5 ms·
Amtrak's New Acela Trains Are Here. They're Moving Slower Than the Old Ones
- octaane 1y agoImportant context buried at the bottom: "Passenger rail analysts said that it isn’t unusual for rail operators to pad their schedules when introducing new trains, especially if they will run alongside older ones. For example, during a rollout, a railroad might schedule more generous dwell time at stops, they said." Also, the new schedule is only about 15 mins longer than the old one...this is a big nothingburger.
- CGMthrowaway 1y ago>"Passenger rail analysts said that it isn’t unusual for rail operators to pad their schedules when introducing new trains, especially if they will run alongside older ones. For example, during a rollout, a railroad might schedule more generous dwell time at stops, they said." Why? For marketing purposes?
- scienceman 1y agoI would guess to account for any unfamiliarity from the operators (new systems, etc) and allowing more time to sort out any other kinks. (they also pad the schedules for old trains too -- this is to accommodate small slowdowns without causing cascading delays).
- jasonpeacock 1y agoNew trains: padded schedule Old trains: padded schedule So really, all train schedules are padded - which makes sense, you need buffers to absorb variance in performance to have reliable schedules.
- eqvinox 1y ago> Old trains: padded schedule No — Old trains: schedule based on experiences from having ran them for at least a year (i.e. all seasons) New trains' buffers are larger because you don't know e.g. how shit the brakes are when you have tons of leaves on your rails. (Yes this is an actual thing¹.) [¹ Ed.: in case anyone is incredulous at the leaves thing: https://www.groupe-sncf.com/en/group/behind-the-scenes/traffic-flows/autumn-leaves https://www.groupe-sncf.com/en/group/behind-the-scenes/traff... ]
- SoftTalker 1y agoThe contact surface area of a steel wheel on a rail is about the size of a dime. That's what you have to work with to stop the train.
- CGMthrowaway 1y agoTo drive the train. But to stop the train, surely the contact surface of the brakes with the wheels is more important?
- jimktrains2 1y agoJust like on a car, if your break pads are capable of completely stopping the wheel, but the wheel is not capable of creating enough braking force with the surface, then you slide. If you lubricate between the wheels and surface, which is essentially what leaves do on rails, no amount of at-wheel breaking power will stop you. This is what antilock Brakes in cars prevent, they pulse the brakes to allow the tire to regain traction, preventing slippage and loss of control.
- tialaramex 1y agoNote that a modern train also has the same system, only more so, a car would typically have 4 wheels, I think the Acela probably has like 96 or something.
- 1y ago
- bobthepanda 1y agoIf you run the new trains at maximum potential then they will just catch up to the old train in front of them and then have to maintain the old train’s pace. So during the transition period you couldn’t really run the new train faster anyways.
- docdeek 1y agoYou’re right on this point, but my read of the article was that you can buy the fastest trains in the world but if your infrastructure is not up to enabling them, they won’t go much faster than the ones you have already.
- eqvinox 1y agoThe headline — which, let's face it, will be the only thing a whole bunch of people are going to read — really makes it out like they bought shitty trains, or even that trains can't be better. Which is just untrue.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- UncleThomas 1y ago[flagged]
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> the new schedule is only about 15 mins longer than the old one...this is a big nothingburger Then why the new cars? Are they cheaper to run? If so, the real price of a ticket (or losses [1]) should go down. [1] https://www.amtrak.com/content/dam/projects/dotcom/english/public/documents/corporate/amtrak-financial-performance-faqs-03052025.pdf https://www.amtrak.com/content/dam/projects/dotcom/english/p...
- craftkiller 1y agoQuoting from the brief article you didn't read: > Amtrak previously has said the new trains could potentially shave 20 minutes off the travel time between New York City and Washington, D.C., reducing the duration to around 2½ hours > because of Amtrak’s old infrastructure, the new trains can only travel at top speed during certain portions of the journey [...] Infrastructure upgrades planned over the coming years will improve trainspeed and reliability, the railroad said. > Each new train will hold 386 passengers, an increase of 27% compared with the current fleet. Therefore: Faster trains carrying more people. Just not faster on day 1.
- JumpCrisscross 1y agoNot faster, per the article. And again, more capacity should mean lower ticket prices or lower projected losses. We have neither.
- adeelk93 1y agoThe train was designed with a 20 year service life and is approaching 30. We do need new trains, even if they didn’t bring about any improvements.
- OneDeuxTriSeiGo 1y agoThe new cars hold far more people, are faster, and they are supposed to be paired with comprehensive upgrades to the extremely aged infrastructure and tracks along that route. Both the cars and the overhaul on the route were funded by the Biden admin (primarily with funds allocated by congress between 2021 and 2023) with the intent that modernisation to the route would gradually allow the cars to run at speed over the next few years. Now it's unclear what the status is of this infrastructure overhaul with the current administration suspending funds for the previous admin's projects.
- octaane 1y agohttps://archive.ph/lTnR7 https://archive.ph/lTnR7
- bobbylarrybobby 1y agoUS rail is so pathetic. Not the rail’s fault per se, but it's pretty embarrassing for a a supposedly wealthy country to not be able to offer its citizens cheap, easy, high speed travel across the country.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> US rail is so pathetic National passenger rail. We still have the world's largest rail network [1]. It's just focussed on freight. (We also have world-class municipal and regional rail in the New York area.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_rail_transport_network_size https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_rail_tran...
- saubeidl 1y agoI'm not sure municipal rail in NY is quite world-class, tho it is by far the best the US has to offer.
- jcranmer 1y ago> (We also have world-class municipal and regional rail in the New York area.) If by world-class you mean something that most of the world would consider a rail system, yes (in comparison to most US cities' attempts which aren't really worth even pretending constitutes regional rail). If you mean something that most of the world would consider as something worth emulating, nope.
- JumpCrisscross 1y agoMetro-North and the LIRR have on-time rates rivalling the Swiss rail system.
- SilverElfin 1y agoI wonder what the cost would be to build a passenger rail network that simply parallels the freight network, even if low speed. Amtrak is terrible mostly because freight trains get priority and it screws up the schedules.
- legitster 1y agoThe B1M put together some good content on the particular infrastructure problems that affect the route: https://www.theb1m.com/video/northeast-corridor-baltimore-tunnel https://www.theb1m.com/video/northeast-corridor-baltimore-tu... The route relies on some really old infrastructure, including single span bridges and tunnels that predate TBMs.
- pempem 1y agoThis is so intensely misleading. The trains are new. The wires etc they run on aren't. When there's funding to update those, the trains will run faster. If this was done in the opposite way, we likely would still be working on infrastructure (it's a bigger project) and the trains would still not run faster cuz they would be old. We need to hold the fourth estate to better account.
- SilverElfin 1y agoFourth estate?
- samtheDamned 1y agoFrom Oxford: "the profession of journalism"