5 ms·
These contraptions are illegal to use in public and if they become popular the laws against them will be enforced immediately, because they're incredibly danger
by jdietrich 14y ago
These contraptions are illegal to use in public and if they become popular the laws against them will be enforced immediately, because they're incredibly dangerous.
It is impossible to provide effective braking on a skateboard. The rider has absolutely no means of impeding their forward movement, so even if the board has effective brakes it's just going to throw them off. This is a minor problem if you're rolling around a skatepark, but it's a Big Fucking Deal if you're commuting in traffic.
It might be conceivable to overlook this failing if it weren't for the fact that tiny unsuspended wheels have almost no capacity to absorb bumps and road defects. Anyone who skated as a teenager will remember being thrown to the ground by a small piece of gravel stopping the wheel.
Add 2000w of tractive power and city traffic and you've got a recipe for disaster. Someone is going to die, their family will sue and they will quite rightly win enough money to bankrupt a small company. Boosted Boards are marketing their device as a vehicle and advertising it's suitability as a means of transport, which completely obliterates any defence they might have had. The laws against unlicensed motor vehicles will be enforced and the police will start confiscating them on sight. The electric skateboard returns to it's rightful place in the gimmick section of a sporting goods store, next to the mini-scooters and the moon shoes.
The bicycle has been a safe, practical and sustainable means of transport for over a century. Modern bicycles are lightweight, efficient and have excellent ride quality and braking. Short-range urban transport is a solved problem in all but marketing - Americans remain inexplicably certain that cycling is not for them.
- locnji9308tfo 14y agoGet off my Lawn!
- guelo 14y agoOver the years I have seen all kinds of contraptions used by SF SOMA commuters[1] including plenty of flimsy electric scooters and skateboards. It's possible that it happens but I haven't heard of any deaths or seen cops hassle anyone. My objection to this business would just be that their marketing is probably overselling the idea a bit, but that's par for the course. [1] SF SOMA commuters seems to be the perfect market for this kind of thing since there are a lot of younger well-paid workers traveling 1 to 2 miles from a train stop, and the weather is nice for a lot of the year.
- mbreese 14y agoI haven't heard of any deaths or seen cops hassle anyone It's a matter of probabilities. The probability may be pretty high for lethal accidents, but the number of people currently riding them is pretty low. Additionally, those that do ride them are probably pretty skilled, since there isn't (currently) a mass market way to get one of these boards. And since the people riding them generally aren't a problem, cops have no incentive to really enforce existing law. Now fast forward a bit when this board comes out. Now we have the potential for many times more people on electric boards, which are likely very over-powered. The already higher probability of accidents, multiplied by an increased user base means that there is more potential for a lethal event. And as soon as this thing gets popular, existing laws will be enforced. I'm all for options in urban commuting, but I see lots of problems for this one. Who knows, maybe they figured out a way to make it controllable enough to make it safe. If that's the case, then they might have a shot at getting it approved under a new law. But that will take time to determine.
- GuiA 14y ago>Short-range urban transport is a solved problem in all but marketing - Americans remain inexplicably certain that cycling is not for them. As someone who has both biked and longboarded to work/local grocery stores/etc., I infinitely prefer longboards (in fact I don't even own a bike anymore). Much lighter, easier to carry around (if you have a backpack that can accomodate it, then it's ideal), you don't have to find a place to lock them when you enter buildings (and fear getting it stolen), much easier to carry in public transportation (the Caltrain bike car at peak hours is complete chaos— and are you even allowed to carry a bike in the MUNI/Bart?), and so on. I've seen some people with foldable bikes, not sure if those solve all of those problems. You do raise valid points wrt the riskiness of the device, but I still think that there's progress to be made in short range urban transportation.
- bmj 14y agoI've seriously considered using a longboard and public transportation as a replacement for my bicycle. Sadly, the geography here in Pittsburgh is rather hilly, so a skateboard isn't practical unless you're commuting within one of the "plateaus." Still, for flatter locales, I could see longboards being viable modes of transportation.
- dreeves 14y agoWith the caveat that I'm not a skateboarder (I inline-skate), I don't think your assessment of the braking is right. As the brakes engage you shift your center of gravity back and you end up with, I reckon, even more stopping power than a bike, since you have more rubber-to-road surface area. The same applies to the "tiny rock pitches you forward" argument, which I can speak to from experience. On inline skates I can plow through grass, gravel, potholes, anything, by shifting my weight back as I go over it. If something in the road catches you by surprise that's another story. EDIT: For the rest of my counterargument, I turn to xkcd: http://xkcd.com/139/ http://xkcd.com/139/ http://xkcd.com/409/ http://xkcd.com/409/
- mbreese 14y agoIt's a bit ironic that the last comic ends up with the electric longboard in an accident.
- saidajigumi 14y agoAs another (rather skilled) inline skater, I'll second the ideas in the above post. When I was a newb, rocks were Teh Evil. Now rocks just spit away, if I don't just avoid 'em in the first place. Physical skills have a learning curve. Whether riding a bike or driving a car, some significant skills acquisition is needed before safe use. For cycling, first there's existing cultural folk knowledge on learning to ride a bike (e.g. what you learned as a kid). If you want to be a properly skilled commuter, then you'll really want to brush up on additional skills ala Effective Cycling or a similar program. I don't see this longboard as being particularly different from either cycling or driving, except that it's new. Living in a very hilly part of the USA, I love that they've designed for that from the get-go.
- wheels 14y ago> If something in the road catches you by surprise that's another story. One major problem there: sidewalk construction isn't sign-posted. I ended up in the hospital because a two foot section of the sidewalk on my work-route had been replaced by sand. That was long enough for my roller-blades to stop and my face to keep going, neatly landing a couple feet after the concrete picked back up. After four broken bones and a dozen or so stitches from roller blading and cycling accidents, I've decided to stick to walking and public transit.
- nostromo 14y ago"More than 49,000 pedalcyclists have died in traffic crashes in the United States since 1932 — the first year in which estimates of pedalcyclist fatalities were recorded. In 2005, 784 pedalcyclists were killed and an additional 45,000 were injured in traffic crashes." http://www-nrd.nhtsa.dot.gov/Pubs/810617.pdf http://www-nrd.nhtsa.dot.gov/Pubs/810617.pdf That's a huge number. By one source cyclists are 10x more likely to die per each mile traveled than motorists. Should bike makers be "rightly" sued out of existence? Should we ban bikes completely?
- tomflack 14y agoWhat a ridiculous comparison. As anyone who has skateboarded ever in their life knows, a bicycle is a thousand times safer and easier to control. Why don't you address the parent's points - that it is impossible to provide safe and effective braking on a skateboard. It's impossible to prove, but replace bicycles with skateboards and the fatality rate would shoot up.
- stickfigure 14y agoThis product is unlikely to ever replace bicycles. It will always require significantly more skill and practice to ride a skateboard - powered or not. However, that's an unnecessary measure of success. The board just has to find a big enough customer base to be profitable. There's room in the world for many different kinds of transportation. As for legality - certainly there are concerns, but unlike the segway, this board is subtle enough to fly under the radar for a while.
- tomflack 14y agoI wasn't suggesting it was to replace bicycles, just pointing out the absurdity of the parent's comparison to bicycle fatalities.
- hollerith 14y agoSounds like you've never ridden a skateboard or done so for only a very short time.
- firefoxman1 14y agoThat's my guess. You just plant one foot on the back, lean backward and Scraaape you're stopped.
- technosex 14y agoThere is no tail on this longboard, so that is impossible.
- firefoxman1 14y agoThat's true for this board, but I was responding to the general statement: > It is impossible to provide effective braking on a skateboard.
- nodata 14y agoWasn't the context "unexpected braking"?
- jeremyarussell 14y agoWhen a pebble hits underneath my skateboard the reason the skateboard stops and I continue is because ME moving was why the skateboard was moving. In the case of a powered wheel I'll hit the pebble and keep going and keep going, sense the wheel itself is still turning. I repeat, the wheel is turning, not being turned by inertia and friction. As for the breaking, I can train myself to lean back when I hit the break, and lean forward when I hit the accelerator. It's not that hard. PS: I would hope to Jebus that someone would be wearing a helmet and other protective gear with this.
- johnyzee 14y agoThis is correct. Pebbles, cracks, small sticks etc. are not a problem for these boards. I mostly credited the bigger wheels, but as you said it is of course because the wheels are powered. A high enough ledge will stop you dead though (hopefully not literally), I have been sent flying by roadwork a few times. Smaller ledges can be 'jumped' by just shifting weight.
- brc 14y agoThe part about braking just isn't true. Sure, there is a stopping limit for any braked device - a bicycle cannot stop any faster than it's wheels can hold friction. I've crashed bikes several times from emergency stops (bikes don't have abs). You can stop any type of board-device and stay on, as long as the friction between the board and the rider is greater than the wheels and the road. You don't automatically flip off the end of a board while braking any more than you flip over the handlebars on a bike - that's because you adjust your position when braking, and more so when braking hard.
- tomflack 14y ago"A bicycle cannot stop any faster than it's wheels can hold friction." Nothing can stop faster than "it's wheels can hold friction". But on a bicycle when you brake hard then momentum is transferred on to the front wheel, which is typically ahead of where the bulk of the weight (the rider) is situated. "You can stop any type of board-device and stay on, as long as the friction between the board and the rider is greater than the wheels and the road." On a skateboard, the front wheel is MUCH closer to the center and the centre of gravity is MUCH higher. You'll be flung off if you stop as fast as a bicycle with properly maintained brakes can safely.
- johnyzee 14y agoIt's really not that difficult - you shift your weight all the way back, flex the rear knee into a very low stance with the front leg 'pushing back' against the deceleration. With proper technique you can brake almost as well as a bike.
- tomflack 14y agoSimply incorrect that you can get bike like braking safely, even using the described technique. Edit: I really want to prove this, but the only way I can think of to do it is you buy one of these for $1200, I buy a bike for $1200 and we spend $1200 in airfares to meet somewhere and try it out. Perhaps someone with physics qualifications can weigh in?
- nikatwork 14y ago>Americans remain inexplicably certain that cycling is not for them. You seem to take this product as a personal attack on cyclists. The more unconventional vehicles on the road, the better for everyone. Longboarders have been commuting at high speed in traffic for decades, this is no different.
- christiangenco 14y agoOne more counterpoint to the "no brakes" argument: Power and braking, even on hills We can electronically limit the top speed without sacrificing the power you need to tackle hills. Steep San Francisco hills become easy to climb. And on top of that, we've added regenerative braking, accomplished using the motors. That means it's easy to learn, easy to maneuver, and easy to control your speed, all while recharging the battery. ... How it works You start with a handheld remote with throttle and braking control and a battery gauge readout
- 001sky 14y agoThe "inadvertant" breaking is still a problem--From the post you are replying to: It might be conceivable to overlook this failing if it weren't for the fact that tiny unsuspended wheels have almost no capacity to absorb bumps and road defects. Anyone who skated as a teenager will remember being thrown to the ground by a small piece of gravel stopping the wheel. Or a crack in tarmac/leaf/stick/drug needle, etc on a hill, etc
- k33n 14y agoThis comment is proof that no matter how awesome the product in an article posted to HN, somebody will always find a way to declare that it will certainly fail. Your comment contains so many factual inaccuracies that it's not even worth debating. I hope that comments like this will start to be deleted in the future because they are the reason many people, including myself, refrain from participating here more.
- mynameishere 14y agoawesome Since when did obvious nuisances become "awesome". I hope that comments like this will start to be deleted I hope that comments referring to obvious nuisances as "awesome" will be deleted. Here's the problem, as no one has quite caught on yet: The public transport areas consist of two main areas: Those for street-legal vehicles (cars, motorbikes, bicycles) and pedestrians (walkers, wheelchairs, baby carriages). There is simply no place for semi-powered vehicles on sidewalks. A moped or segway or motorized skateboard is an absolute nuisance on the sidewalk, and is a danger to everybody on the roadway. It doesn't fit outside of a mall-cop context.
- k33n 14y agoAt the risk of feeding the trolls, I'll bite. Who is this "obvious" to? Clearly not you, since you think it's a horrible idea. Electronic skateboards have been around for quite awhile, and until now, they've been very heavy and mostly impractical. Yet, they are a viable product in the market and popular enough that people are making money selling them. One of the reasons this product is a leap forward is because it's lightweight enough to be used as a normal skateboard without electric power. Simply stating that there is no place for this product on the sidewalk doesn't make it true, and I personally disagree with you. Stating that it is a "danger to everybody on the roadway" is absolutely absurd and simply untrue. Any vehicle that is under the control of a competent and observent operator will not be a danger to others in the least. Here's the real problem: The contrarian, negative, hostile commenters on HN are the vocal majority in a lot of cases. Personally, I'm really, really tired of this even being accepted by the community.
- mertd 14y agoThere is another issue that everyone missed. These things will most definitely be used on bike lanes. Any cyclist who had to share a lane with a longboarder knows that this feat is impossible. Longboard takes up the entire lane due to the salmon-like movement pattern. This forces the cyclist to go into the regular lane. Not that it is illegal, but frequent merging in and out of regular lanes is always dangerous.
- k33n 14y agoI guess you'll just have to "share the road" and stay behind them until it's safe to pass ;)
- mertd 14y agoThe existence of bike lanes is the number one proof that humans are incapable of peacefully sharing the road ;)
- prawn 14y agoOn a powered longboard, they've said that the swerving won't be necessary.
- baddox 14y ago> These contraptions are illegal to use in public Citation needed. > It is impossible to provide effective braking on a skateboard. I don't skateboard, so I don't know, but it seems like a lot of people are pretty effective at transporting themselves via skateboard. Besides, how does this contraption exacerbate the problem? If it's accelerating you to higher top speeds than a self-powered skateboard, then sure, but if the speeds are the same I don't see how this board could do anything other than improve braking.
- rokhayakebe 14y agoI am pretty sure someone said the same thing when boats first came out thousands of years ago. Then cars and trains hundreds of years ago. And motorcyles. Let us not get started on airplanes. Actually I am even sure someone said the same thing to the first guy/gal who came out swinging riding a horse "Oh my God, these animals are unpredictable, they will kill you, you will fall and break your neck."
- jordn 14y agoI think they've just invented the first skateboard brake by having an electric motor on there. If you have your weight on your back foot (which is pretty natural so you don't get caught in pavement cracks etc) then it shouldn't necessarily throw the user off.
- boostednoob 14y agoI'd like to address all of your bombastic remarks, but everyone else has picked you apart pretty well, so I'll just address the comment about short range urban transportation being a "solved" problem. I disagree. The bicycle is not the complete solution. compared to a board. Their actually huge. you rarely see a cubical that you could fit a bike in and most businesses don't have showers after your sweating bike ride to work. I think a board/public transit solution is a huge step. 1) Choosing your house or apartment: If you could board a couple miles to any type of public transit stop this decision really opens up. I emphasize ANY public transit stop. Some buses can only hold 2 bikes, and have you ever lugged your bike onto Caltrain. They really haven't learned anything from Europe about ergonomics of a train stop. Sometimes you have to lug your bike up 4 feet of stairs onto one of those trains. The board is light and small and EVERYONE on the bus or train could have one. And think how it open your transit schedule planing to choose from stops in a couple mile radius. The rent you can save from this decision will pay for your board. 2) Cubical space: How sweet is it that you could park your board next to your desk? I'm totally getting one of those hooks from the kickstarter video. 3) No sweat: Sure, I guess you could get a (massive) electric bike, but frankly who wants an electric bike? Not cool. The zero sweat solution to your commute would be one of these boards. I'm sure you and your colleagues would prefer if your didn't sit in meetings covered in and smelling of sweat from your morning ride. You'll have to get the exercise somewhere else.