one of the earliest adopters of Automatic Train Control[4], which appears to be a PTC equivalent. If not more automated. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loading_gauge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loading_gauge [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Railroad_Administration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Railroad_Administratio... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positive_train_control https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positive_train_control [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bay_Area_Rapid_Transit#Automation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bay_Area_Rapid_Transit#Automat...
- reaperducer 1y ago(Actually, this is generally true even for those systems that do use 4'8.5" gauge track--I suspect that the standard US freight car envelope doesn't actually fit on most subway systems.) As a related aside, the Chicago Transit Authority still ran freight on its tracks until not that long ago. Maybe the early 2000's?
- bombcar 1y agoStandard US freight envelope doesn't even fit on the standard US freight line, famously there are tunnels and bridges in the East that prevent Superliner and other double-stack cars from getting into New York and other places. It is certainly possible to send a freight train that will fit in most subway tunnels of the right gauge, but you may need a short locomotive and short cars. (After all, what are the maintenance trains but a form of freight?)