5 ms·
Anti-establishment versus authoritarian populists and support for the strongman
- dash2 1y agoBeware of Frontiers In... journals. They do not have a great reputation.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Beware of Frontiers In... journals. They do not have a great reputation Could you substantiate that? The abstract looks compelling, but I don't want to waste time if this is a trash journal.
- FreakLegion 1y agoThey're the ones who published the bizarre AI-generated rat last year: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39391034 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39391034 That was my first encounter with Frontiers Media, but they have a...history: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frontiers_Media#Controversies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frontiers_Media#Controversies
- kelseyfrog 1y agoIn this house, our epistemic standard reflects the content of the message, not who delivered it.
- dash2 1y agoUnless you're an expert in the field, you are going to partially rely on how much you trust the messenger, for any reasonably complex message.
- FreakLegion 1y agoEven if you're an expert, you can't read every paper in every journal. There aren't enough hours in the day. That was the context of JumpCrisscross's original question. You could say kelseyfrog's response is stuck in a local optimum, or that it's just part of a different conversation altogether.
- darth_avocado 1y agoCompletely opinionated take: all forms of populism is directly correlated to levels of inequality of wealth in the economy and level of standard of living of the bottom 50%. Everything else is just manifestations of frustration with one’s own situation.
- aredox 1y agoAnd at the same time populism worsens inequality and isn't punished for it (it gets away with making the elections just a little bit "unfair", it doesn't need full totalitarian control over them and can keep the opposition alive on not-too-tight a leash). Which is the most terrifying thing: it is a self-renforcing loop.
- lazyeye 1y agoSeems like its been a "self-reinforcing loop" for decades... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_inequality_in_the_United_States https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_inequality_in_the_Uni...
- mindslight 1y agoCorollary to that though: is it actual wealth inequality, or the perception of wealth inequality?
- darth_avocado 1y agoActual inequality
- mindslight 1y agoMy comment wasn't really fleshed out, but my point is that it has to be something besides actual inequality because people can't perceive inequality directly. They can perceive their purchasing power and labor-selling power going down (could be all of society rather than equality). They can perceive inequality through trusted news media (NSA/security definition of can break you. I certainly do not mean trustworthy). I am not trying to deny inequality as a driving factor. I do agree that inequality has been going up, I do agree that inequality is a society-destroying problem, and I do agree that this has created a fertile ground for the destructionist movement. I just think there needs to be a little more to the theory for it to make sense.
- pessimizer 1y agoBrain dead garbage that could have been generated by AI, one of a vast literature that attempts to make popular sovereignty seem like a mental illness rather than the only non-supernatural justification for government at all. They selected a few strongmen, as designated by the CIA, to illustrate their points: Italy, Hungary, Poland, Spain, Brazil, and Argentina. Only while the CIA disapproves of them, though. The CIA always changes their minds about them at exactly the same time they make a break with their past and announce that their country is open for foreign investment. Al Qaeda leaders in expensive suits. Anti-establishment populists, the "good" kind, are represented by the organizations that employ people to write garbage like this, and whose primary messaging is that power can be wielded by loving and believing hard enough, and that everyone who does anything to threaten any institution is completely dominated and motivated by hate, cynicism, or ambition. We don't hate them, we love them, so to help them they should be under mandatory therapy; and to protect us, maybe that therapy should be done in a prison.
- zpeti 1y agoCan someone explain to me how populism is different to democracy? I know what the mainstream answer to this is, but fundamentally, if you are pro democracy, how can you be against the choice of the majority of the people?
- lazyeye 1y agoPopulism is a democratic mandate you don't like. And I guess it's also where a politicians lies are more simple, direct which apparently is MUCH WORSE than the more sophisticated, poll-driven lies of the establishment politician's PR hacks.
- popra 1y agoWhat if the choice of the majority of the people is anti-democratic? It would seem that that would make you anti-democratic while trying to be pro democracy.
- randomNumber7 1y agoThere is a great article of german philosopher Leonard Nelson that discusses this (and other) weaknesses of democracy. He was thrown out of the SPD for it in s.th. like the 1920s
- matrix87 1y ago> What if the choice of the majority of the people is anti-democratic? Isn't the majority choice a priori democratic? Unless you're saying the majority is saying "let's throw away voting and go back to monarchy"... which they aren't, systemic change on that level is usually a highly niche opinion I'm sensing some doublethink here
- popra 1y ago"which they aren't" ... OK, you seem oddly confused about what's actually being discussed. Let me help: here's a passage from the paper itself "On one hand, some scholars argue that populism is inherently illiberal [...]. Populist movements embrace majoritarian politics and seek to suppress opposition, often through a charismatic strongman who pledges to dismantle institutional constraints in the name of executing the people’s will. Under this interpretation, populism becomes synonymous with authoritarianism." So while you clearly don't perceive populism as anti-democratic ... because you're immune to "doublethink", or something — others, including some of the people actually cited in the paper clearly do. Also, famously: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/think/article/abs/poppers-paradox-of-democracy/F99CA4DC88347BC0E660026B303C3224 https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/think/article/abs/po... And oh BTW, no. The majority choice is not automatically a priori democratic, unless by "democratic" you mean the literal Greek etymology of the word and not its actual meaning: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberal_democracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberal_democracy
- throwaway81523 1y agoArticle doesn't say whether Franklin D Roosevelt was populist, and if so, which variety.
- matrix87 1y ago> An alternative interpretation, which we advance in this analysis, is that populism enables the expression (and execution) of authoritarian impulses within a democratic system. If this interpretation holds, then merely addressing economic inequalities or enhancing political representation through mechanisms such as referendums will be insufficient to mitigate underlying authoritarian impulses. Governments will need to proactively reinforce existing democratic safeguards before populist actors assume power. I.e. the solution to democracy is getting rid of democracy. More doublethink I guess