6 ms·
Before someone chimes in with that XKCD strip: How does Opus compare to other codecs? Opus is distinguished from most formats for high quality audio (AAC, Vor
by kibwen 14y ago
Before someone chimes in with that XKCD strip:
How does Opus compare to other codecs?
Opus is distinguished from most formats for high quality audio (AAC, Vorbis, MP3) by having low delay and it is distinguished from most low delay formats (G.711, GSM, Speex) by supporting high audio quality. It meets or exceeds existing codecs' quality across a wide range of bitrates, and it operates at lower delay than virtually any existing compressed format. Further, the Opus format itself and the reference implementation are available under liberal royalty-free licenses, making it easy to adopt, compatible with free software, and suitable for usage as part of the basic infrastructure of the Internet. See the Opus comparison page for more details.
http://wiki.xiph.org/OpusFAQ#How_does_Opus_compare_to_other_codecs.3F http://wiki.xiph.org/OpusFAQ#How_does_Opus_compare_to_other_...
Which is to say, this isn't (okay, isn't just) a case of having "too many standards"; Opus is legitimately impressive from a technical standpoint. Oh, and it's unencumbered by patents. That's cool.
EDIT: And here's the coolest part of the article that completely took me by surprise:
"The IETF recently decided with “strong consensus” to adopt Opus as a mandatory-to-implement (MTI) codec for WebRTC, an upcoming standard for real-time communication on the web."
- wissler 14y agoThere is no such thing as "unencumbered by patents". Unless you have a technology that has already been tested thoroughly in the courts, which is the only way you can really determine whether something would be deemed to violate a patent or not, you simply can't know.
- azakai 14y agoEven if it was tested by the courts, you can appeal. And even after the appeal, you can appeal to a higher court, all the way to the Supreme. And even if was tested there, congress can pass a law that allows it. And even if that happens the Supreme court can strike down the law. And even if that happens, the public can mount a revolution and tear down the legal system. But, practically speaking, Opus has extremely good guarantees for being unencumbered, as much as is possible - the people working on it have given licenses to use it, and experts in the field have had a while to go over this stuff. Nothing is 100%, but this is as good as it gets.
- wissler 14y agoNo matter how many times I'm downvoted, it's still not unencumbered. It's simply not in the nature of our patent system that something this complex can be unencumbered, unless it's with respect to an expired patent. I know my position causes a lot of cognitive dissonance with people, because it implies that the system is fundamentally unfair. Well, you can either take the red or the blue pill.
- azakai 14y ago> No matter how many times I'm downvoted, it's still not unencumbered. Who said you were wrong? Quite the opposite, I strongly agreed with you - anything can be encumbered, and anything includes this. But the point is that Opus is as safe as you can possibly be from being patent encumbered. Everything is potentially encumbered, but there are things with higher or lower likelihoods. And there isn't any lower than Opus. If this is still too worrying for you to use, then you can't use any software at all.
- shmerl 14y agoIt is unencumbered, unless someone proves that it is encumbered.
- wissler 14y agoIt is unencumbered, unless there's a ton of money to be made by suing them. Same goes for Theora. When some deep-pocketed hardware manufacturer dares put one of these "unencumbered" algorithms into its hardware, then we will see. But I doubt they'll dare.
- shmerl 14y agoLet them present their patents and try to sue, then you can say something is encumbered. Until now they engaged in empty threats and demagogy. They make tons of money by dominating the market, and when some potential completion shows up they try to prevent its adoption by spreading empty FUD. So it has nothing to do with patent encumbrance, it's just about their greed and thirst for market domination.
- shmerl 14y agoIt means to the best of authors' knowledge.
- derleth 14y ago> There is no such thing as "unencumbered by patents". When do the lawsuits over PNG begin?
- smiddereens 14y agoI don't know which XKCD strip you're referring to; link?
- kibwen 14y agohttp://xkcd.com/927/ http://xkcd.com/927/ Keep in mind that this strip is a strong contender for the title of "Most Frequently-Posted Link in HN Comment Threads." That would be an interesting analysis, actually.
- lloeki 14y ago> And here's the coolest part of the article that completely took me by surprise: "The IETF recently decided with “strong consensus” to adopt Opus as a mandatory-to-implement (MTI) codec for WebRTC, an upcoming standard for real-time communication on the web." Indeed. There may be interesting side consequences for that. The first article comment asks: > Interesting! Any idea if this will become mandatory to implement for HTML5 audio as well? That’s another area in sore need of a single format that works everywhere. This means that if a browser supports WebRTC, it has to support Opus, and it then happens that the codec will be available for <audio>. Now that does not mean that <audio> => Opus support, but it will have a (increasingly with time) high chance to be so.