3 ms·
So, how does this relate to PG's article: Black Swan Farming? There is a huge difference in profiting from a stochasitic-but-diversified portfolio with massive
by 001sky 14y ago
So, how does this relate to PG's article: Black Swan Farming? There is a huge difference in profiting from a stochasitic-but-diversified portfolio with massive variance and extrapolating from the outlier data. The properties of the outlier data, by definition, are not charachteristic of the data-set as a whole. The properties of the outlier data are useful for talking about the potential of future outliers and possible portfolio variance.
'The sink or swim strategy was successful for all 1% of the successes'? [1]
Its easy to overgeneralize.
__________
[1] 'The sink or swim strategy was not successful for all 99x1% of the non-successes.'
- JumpCrisscross 14y ago>"The properties of the outlier data, by definition, are not charachteristic of the data-set as a whole" Graham's statement about three-quarters of the value of YC's $10 billion portfolio being comprised of Dropbox and Airbnb counters this. It's the difference between the probability density function and the aggregated cumulative distribution function. This is actually part of the founding logic of modern portfolio theory: let's suppose all start-ups have a 1% chance of making it to a billion and a 99% chance of going bust. From the start-ups' perspectives, the $1 billion exit outcome is an outlier scenario. If I put a few hundred of these guys in a portfolio, however, it would be improbable for not one of them to Instagram. This oversimplifies as it assumes simple distributions and pre-known probability densities, but it illustrates one of the un-intuitive effects of the way variances combine mathematically.
- 001sky 14y agoThe counter-argument is that black swan is not a regular gaussian style outlier from a known distribution. Its better thought of a datapoint from an <Uncertain> process, being mixed into your run of the mill vanilla <stochasitic> one. Thats the issue -- I appreciate your comment making it more clear. So, if we take the black swans and put them into a group, its not clear what we have. Though it seems a stretch that they would be representative of the vanilla process per-se.