4 ms·
"It helps tell these apps apart (“Find My Friends? Oh, right, the one with leather!”). It makes the apps more approachable (“Hmm, this looks just like my real-
by majormajor 14y ago
"It helps tell these apps apart (“Find My Friends? Oh, right, the one with leather!”).
It makes the apps more approachable (“Hmm, this looks just like my real-world address book, it can’t be much harder to use”)."
Honest question: are these two things really issues? I've just never encountered the level of non-technical user that would be lost but for those particular touches. And I know there's a huge amount of selection bias in there, but I think usability/distinctiveness can be achieved without kitschy textures or creating your own set of UI elements.
If anyone has more links on it actually helping new users, I'd love to see them. The reasons just sound like post-hoc rationalizations to me. Especially because realistic/skeuomorphic/what-have-you skins have gone in and out of fashion over the years and I don't recall complaints that, say, iTunes looked less "just like" a CD player than the old System 7.5 CD player app.
(And honestly, in the few minutes I played with the Lion Address Book out of curiosity, I felt like I was missing something big about how it worked. That one in particular seems like a case of things getting more confusing because it presents a physical metaphor that doesn't really fit the digital version.)
- RickHull 14y ago> I've just never encountered the level of non-technical user that would be lost but for those particular touches. They say that economics happens at the margins. In other words, changing the price of a sandwich from $3.40 to $3.25 isn't going to make you buy 10% more of them. But in the population of consumers, there is a chunk that are on the margin that will be totally converted, and that results in a 10% volume increase in aggregate. Something similar may be going on here. Make a design tradeoff (using leather) in order to get a 10% user benefit, even if 50% of your users get no benefit.
- jarek 14y ago> are these two things really issues? Of course. Real people don't say "Calendar app? Oh, right, the one with the calendar sheet," or "Address book? Oh, right, the one with the people's contact info in it!". This is why we need on-screen leather.
- bergie 14y agoIt makes the apps more approachable (“Hmm, this looks just like my real-world address book, it can’t be much harder to use”)." That was the argument behind Microsoft's acclaimed skeuomorphic Post-PC platform, Bob: http://www.bentuser.com/article.aspx?ID=327&page=3 http://www.bentuser.com/article.aspx?ID=327&page=3 http://www.bentuser.com/article.aspx?ID=327&page=4 http://www.bentuser.com/article.aspx?ID=327&page=4 iOS hasn't quite gone as far as introduce Clippy, but of course Siri could be taken to that direction...
- lmm 14y agoI was amazed when I showed my dad and one of his friends the kindle app on my transformer. "Can I turn the page?" "Sure, tap the margin" taps the margin, and the kindle app does its slide animation to go to the next page "That's not what I want! I want to see the page turning like on my ipad!"
- gurkendoktor 14y ago> are these two things really issues? Yes - every app is light grey on grey on dark grey in OS X (Mountain) Lion. The theming of some apps makes it easier to spot them in Mission Control. Though I'd rather have 10.6 back where windows weren't all gray to begin with.