4 ms·
America Needs Tough Grading
- tupac_speedrap 1y agoParents won't allow tough grading lets be honest, they just like how it sounds on paper. There's far too many kids nowadays with parents who think they can do no wrong terrorising classrooms and sapping attention from students who actually put the effort in but if you actually contact their parents and tell them maybe their kid shouldn't assault other people or put some more effort in to get better grades they enter this weird denial state and lash out and their kid keeps up the bad behaviour.
- garciasn 1y agohttps://archive.is/YmsDf https://archive.is/YmsDf -- I attended Undergrad from 1997 to 2001 and I distinctly remember the first paper I received from a new Associate Professor in my major (History) that was a C-. I argued that it would have been an A-level grade in any other professor's class; this new professor told me, in no uncertain terms, that it was most definitely a C- grade and I needed to do better. I did and it made me a better researcher and eventually writer. I finished that course with a hard-earned B+ and I felt better about myself and my abilities thereafter. As a D1 athlete, I had clear goals and expectations set for me by those who I was against and whom came before me. This was the first time in my academic career where I felt I had received a challenge and clear guidelines on how to improve; something I felt helped me achieve better outcomes. Education is not intended to be a breeze; it's intended to be a challenge to help you stretch and grow. Just because you and/or your family is spending tens of thousands a semester does not give anyone the right to skate by with the bare minimum effort applied. I have high expectations for my children academically. My undergrad and graduate degrees were paid for by others (athletics and my employer) alongside of my own work in both. I want my children to grow up and be successful and they will not be if I smooth the road for them in unfair ways. I explain that, in life, they will face uncertain and likely unfair challenges from external forces and they need to not only stretch and grow in their knowledgebase to challenge these forces, but they should also learn to navigate them with grace--an academic exercise in and of itself.
- aredox 1y agoAbsolutely tone deaf article when the whole US Presidency, half of Congress and half of Senate are promoting incompetence and punishing any experience. What is the goal of "tough grading" when they, and a majority of the population, actively despise any kind of expertise?
- tuckerman 1y agoI don't disagree about the problems in government but I don't think we need to look through that lens all the time. Grade inflation and an environment that is unwilling to challenge our children can be a problem even if bad things are going on elsewhere. One could argue that a system that encourages kids to work hard, face challenges, and value deep thought might make the population more resilient against anti-intellectualism.
- aredox 1y ago>I don't think we need to look through that lens all the time. You don't think so, but kids aren't stupid and see what's going on.
- sciencesama 1y agoWell if we post the Ten Commandments in our schools, wouldn’t that make us wiser and smarter ?
- garciasn 1y agoNo; plus, it's illegal under state and church separation in the United States. Also, this isn't 500 BCE; we live in 2025. Humanity no longer needs to learn the basics of common decency, morality, and legality through the mythical threat of a being(s) in the sky helping or hurting an eternal life that simply does not exist after death.
- aredox 1y ago>it's illegal under state and church separation in the United States. Try to keep up with reality. It is on display right now, and there is reason to think the Supreme Court will allow it. https://www.ksat.com/news/local/2025/09/02/ten-commandments-posters-on-display-across-texas-public-school-classrooms/ https://www.ksat.com/news/local/2025/09/02/ten-commandments-... https://www.scotusblog.com/2025/07/the-ten-commandments-return-to-classrooms-what-will-the-supreme-court-do/ https://www.scotusblog.com/2025/07/the-ten-commandments-retu...
- jzebedee 1y agohttps://archive.is/YmsDf https://archive.is/YmsDf
- anthem2025 1y agoSo already overburdened teachers can have to deal with flunking half the class and parents getting mad at them for it?
- vlark 1y agoThis article references how grade inflation has boomed since 2013 (when the authors were in school). Here's an article from 2013 bemoaning grade inflation: https://www.usnews.com/opinion/blogs/economic-intelligence/2013/12/26/why-college-grade-inflation-is-a-real-problem-and-how-to-fix-it https://www.usnews.com/opinion/blogs/economic-intelligence/2... Here's a whole book about the issue, published in 2003: https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/b97309 https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/b97309 And here's one from 1991: https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/jep.5.1.159 https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/jep.5.1.159 Folks, this is an annual grouching point among folks who care about or work in academia. Nothing to see here. -- Edited to add that I am a community college English professor. Most people pass my class because the college has set the final drop date one month before the end of the semester, so students have plenty of time to avoid a bad final grade.
- djoldman 1y agoThis is quite the piece. One section that stands out is: > It’s no coincidence that as grades have gone up, civic friendship between people with different views and backgrounds has gone down, both on campuses and in the nation at large. Students are so confident in their beliefs that they verbally assault professors and guest lecturers and physically assault classmates and janitorial staff. A dose of humility is needed, and it can start in the classroom. I'm not convinced that grade inflation is causing verbal and physical assaults.
- cafard 1y ago>> civic friendship between people with different views and backgrounds has gone down, both on campuses and in the nation at large. Views, I don't know. Backgrounds I'd attribute to the cost of college significantly outrunning inflation.
- otterley 1y agoSpeaking of tough grading, did anyone catch the misspelling of "education" in the article slug? https://www.wsj.com/opinion/america-needs-tough-grading-educaiton-learning-students-98fa87d5 https://www.wsj.com/opinion/america-needs-tough-grading-educ...
- castillar76 1y agosigh Is it that time of the year again that we start publishing these? Boy, how time flies... Too frequently, what people (and clearly the author of this piece) mean when they say "tougher grading" is just a return to forcible bell-curve application and faculty who take out their personal insecurities and annoyance over being required to teach classes on their students. That's not making academics more challenging, it's just torturing statistics and arbitrarily modifying the race-course in order to satisfy other agendas. If you have a good teacher and a good course and more than half the class does well, you should consider making the next iteration more challenging, but you should not feel obliged to fail 10% of them because "there's always a bell-curve", nor should you be using grading as a means to "humble" your students. I emphasized the word "consider" up there because not every course needs to be a slog up Everest, either — an "intro to X" course might well be a class in which many people do well. Some percentage of them will be people looking to make that their major, so they'll already know enough to be ahead of the curve in an "intro" course. Others will be bright people who learn well and adapt to the material. As someone who teaches classes regularly at the college/grad-school level, I try to make the content interesting and challenging, but if most of my students turn in work that exceeds standards and are coming out with a good understanding of the content, I feel like I've accomplished my goals — academia is supposed to be about learning after all, and they're displaying that they've correctly learned the content I wanted to communicate to them. I do spend time trying to re-work the course regularly (something I'm forced to do much more since the explosion of sites like Chegg...), but past a certain point if something is clearly working, why am I obliged to break it?
- ahazred8ta 1y agoTerminology -- 'grading on a curve' and bell curve are two different unrelated things. A grading modification curve is not a bell curve. But the rest of your argument makes sense.
- electric_muse 1y ago[flagged]
- scrubs 1y agoIn short one anthem for the US ought to be: competence is back. Know how matters. Like others report uni profs made me better. Wherever my English prof is at ... thanks a ton! Leadership, caring, and know how. You were marvelous.