4 ms·
Some other factors to think about: Road quality in the United states is low compared to other OPEC countries Seatbelts and motorbike helmets are still not man
by grecy 14y ago
Some other factors to think about:
Road quality in the United states is low compared to other OPEC countries
Seatbelts and motorbike helmets are still not mandatory in all US states
Car quality and safety in the United States is lower than other OPEC countries
EDIT: I meant OECD, not OPEC.
- tptacek 14y agoIn only one state in the US are seatbelts not mandatory for adults (New Hampshire). Otherwise, the only differences are between states in which you can be pulled over for being observed not wearing a seatbelt (the "primary enforcement" states) and those in which you can only be issued a seatbelt ticket after being pulled over for some other reason. I also think the road and car quality questions are up for debate.
- grecy 14y agoAren't there a lot of states where back seat passengers don't have to wear seat belts, and people can ride in the back of pick-ups etc. Obviously road and car quality are up for debate, but once you spend some time driving around Europe in European cars, you'll see what I mean.
- tptacek 14y agoFor every 1 passenger killed in the US, almost 3 drivers are killed. Given that the mean occupancy per car in the US is something between 1.3 and 1.7, it seems very unlikely that back seat restraints are a significant contributor to these statistics.
- grecy 14y agoIt's exactly that kind of thinking that explains why road deaths in the US are high (the original topic of this thread). Whenever a stat says something interesting that could be improved about America, it seems Americans find a way of dismissing the data as "not really appropriate for reasons x,y,z", thus leaving the original problem unimproved.
- tptacek 14y agoI'm sorry, 'grecy, I've been dismissive of you in this thread, but I simply don't understand what you're trying to say here. It is evident from the statistics that lack of mandatory rear passenger seat belts are probably not a significant cause of death in the US. If you're just trying to make a case that we should mandate rear passenger seatbelts, I'm not arguing with you. I'm talking about life expectancy stats.
- baltcode 14y agoI thought OPEC was the oil producers club, and that the US isn't a member. Did I miss something?
- grecy 14y agoSorry, confused my acronyms. OECD
- tptacek 14y ago[WARNING: Egregiously incorrect comment follows] In other words, you think car quality in the US is lower than that of countries like Tajikistan, Swaziland, Kazakhstan, and Ecuador. When you say "OECD", you might as well say "the entire world". I officially doubt your statistics.