4 ms·
I don't see how "people of other nationalities should be allowed to freely compete with Americans" in any way leads to "slavery should be permitted". (I'm assu
by yummyfajitas 18y ago
I don't see how "people of other nationalities should be allowed to freely compete with Americans" in any way leads to "slavery should be permitted".
(I'm assuming you mean to imply that the caged compounds keep women in rather than keep pirates out.)
- tptacek 18y agoWe tacitly approve of inhumane working conditions when we allow countries with no human rights or workplace safety standards to compete on a level playing field with us.
- potatolicious 18y agoNo, we don't. When American companies were caught using near-slave labor consumers revolted, causing widespread changes in manufacturing policies for a great number of corporations. In fact, nowadays many manufacturers go out of their way to advertise their workers' working conditions and wages in an effort to demonstrate their social responsibility. Why? Because consumers demand it. And then there are the Wal-Marts of the world, who do not do as above, because there are also consumers who do tacitly approve of inhumane working conditions. The free market seems to be taking care of this problem - I don't see regulation needed here. Not to mention the fact that many of these "inhumane" conditions are actually pretty par for the course as far as those regions go. My own mother worked as a child laborer in a textiles mill when she was still in primary school. The extra income allowed her desperately poor family to move into the city, find jobs, and get educations. I doubt I would be typing on this computer if it were not for the opportunities presented by what the Western world would have, at the time, seen as atrocious workplace safety standards and an abuse of labor. Modernization is a long and arduous process that can be sped up with the right pressure, but preventing these countries from competing is simply condemning them to continual and perpetual poverty.
- tptacek 18y agoIf your position is that we should allow child labor in textile mills, and my position is that we should enact trade penalties on other countries that allow child labor, there's no useful discussion for us to have. So, duly noted. The slippery slope is an easier thing to address; the comment that "Microsoft is not a public work" basically refutes all labor, trade, and immigration regulation. It's not a betrayal of the GOP to suggest that Microsoft might comply with the rules we already have.
- potatolicious 18y agoChild labor is but one of many issues. My point is that there is a progression to modernizing a country, and that certain evils need to be tolerated while progress is being made. Do I agree with child labor? No. But I do believe that, in certain contexts, it is unavoidable and needs to be accepted temporarily, for the alternatives are certainly worse (e.g. condemning a large segment of the population to perpetual poverty). Expecting a 3rd-world country to act like a 1st-world one, when it clearly isn't, does not work. In the same way that the US often forces American-style democracy upon other countries without going through the requisite social changes beforehand, so do Western nations force first-world labor standards on countries that are simply not ready. What we, as modernized nations, should be doing is not unfairly punishing these countries, but rather establishing a roadmap to eliminate these evils through economic development. This may take years and decades, but at least in my birth nation child labor and sweatshops are all but eliminated, with the help of the US government no less. To try and play it black and white is foolish and solves nothing.
- davidw 18y agoHere's a good Paul Krugman column that addresses this: http://web.mit.edu/krugman/www/smokey.html http://web.mit.edu/krugman/www/smokey.html Also, you should take into consideration whether the US as a country should be in the business of telling other countries what to do.
- tptacek 18y agoIn the context of Microsoft, isn't this basically an argument for allowing the US to backslide on labor policy? We're talking about jobs that are already fulfilled by our domestic work force, at one of the world's most profitable corporations.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoMy point is that there is no slippery slope. There is a very clear dividing line: forced labor and slavery. H1B's are on one side of that line, women trapped in caged compounds are on the other.