3 ms·
HR and legal across the UK are probably updating their company procedures right now to include every imaginable reason they might want to fire someone. That’s
by Aurornis 1y ago
HR and legal across the UK are probably updating their company procedures right now to include every imaginable reason they might want to fire someone.
That’s why I don’t see these rulings as a win for the common employee. The situation now encourages companies to be as broad as possible with their contracts and policies and include so many just-in-case provisions that it starts to get hard for anyone to know and follow all of them.
- ceejayoz 1y agoThey'd best be prepared to enforce it evenly, then, or the next suit is "my boss called me a dickhead 43 times without any consequences, and that's discriminatory".
- Aurornis 1y agoWhich is another loss for the common employee, because now if you mistakenly violate one of those voluminous company policies or you're having a bad day and make a small lapse of judgment, they're going to feel obligated to punish you for it to avoid more legal infractions.
- ceejayoz 1y agoOr, as said rules also apply to the boss, they might feel obligated to be a bit more reasonable. In this case, all they had to do was issue a warning - as they promosed to do in the contract - instead of a summary firing for the first offense. If the behavior reoccurred they'd have been clear.
- wredcoll 1y agoThis is a terribly bad faith argument. We're literally reading an example of someone being protected by laws and your response is "well this is actually bad for them"?
- Twirrim 1y agoBased on conversations with a relative in HR in the UK, usually the company procedures are detailed and cover everything. You just have to follow the procedure. Most of the pain they ever had to deal with has come down to managers etc. acting off the cuff, not following the documented process.
- scott_w 1y ago> HR and legal across the UK are probably updating their company procedures right now to include every imaginable reason they might want to fire someone. No, they aren't because that's not how contracts or the law work in the UK. The court found that the contract enumerated a long list of breaches of contract, of which "swearing at colleagues" was not in that list. This means the court read the list as exhaustive, because it appeared to be exhaustive. If the contract was worded differently, the court may not have used this interpretive rule. If the wording was a little more broad, the court may have worked to determine whether "swearing at your boss" could reasonably fit into the terms.
- Aurornis 1y ago> No, they aren't because that's not how contracts or the law work in the UK. The court found that the contract enumerated a long list of breaches of contract, of which "swearing at colleagues" was not in that list. This means the court read the list as exhaustive, because it appeared to be exhaustive. Yes, and that's why I said HR and Legal are updating their boilerplate to be more exhaustive.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoUK companies are not going to be able to out engineer UK labor protections to arrive at the US' at will experience. Such is the point of labor laws and protections. They can update the procedures, they'll still end up in court or tribunals. This is not the US (thankfully).
- Aurornis 1y agoObviously contracts can't override labor laws I'm saying they're going to update the contracts to match the labor laws. If the labor laws say you have to have fireable offenses explicitly enumerated, contracts will now have a lot of fireable offenses explicitly enumerated. That's not evading the law, that's literally how you comply with the law.
- 1y ago
- tempfile 1y agoDoesn't every win for the common employee encourage companies to be as broad as possible? What would count as a "real win" by your standard?
- tialaramex 1y ago> HR and legal across the UK are probably updating their company procedures right now to include every imaginable reason they might want to fire someone. If you want to fire someone you follow procedure. In this case they didn't follow procedure. This is exactly the sort of situation HR already despairs over. Writing new HR documents can't fix this, the same way that bolding the text "Do not press this button" in the instruction manual will not stop customers who don't read the manual and then press the button from doing so. This also just obviously isn't gross misconduct. So now your rewritten procedures might get you sued which (checks notes) is the opposite of what you wanted.
- KaiserPro 1y ago> broad as possible with their contracts have you read any of your company's policys recently? at one company I could be technically fired for wearing a tracksuit to work. at a FAANG, one that was very famous for upholding "freedom of expression", could fire me for questioning _in private_ the direction of anyone more senior than me. Even if those policies are broad and all encompassing, you still need to demonstrate that they were applied correctly, proportionally and reasonably. You also need to prove that the _policy_ is reasonable as well. for example you _could_ have a policy where you cannot say anything negative. Good luck trying to prove that its legally reasonable (and that it was applied evenly)