4 ms·
Which is why alongside freedom came the business of anti-virus.
by pjmlp 1y ago
Which is why alongside freedom came the business of anti-virus.
- wiseowise 1y agoNever in 20 years of using Linux/Macs I’ve ever needed anti-virus.
- charcircuit 1y agoYou have been lucky. It's trivial for someone to write a stealer and trick someone to run it. For example there's been stealers targeting Linux built into trojans of Minecraft mods.
- aquariusDue 1y agoAs another lucky soul do you happen to know of a case documented somewhere?
- charcircuit 1y agoFor example. https://support.curseforge.com/en/support/solutions/articles/9000228509-june-2023-infected-mods-detection-tool https://support.curseforge.com/en/support/solutions/articles...
- aquariusDue 1y agoThat is wild, the numbers are much bigger than I expected. Thanks for sharing!
- pjmlp 1y agoMany people also never need insurances, until they do. How is that curl https://... | sudo sh going?
- saagarjha 1y agoGiven its prevalence, I think it's actually going surprisingly well
- mike_hearn 1y agoOnly if you ignore the "npm install" or "pip install" moral equivalent. Free open source packages that come with a side helping of malware have become common in recent years.
- saagarjha 1y agoOh I included that I just think that statically things are mostly going fine (unless we are all secretly backdoored in a way that has yet to be made public).
- mike_hearn 1y agoMacs come with an Apple provided antivirus built in, it's called XProtect. Apple also has enforced a similar policy to what Google is doing, but much stricter, and has done for ~13 years or so (devs must be identified, the OS rejects unsigned code in all territories by default, Apple pre-approves all binaries even outside the app store). Linux distros have policies far more extreme than anything Google, Apple or Microsoft have ever done. They explicitly don't support installing any software not provided by their "app stores". Getting into those requires giving up your source code to them, and they reserve the right to modify it as they see fit without informing anyone, reject it for any reason or no reason at all (including reasons like "we don't have time"), and they tie getting new releases of your app to the user upgrading to new releases of the OS. If you do try and install stuff from outside of your distribution, not only are there security warnings to click through but an expected outcome is that the OS breaks and the vendor washes their hands of you. Despite those policies, or perhaps because of them, botnets of Linux servers are common. Of all consumer-facing platforms only Windows and Android allow installation of unsigned third party code out of the box via some obvious graphical path. And on Windows that right is somewhat theoretical. You can do it but the built in browser will try very hard to stop you, and the OS itself will happily break unsigned code by blocking file open syscalls heuristically. So in practice most apps don't go the unsigned route. On Android OTOH, unsigned (non ID verified) code is sandboxed and works just like regular apps after installation, the OS won't heuristically interfere with the app.
- BLKNSLVR 1y agoThat's an interesting take on Linux. I see it as a lot closer to what Windows programs were like back in the day, where you can install whatever you want. Linux distributions each have their built in package managers, but there's no 'policy', as I understand it, that prevents installation of, literally, whatever you want. It's generally more difficult than just downloading and double clicking on the installer / exe, but just follow the instructions and it's done. And, yes, also there are weird version and dependency issues that crop up more than would be ideal, but that's not the topic.
- mike_hearn 1y ago
- zeta0134 1y agoNever in those 20 years did I need one on Windows either. It turns out if you vet the software you install in the first place, malware is pretty rare. That isn't the bar for most regular users of software though. Working in retail tech support, we got folks bringing in their new macbooks, freshly ruined by new ransomware, utterly baffled that it was possible at all. But when you're trying to use Photoshop without paying... well, shady stuff's still out there.
- lukan 1y agoBut you also browse the web. Running lots of unvetted software. All safe, as long as the sandbox holds.
- scarface_74 1y agoAnd the other 80%+ of the population that uses Windows?
- thebruce87m 1y agoI’ve never needed the seatbelt in my car or the airbags but I will not be uninstalling them.
- BLKNSLVR 1y agoSame with me for Linux, but I would also say that, with the discipline and knowledge I have had for the last 10-15 years I probably wouldn't need anti-virus for Windows either.
- thebruce87m 1y agoDiscipline and knowledge cannot protect against 0-click attacks.
- rcxdude 1y agoantivirus won't generally do much for those either.
- thebruce87m 1y agoIf your system is infected you may know after the fact, which is better than never knowing.
- sunaookami 1y agoAnd people were successfully tricked into "needing" anti virus scanners that do more harm then good.
- mike_hearn 1y agoAnti-virus apps aren't actually useless. They are slow, inefficient, have bad false positive and negative rates, but they aren't useless. I know it's an unpopular opinion but most HN posters have never been on the other side of this stuff. Many moons ago I attended an internal tech talk by the Google security team. This was shortly after they got hacked by China around 2010 or so. The talk was a general one on what they were doing to boost the security posture in general. Number one thing they were doing was moving away from AV scanners on Windows to a regime in which IT would centrally whitelist all apps by signature or EXE/DLL hashes. Beyond the issue of false negatives, the reason was that people would routinely install malware infected software despite being told by the AV scanner that it was infected. They'd be told that and they'd just override it. Nearly always the reason was that they were installing pirated software and wanted it badly enough that they either didn't care that it was virus infected, or they talked themselves into believing a conspiracy theory in which AV companies reported false positives to try and discourage piracy. The other problem with AV was that it reported true positives centrally, but then they'd be coming from high level executives and there'd be problems with addressing the issue. Whereas in a whitelisting scheme said executive would have to file a ticket to request permission to install the malware-ridden pirated Photoshop or whatever, and they wouldn't do it. This was very sad and I don't know if they kept it up, that sort of thing is terribly high maintenance and it wouldn't be a surprise if they moved away from it at some point. But when your biggest problem is AV that is accurate but ignored and that's inside one of the world's most sophisticated tech companies, it's fair to say AV is not useless but if anything needs to be even stricter.
- LoganDark 1y ago> or they talked themselves into believing a conspiracy theory in which AV companies reported false positives to try and discourage piracy. To be fair, pirated software often uses obfuscation techniques similar to malware, and then it's more like antivirus vendors refusing to add an exception for pirated software, rather than antivirus vendors specifically seeking out pirated software to mark as malware. Also: Certain types of scripts and software that I use to configure Windows in unsupported ways are detected as malware by major scanners. While I'm sure someone wouldn't appreciate these scripts being used on their computer by surprise, when I use them intentionally, I want their effects.
- _Algernon_ 1y agoAs a consequence of the freedom of driving cars we got seat belts. But we did not prevent everyone from driving.
- pjmlp 1y agoWe certainly did, those that fail to obey following the rules, besides the monetary expenses, given enough points they either lose their license or are given some months on a tiny room to think about their life decisions.