6 ms·

Discord is just absolutely worthless for this. Any question that gets asked gets buried in days if not hours. It pretty much guarantees the same basic garbage g

by roblh 1y ago

Discord is just absolutely worthless for this. Any question that gets asked gets buried in days if not hours. It pretty much guarantees the same basic garbage gets repeated over and over and over forever. Basically the exact opposite of stack overflow.

natebc 1y ago
Inevitably too you'll get someone scolding you to "check the pins" which you then do and get introduced to that hellish nightmare. Discord is great for chatting with your friends, gaming, etc. but man it's a horrible knowledge repository.
- verdverm 1y ago
  > horrible knowledge repository I don't disagree, but that does not change the fact that people have moved from sites like SO to Discord for this purpose. There are Q&A channels, so not everything is chat, but Discord search is abysmal Slack is another place where former SO content / answers are happening. Discourse too. The tl;dr is that it has become more fragmented, for better or worse SO has a related problem to Reddit. Some mods high on their status and power
  - Den_VR 1y ago
    The move has happened because SEO rotted out The Internet to the point there’s been a “theory” that the Internet died a decade ago. If the current Internet is unsustainable under new technology trends then the new parts need to and will evolve to thrive inside the new ecosystem.
- Gud 1y ago
  Frankly it’s not really great even for that, but they have captured the audience and now we are stuck with it. Every time I boot into Manjaro to do some gaming, almost always there’s a new update for Discordavailable and guess what? The updates to Manjaro are always lagging behind a few days to a week, and Discord won’t run with a slightly out of date client. The only way to get is working is using the snap, and who doesn’t want use some 3rd party package manager just to send some kbit/s voice data? Additionally the interface sucks and is really bloated
- BoredPositron 1y ago
  That's why I still prefer IRC without retention there is more freedom for discussion.
verdverm 1y ago
There are question/answer channels, not everything is chat on Discord
- blharr 1y ago
  Those are not easily searchable either
  - verdverm 1y ago
    Oh I know, it's one of my top 3 complaints. Information gardening is hard
ddingus 1y ago
I hate that about Discord. It is a fun comms application, but it is severely lacking as a community. Once, before I realized this, I recommended users of a forum use Discord. The impact was severe and fortunately brief. We all realized we would not be leaving the usual, often high value info for others, and ourselves to benefit from in the future. We unwound that mess and now carry on in the usual way. Discord has carved out a huge chunk of discussion people will wish was available in the future.
- stevage 1y ago
  It depends very much on the discord. I'm in several discords which are excellent communities. They're really good places to hang out, get to know people interested in the same hobby, build a subculture etc. I haven't really tried one as a QA or knowledge sharing site, perhaps they're much less good at that.
  - ddingus 1y ago
    They can be excellent, but only in the moment. The excellent communities I have been a part of can be searched. People can read it and learn. The Discord ones, unless they publish to a wiki or something, just don't exist.
    - stevage 1y ago
      Interesting point. The main one I'm part of started out as a wiki and is now both. The wiki is kind of the long term memory of the community, but it's so painful to have conversations there.

by roblh 1y ago

natebc 1y ago

Inevitably too you'll get someone scolding you to "check the pins" which you then do and get introduced to that hellish nightmare. Discord is great for chatting with your friends, gaming, etc. but man it's a horrible knowledge repository.

verdverm 1y ago
> horrible knowledge repository I don't disagree, but that does not change the fact that people have moved from sites like SO to Discord for this purpose. There are Q&A channels, so not everything is chat, but Discord search is abysmal Slack is another place where former SO content / answers are happening. Discourse too. The tl;dr is that it has become more fragmented, for better or worse SO has a related problem to Reddit. Some mods high on their status and power
- Den_VR 1y ago
  The move has happened because SEO rotted out The Internet to the point there’s been a “theory” that the Internet died a decade ago. If the current Internet is unsustainable under new technology trends then the new parts need to and will evolve to thrive inside the new ecosystem.
Gud 1y ago
Frankly it’s not really great even for that, but they have captured the audience and now we are stuck with it. Every time I boot into Manjaro to do some gaming, almost always there’s a new update for Discordavailable and guess what? The updates to Manjaro are always lagging behind a few days to a week, and Discord won’t run with a slightly out of date client. The only way to get is working is using the snap, and who doesn’t want use some 3rd party package manager just to send some kbit/s voice data? Additionally the interface sucks and is really bloated
BoredPositron 1y ago
That's why I still prefer IRC without retention there is more freedom for discussion.

verdverm 1y ago

There are question/answer channels, not everything is chat on Discord

blharr 1y ago
Those are not easily searchable either
- verdverm 1y ago
  Oh I know, it's one of my top 3 complaints. Information gardening is hard

ddingus 1y ago

I hate that about Discord. It is a fun comms application, but it is severely lacking as a community. Once, before I realized this, I recommended users of a forum use Discord. The impact was severe and fortunately brief. We all realized we would not be leaving the usual, often high value info for others, and ourselves to benefit from in the future. We unwound that mess and now carry on in the usual way. Discord has carved out a huge chunk of discussion people will wish was available in the future.

stevage 1y ago
It depends very much on the discord. I'm in several discords which are excellent communities. They're really good places to hang out, get to know people interested in the same hobby, build a subculture etc. I haven't really tried one as a QA or knowledge sharing site, perhaps they're much less good at that.
- ddingus 1y ago
  They can be excellent, but only in the moment. The excellent communities I have been a part of can be searched. People can read it and learn. The Discord ones, unless they publish to a wiki or something, just don't exist.
  - stevage 1y ago
    Interesting point. The main one I'm part of started out as a wiki and is now both. The wiki is kind of the long term memory of the community, but it's so painful to have conversations there.