4 ms·
Here is another perfect examplee of what's wrong with SCRUM, it creates zealots. When someone starts talking about a need to give good, self-disciplined devs a
by InclinedPlane 14y ago
Here is another perfect examplee of what's wrong with SCRUM, it creates zealots. When someone starts talking about a need to give good, self-disciplined devs a little freedom instead of micromanaging them to death the scrum zombies start shouting about "cowboy programmers". When someone starts talking about long-term or strategic planning they start screaming about "waterfall".
The truth is that there is a lot of evidence from the field that having good developers and zero formal process is actually fairly workable, and often produces results. It's typically not the best system, but it's a strong antidote to the poisonous ideas of SCRUM, which holds that constant micromanaging at every level is strictly necessary otherwise puppies will die.
There are good elements within agile, such as iterative development, continuous integration, etc. but if you just choke down a whole ideology without exercising any degree of critical thought then you're going to make a lot of people miserable.
- zwieback 14y agoGood developers+zero formal process only works to a certain scale, though. I think that's where scrum might have a place, just enough process to keep things from going off the rails when the team is too big to self-organize over a long period of time. Agree about the danger of zealotry though. Also, the vocabulary is just so ridiculous - I have to mentally think "black dog grooming" when I say "backlog grooming" just to keep my self-respect.
- eevilspock 14y agoIt also depends on the nature of the work. Is it more mechanical, a more-or-less straightforward implementation of a spec? Or does it require real creativity, invention, non-linear thinking? Anyone who truly understands the creative process knows you have to give it freedom. Scrum might have valuable in big hierarchical companies or when there are many average-talent programmers, but there's no way I'd foist it on a team of smart developers much less and early stage startup.
- brazzy 14y agoScrum is pretty much exactly the opposite of what you apparently think it is. Is is ALL ABOUT giving the developers freedom and and inteded exactly for projects that require creativity and don't have a spect to implement straightforwardly.
- adrianhoward 14y agoThe truth is that there is a lot of evidence from the field that having good developers and zero formal process is actually fairly workable, and often produces results. For certain kind of organisations yes. Take a look at the research Alistair Cockburn did and his various Crystal [colourname] methodologies. http://alistair.cockburn.us/Crystal+methodologies http://alistair.cockburn.us/Crystal+methodologies It's typically not the best system, but it's a strong antidote to the poisonous ideas of SCRUM, which holds that constant micromanaging at every level is strictly necessary otherwise puppies will die. If you've got a team claiming their doing Scrum where you see constant micromanaging - that team is not doing Scrum. At the very core of Scrum is the idea that the team organise their own work (within the very few practices that Scrum enforces). (Obniggle: Scrum is not an acronym you don't need to SHOUT :-)
- alphadogg 14y agoIronically, SCRUM creates a sort of anti-zealot too. The kind that compares no SCRUM as giving "good, self-disciplined devs a little freedom" and having SCRUM as equivalent to "micromanaging them to death the scrum zombies". SCRUM has basic principles that I don't think are egregious to any dev. Mind you, there's a million and one ways to mis-apply them, like patterns, frameworks and other things devs take for granted.
- brazzy 14y agoYou obviously have no idea whatsoever what you are talking about. Please actually do some reading about what SCRUM is before you spread this kind of FUD.