4 ms·
Healthcare, especially the patient-facing part, isn’t like other services. If we want private ownership of this infrastructure it has to look more like either
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
Healthcare, especially the patient-facing part, isn’t like other services.
If we want private ownership of this infrastructure it has to look more like either a utility, where the state has a direct say in service changes and pricing, or a partnership, where unlimited liability flows through to the owners. I’m a fan of the latter.
Limited liability was an amazing invention. But it’s not appropriate for healthcare. Turn these services into partnerships and you’ll see the give-a-shit factor quintuple overnight. (You’ll also probably see a reduction in leverage.)
- lokar 1y agoI agree, there should be no limited liability for for-profit healthcare organizations. And non-profit health care orgs should have strict regulation, and the state should appoint some of the members of the board.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> there should be no limited liability for for-profit healthcare organizations Any. If you ringfence it to for-profit companies you'll just wind up with non-profits either siphoning profits away or exorbitantly compensating their leadership.
- lokar 1y agoThat’s why all high revenue non-profits should have some board seats appointed by the state, and state audits, etc.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> all high revenue non-profits should have some board seats appointed by the state, and state audits, etc. Why would you want to politicise every non-profit like this?
- lokar 1y agoIt can be done fairly neutrally In CA, put a professor of medicine and one from a mgmt school from the UC system on the boards of the to 10 medical systems. Let the regents pick the person, etc
- BrenBarn 1y agoJust hard-cap compensation.
- whimsicalism 1y agogiven the absolutely nutso judgements juries award in the US, nobody would open a practice if this were true
- lokar 1y agoThey do it every day. Many (most?) doctors work in partnerships. And they have insurance.
- whimsicalism 1y agoNo, only a small proportion (less than a quarter) work in partnerships and a large driver of the decrease is the American liability environment. But sure, doctors in some specialties choose to take the gamble that the liability doesn’t exceed their insurance limits. But such a gamble would be extremely risky for a system or hospital employing hundreds of caregivers.
- lokar 1y agoMy goal is to force the large systems into being non-profit
- giardini 1y agoMy goal is to eliminate all non-profits. That is, I want them taxed!
- whimsicalism 1y agomost large providers already are, it is no panacea. imposing further costs on the provisioning of care only means less care in the equilibrium
- Der_Einzige 1y ago1. Force Americans to take GLP-1s en mass to get objective health care costs down (most are cus we are fat as fuck) 2. Destroy the APA and reform medical training in america. Doctors shortages are primarily the fault of professional organizations. Doctors in the USA are massively overpaid compared to the rest of the world. Use US power to force the free world to imitate us so that capital has nowhere else to fly to and is forced to stay here. 3. Do something to basically destroy scam wastes of medical dollars and insurance dollars like homeopathy, naturopathic, etc It won’t fix everything, but it’ll do a lot to help.
- SoftTalker 1y agoThat would have to come with some liability reform however. Injury lawyers are another cancer on society along with many practices of Private Equity. When you take care of sick or disabled people, bad outcomes, even death, can come along with that. Nobody in their right mind is going to form a health care partnership with unlimited personal exposure to liability unless that is strictly limited to actual losses in cases of proven negligence.
- alistairSH 1y agoAbout half the states already have caps on damages. [1] 1 - https://www.millerandzois.com/medical-malpractice/maryland-medical-malpractice-cap/malpractice-damage-caps/ https://www.millerandzois.com/medical-malpractice/maryland-m...
- phil21 1y agoCaps aren’t super interesting overall. It’s the low bar it takes to sue and how expensive it is to litigate bullshit to marginal cases vs. settlements.
- infecto 1y agoThis is the hard part imo. Thinking about the argument for a government run single payer system, someone is still having to make a calculation on appropriate treatment. It’s what happens at the NHS, perhaps a single payer can do it more efficiently and no I am not defending the American system but I do think there are a lot of hard to answer questions.
- tartuffe78 1y agoThe American government hasn’t had a good track record for solving difficult problems in my life time.
- slg 1y agoThis has become a self-fulfilling prophecy. When roughly half the political power in this country believes that government can only hurt, it makes it nearly impossible for the government to actually help.
- anthem2025 1y agolimited liability has been a disaster for the entire human race.
- bko 1y ago> Limited liability was an amazing invention. But it’s not appropriate for healthcare. If you want to make these services more expensive and produce shortages, this is how you would do it. Why would anyone invest or want to work in these fields? I have an unpopular take on PE taking over these small businesses after working with a few small businesses in the home improvement space. The fact is they are incredibly inefficient. You can't even get these guys to answer a phone. They bill you by mail weeks after and you call them to give them a credit card over the phone after you received your bill. Even getting estimates could take months. The service is not consistent. Depending on who they send, they could be completely clueless. You don't know until you finally stumble across someone competent that tells you how bad the last guy was. Pricing is all over the places. You can get two quotes that are 50% different. So there is little discovery. These are only the obvious external inefficiencies. I couldn't imagine how bad it is operationally. The bar is so low, which is prob why it's interesting for a PE firm. There is so much money being left on the table. That's why I generally prefer large chains for things like auto. You know the pricing. They are efficient and won't rip your face off for the most part. So I welcome more professionalism and corporate ownership if this means a better, more consistent level of service for me. I get there are downsides but right now I have enough trouble getting a hold of any of these guys that I just don't care.
- triceratops 1y ago> Why would anyone invest or want to work in these fields? That's how individual doctor's practices already work. If someone doesn't want to take liability for patient outcomes, good riddance.
- azinman2 1y agoYou’re making the assumption (from what I understand) that most of the inefficiency is in the administration side. I’m sure there is, but it’s also woefully complicated with insurance, laws, parties who may or may not be financially and cognitively sound, etc. But let’s say you can make the administration side way more efficient. How much did that save? 20%? That’s not the kinds of returns being sought. So where does the 2x, 3x, or more returns expected come from? Cutting services.
- mindslight 1y agoI don't understand how either of your proposed angles of reform are supposed to work. These are services being paid by the state, so I would think the state already has direct say in pricing? Which is why the business becomes a march to the bottom in provided services, to increase margins by decreasing expenses since they can't increase prices. I didn't see any mention of bankruptcy in the article, so I don't see what limited liability has to do here. If anything it seems like the entities are too well capitalized, in that they can fight with individual states and pay off whatever meager fines might result. Also as far as I understand the medical industry, the individual doctors/nurses signing off on the care being given are still directly liable (modulo professional insurance policies). They just have reams of paperwork saying the care was correct from their perspective, despite what the low level caregivers might be doing outside of the paperwork. I personally think what limited liability entities have developed into has become a scourge in general, as they end up being considered to have all the rights and freedoms of personally-liable natural persons. Getting a government granted liability shield should mean submitting to significantly more regulation to preclude engaging in well known patterns of constructive negligence. The vaunted fiercely-independent "man in the arena" can always actually get into the arena if they want their business to partake of the full natural rights afforded to natural persons... And maybe you're just coming from a similar feeling of wanting those ultimately in charge to also be directly responsible? I usually think of this in terms of corpos fighting regulation with specious justifications based on individual rights (Citizens United, corpo direction of employee speech, etc). I just don't see how adding the liability would make anything more actionable here.
- next_xibalba 1y agoI would think unlimited liability would only work to increase prices as it would mean providers would become more laden with lawyers, even more bureaucratized and slow (spend most of your time documenting everything so we don't lose lawsuits), etc. Those already seems like drivers of cost in hospitals. I have several family members who work in healthcare who are just miserable because so much of their time is consumed by things that are not helping and healing patients (documentation, etc.)