4 ms·
I suspect history will show their three biggest mistakes to be: 1. Allowing an IPO that was vastly overpriced. 2. Keeping Zuckerberg in the CEO role for too l
by Silhouette 14y ago
I suspect history will show their three biggest mistakes to be:
1. Allowing an IPO that was vastly overpriced.
2. Keeping Zuckerberg in the CEO role for too long.
3. Taking their users for granted.
Obviously the first has seriously damaged their credibility, and with it their ability to hire and retain people who could solve their problems and grow the business.
I believe the second has a similar effect. Aside from the catastrophe of the IPO, Facebook don't appear to be going anywhere strategically. The cat is out of the bag in terms of cost effectiveness (or lack thereof) of Facebook ads compared to alternatives like Google. And generating ad revenue on small-screen mobile is bound to be harder, whether you're using HTML5 or anything else, because the physical screen size only provides so much space.
The third will probably be what finally kills them. As long as they can maintain the critical mass of users, the "everyone's on Facebook because everyone's on Facebook" effect, they can get away with a lot. But no-one using Facebook goes there for the ads, and no-one really likes all the privacy invasion. These things are merely tolerated, and only up to a point, because people like being sociable and right now Facebook lets them keep in touch with their friends and family more conveniently than anyone else.
So when Zuckerberg says "Over the next three to five years, the biggest question on everyone's mind is really going to be how well Facebook does with mobile"[1], I think perhaps he's getting ahead of himself. The biggest question I would ask, if I were a potential investor, is whether Facebook will still have that critical mass of users in three to five years, or whether, like every popular social forum on the Web before them, they will have been disrupted by the new shiny.
[1] http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-19565937 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-19565937
- jpdoctor 14y ago> 1. Allowing an IPO that was vastly overpriced. As others have pointed out, that's a feature not a bug. They raised a ton of money for not much equity, which is the best case result for an IPO from the company standpoint. Not so much for the suckers who bought. > 2. Keeping Zuckerberg in the CEO role for too long. As a consequence of #1, Zuck did not give up control. He can stay there until the equity is worth $0.00/share. The only consequence of #1 and #2 is that he pissed in the pool for all those that follow, because the suckers have been bled dry. And when you think about it, that means IPO is not as much of a possibility for all the future acquisition targets for FB. Total win for the company.
- pbreit 14y agoI disagree pretty strongly on all three points. The post-IPO share price decline is bad but I have not seen much, if any, evidence that it has hindered the ability to hire and retain employees. In fact, an easy case can be made that the smaller valuation creates much more upside for the RSUs that Facebook issues. Mark is one of the premier CEOs of his generation. Removing him would be completely insane. He is, by far, the single most responsible for having created a $60 billion company, something few can ever even hope to do. Facebook is extremely customer-focused and I don't think the privacy dust-ups suggest strongly otherwise. It's fashionable but trite to think Facebook will got "the same route" as properties before it. Pretty much the same thing gets said about any lasting company. It doesn't take much intelligenc or curiosity to consider that's not always the case.
- jonknee 14y ago> Mark is one of the premier CEOs of his generation. Removing him would be completely insane. He is, by far, the single most responsible for having created a $60 billion company, something few can ever even hope to do. There aren't many CEOs in his generation (of large companies) so that's not a great comparison. Facebook is also a $40B company, it has dropped like a rock since the shares became liquid. How much lower before his leadership is questioned? With the lack of growth and low profits I could easily see another $10-15B dropping off in short order.
- Pongo_the_Great 14y ago[i]He is, by far, the single most responsible for having created a $60 billion company, something few can ever even hope to do.[/i] Two things: Q) Wasn't this $100 billion not so long ago? A) Yes, and if things progress, it'll be $2 billion in six months.[1] Q) Who provided MZ with the finance, the clout and the film, not to mention a whole lot of other perks? A) The people who really made Facebook what it is. Anyone who thinks that the Facebook saga is one lone libertarian hero proving Capitalism need to... re-evaluate their maturity levels. [1] Please note the # of total shares about to hit the market.
- Jabbles 14y agoIt would be remarkable if a company with $10bn in cash and short-term investments had a market cap of $2bn. http://www.google.com/finance?q=NASDAQ%3AFB&fstype=ii&ei=j2NQUKjIKaimwAPk4AE http://www.google.com/finance?q=NASDAQ%3AFB&fstype=ii...