4 ms·
This is more an exercise in how conditions as described in the DSM IV can be applied to almost anyone as easily as a horoscope or fortune cookie. A psychology
by stephengillie 14y ago
This is more an exercise in how conditions as described in the DSM IV can be applied to almost anyone as easily as a horoscope or fortune cookie.
A psychology prof once told us that the DSM isn't a diagnostic manual or any sort of medical text -- it's just a reference book so the insurance industry knows how to bill psychological conditions.
- enmaku 14y agoFunny that the "Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders" isn't considered a "Diagnostic Manual" given that a) those words are in the title and b) it's commonly and constantly used by professionals as a manual for diagnosis. It doesn't really matter what your one prof said, it matters how the profession as a whole uses it. I also cited the ICD-10 in the article for several of the disorders, and there absolutely is not any arguing that the ICD-10 is a valid diagnostic tool. Also, while I agree the mis-dignosis is common and many of the elements read like a horoscope/fortune cookie, you can't say that Nite Owl II was a narcissist or that Ozymandius had avoidant personality disorder.
- pinchyfingers 14y agoJust because something bears a title doesn't make it so. Perhaps his professor _was_ accurately describing how the profession as a whole uses the manual. You can diagnosis pretty much anyone with narcissism.
- electromagnetic 14y agoThe ICD-10 is a diagnostic manual, when used by a professional. A professional psychiatrist (by that I mean a non-pill pushing psychiatrist) and psychologists are supposed to take long-term observations of their patients to evaluate the severity of the personality traits. In all of these cases it's the severity not the presence that determines if you have the disorder or not. For those listed in the article, here's my winning score for presence of traits that I'm known to have IRL. The ICD-10 requires at least 4 of the following for an SPD diagnosis: 1 Emotional coldness, detachment or reduced affect. 2 Limited capacity to express either positive or negative emotions towards others. 3 Consistent preference for solitary activities. 4 Very few, if any, close friends or relationships, and a lack of desire for such. 5 Taking pleasure in few, if any, activities. 6 Indifference to social norms and conventions. 7 Preoccupation with fantasy and introspection. The ICD-10 requires at least four of the following for an AvPD diagnosis: 1 Persistent and pervasive feelings of tension and apprehension. 2 Belief that one is socially inept, personally unappealing, or inferior to others. 3 Excessive preoccupation with being criticized or rejected in social situations. 4 Unwillingness to become involved with people unless certain of being liked. 5 Restrictions in lifestyle because of need to have physical security. The ICD-10 requires at least 3 of the following for an APSD diagnosis: 1 Gross and persistent attitude of irresponsibility and disregard for social norms, rules, and obligations. 2 Incapacity to experience guilt or to profit from experience, particularly punishment. 3 Markedly prone to blame others or to offer plausible rationalizations for the behaviour that has brought the person into conflict with society. I'm 1 short on the others except histrionic personality disorder, which I'm at least satisfied I had a zero on.
- brigade 14y agoOne thing that a lot of people forget is the general diagnostic criteria (e.g. http://behavenet.com/personality-disorder http://behavenet.com/personality-disorder) Specifically, one big glaring criteria that most people don't meet is "C. The enduring pattern leads to clinically significant distress or impairment in social, occupational, or other important areas of functioning."
- enmaku 14y agoExactly. We can all find the patterns of personality disorders in ourselves, but diagnostic criteria require WAY more than "you act this way" - your actions actually have to be severely detrimental. Personally I'd say that if your particular behavioral patterns lead to costumed vigilante crime fighting you probably meet criteria C.