5 ms·
I think the main problem is, that there is simply too many people in the world. Of course it's very politically incorrect to say so, every politician will say t
by gambiting 14y ago
I think the main problem is, that there is simply too many people in the world. Of course it's very politically incorrect to say so, every politician will say that we need to increase our birth rates,not decrease them. But honestly,if we reduced the population to around 1-2 billion, we could all afford to live like we do today, with all our consumerism, fossil-fuel burning and so on. 7 billion people just cannot sustain that kind of lifestyle, not on this planet.
- aychedee 14y agoWell, you could kill yourself. If you think that's the moral solution to this problem.
- mcantelon 14y agoThat's like suggesting that if someone has a problem with something in society not being adequately funded by the government that they should contribute their life savings to it.
- randallsquared 14y agoIndeed. Be the change you want to see, and all that...
- hosh 14y agoI used to say that too. However, I could not get over this part: are you volunteering to be one of the 1-2 billion in the die-off so that rest of humanity can survive with this current lifestyle? Barring people who are already suicidal, I doubt anyone would want to volunteer. This is a hard problem, well beyond the concerns of political correctness.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- kvnn 14y agoHe didn't say anything about a die-off. He said we need to decrease birth rates.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- RyanMcGreal 14y agoThat's already happening, and birth rates tend to go down as median income goes up.
- aplusbi 14y agoI am volunteering to not have children (that are biologically mine).
- hosh 14y agoThat's fair.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ArbitraryLimits 14y agoUm, you don't have to have people currently living die. Even if you found 5-6 billion people to sign up to die tomorrow, what would you do with their bodies? How would you provide for their children, if any? Would you allow parents to sign up their whole families? etc. etc. I'm pretty sure the GP was just talking about capping reproduction for a while.
- hosh 14y agoI was responding to this: "But honestly,if we reduced the population to around 1-2 billion, we could all afford to live like we do today, ... " However, you bring up some good practical points of the consequences. A person's life ripples out and touches other people around him. As I said, this is a hard problem, not one solvable simply through a die-off or a cap on reproduction. At the heart of the problem is that each of us are self-centered to the point of ignoring anything beyond ourselves. We're already zombies in a culture of mindless consumerism. In First World countries, if you take away an individual's "job", "work", and "productivity", then that individual is lost. He does not know why he is here or what his purpose is. All he knows is that he needs to pay his rent and mortgage, watch TV, raise a family, and go shopping. People who do not fit that mold is either outcast or assimilated. Braaaaiinns. A few people might see beyond it thinking, let's do a startup! but end up mindless hitting the refresh button to see new comments on HN. Heh, zombie apocalypse is already here, and we didn't even see it coming. Though we did make some great TV shows about it.
- alberich 14y agoThe divide between rich and poor was never related to the number of people on the planet. People have been starving on earth for many generations and, probably, a considerable fraction of the human population will always be deprived of basic needs. And if someone could come up with a solution for this, for providing everyone with a fair share of everything, I don't doubt he/she would be promptly killed :P
- rdl 14y agoI wonder what the optimal population is for modern US quality of life. Clearly at 3000 or so, we wouldn't have enough specialization to have a decent quality of life. At 10b (and even at 7b), we're stretching available resources. I do think 1-2b would be a good number (if optimally selected). Arguably if we had better technology, even an increase over current population could be an improvement (assuming a marginal extra person was engaged in productive activity); most of the constrained resources seem like they could be dealt with using cheaper energy (making recycling/low grade ores/etc. recoverable, better transportation to reduce crowding, dealing with pollution, etc.)
- dasmoth 14y agoInteresting attempt to answer a closely-related question: http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2010/07/insufficient-data.html http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2010/07/insuffic...
- jnw2 14y agoHow well would the average US city cope with providing enough tap water for its population suddenly tripling?
- rdl 14y agoIn drought-prone areas, probably ok -- the range between normal and drought ("don't water lawns", cutting some industrial/commercial/ag use, etc.) is more than 3x.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoA very common sentiment, but just wrong, in my opinion. If there were fewer humans, the price of resources would drop, so we'd start using more of them frivolously, resulting in no significant benefit. On the other hand, if there were more humans, the price of resources would rise, and we'd start using them more efficiently. Quick quiz: what's the only commodity that has consistently risen in inflation-adjusted cost over the last few centuries, signalling that demand is greater than supply? Answer: labour. The large population of the world is what has allowed the intense specialization of the modern economy, leading to the technological revolution. Without the technological revolution we'd still be burning wood for heat, which is far more harmful on the environment than what we currently do, just to name one effect.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoHeading off the inevitable "what about food?" comment. Energy can be turned into food in a limited space very efficiently. Back of the envelope calculations show that a few hundred large nuclear power plants could feed the entire world. The only reason we don't do it this way is because it's cheaper to use the sun as a power source.
- sp332 14y agoAdjusting for inflation, the average wage in the US has stagnated since the 80's. What does that say?
- pchristensen 14y agoHow have worldwide wages changed during that period?
- bryanlarsen 14y agoAs far as I understand, it's not the average wage that has stagnated, but the median wage. That says something about the US, but nothing about the world. In the same time period the median wage across the world has increased dramatically, especially in China, India & Africa.
- crpatino 14y agoNo, I don't think this is accurate. There are probably 1 billion people in the developed world enjoying a life of "consumerism, fossil-fuel burning and so on", plus a tiny minority composed of the elites of the global south. You may add roughly another billion people from the emerging economies (i.e. the BRIC countries), who have lesser, but rapidly growing, rates of per capita consumption. We are already 1-2 billion people living what we'd consider a "normal life" by modern standards, maybe another 3-4 billion with tolerably low levels of resources, and 1 more billion in the most absolute poverty. Heck, I have not seen any study to confirm, but I suspect that the average pet in the US is better taken care off that the average child in a 3rd world shanty town (and probably have a longer expected lifespan too)! So, yes, the population bomb is a problem, but it gets amplified by the per-capita expenditure, and the 80-96 percentile have a disproportionate weight on the overall effect. (Contrary to OWS retoric, my opinion is that the "one percenters" are not the main part of the problem. They are not only too few, but subject to time and space limitations that prevent them to consume as much as their wealth would predict. At the end of day, they will use most of their money to make more money or gain political influence. What they use that influence for is yet another dimension of our predicament).
- roc 14y agoI think you're misunderstanding OWS rhetoric; or conflating edge noise with the core philosophy. Their primary complaint is that the 1% have already used their money to gain political influence to advantage the further consolidation of existing wealth and to disadvantage those who would make new wealth, potentially at the expense of the existing 1%. It has nothing to do with other consumption, or lack thereof, of the 1%.
- crpatino 14y agoindeed. But the thing is, you cannot lead people to go where they do not want to. We are not in this situation because some evil overlord made us do it, but we ended up here due to our collective needs and wants. And the way out is not by opposing an overlord that may turn out not as evil and definitively not as in control and we had imagined, but through the conscious modification of our needs and wants.
- ctdonath 14y agoI think the main problem is Based on _what_? Have you actually crunched any numbers, however casually? Have you looked at population trajectories? Have you considered that most people don't live at, or even anywhere close to, your elite level? While far from definitive, I do play with world population numbers on occasion. My guestimate of world carrying capacity is around 33B people. Sure, it's not what you're used to, but it's sufficient (albeit mundane) food and shelter. Population replacement rates are falling worldwide. World population is set to peak mid-century. Many first-world countries are facing population reduction at crisis rates, with a few having birth rates so low the country/culture is set to disappear entirely. Insofar as some think there should be fewer people, seems the species is pretty good at handling that without wanton interference. "Too many people" is easy to say when you're very comfortable, assume everyone else lives as you do, and don't like the idea of having to give way to a few more. Don't forget that half the world's population functions under 1/20th of the official American "poverty line". Funny thing is, if "we could all afford to live like we do today" we'd be complaining about how bad off most people are and arguing for a population reduction to 0.5-0.9 billion so the survivors could live like the top 10%. In the past (exemplified by _The_Population_Bomb_) similar predictions were made lamenting the world's inability to support X billion people; we're well beyond those feared limits now and doing quite well. Technology (notice which discussion board we're on here) is very good at working out ways of drastically improving resource providence. The problem with food isn't lack thereof - thanks to technology we have more than enough for everyone; the problem with food is politicization of distribution. Insofar as some resources really are limited (and there are valid arguments that fossil fuels et al are not nearly as limited as naysayers claim), high tech enables better/cheaper/sustainable solutions. Problems can be resolved with solutions, some of which are unimaginable now but will be normal in the not-far future. So the question remains: on what objective grounds can you claim "there is simply too many people in the world"? Why can't Y-Combinator types view the "too many" problem as a challenge for making 7-10B people sustainable & comfortable? 1-2B is a heck of a reduction, presumably beyond mere curbing of procreation; as others ask - are you willing to sacrifice yourself and/or [potential] offspring to get there? and how far are you willing to go to enforce the view on those of us who disagree?
- CWuestefeld 14y agoThis is a common sentiment, and one that's been around quite a while -- at least two centuries, dating back to Thomas Malthus [1]. Back then, he thought the world was at its max carrying capacity, and disaster was imminent. The idea keeps coming back, as with Paul Ehrlich in the '70s, which climaxed in the Simon-Ehrlich wager [2] (which was flawed, but still a pretty good demonstration). The thing is, we're always on the verge of disaster, but the price mechanism of the market continually motivates people to seek out alternatives. So we always find a new way to achieve something "just in time". Consider the history of lighting. There's no way we could continue to light our homes with candles or whale oil; as the whales got scarce, the price of oil increased, and that's a big part of what drove the invention of newer means of generating light. The fact is that the single greatest resource at our disposal is the human mind: that's what allows us to invent new alternatives, to get away from the things that become scarce. All of human history shows that the more people we've got, the better off we are. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Robert_Malthus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Robert_Malthus [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simon-Ehrlich_wager https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simon-Ehrlich_wager