3 ms·
In the 2010 Times Higher Education "top universities" list, Alexandria University in Egypt ranked ahead of Georgetown and Delft. It also beat out Harvard and St
by ilamont 14y ago
In the 2010 Times Higher Education "top universities" list, Alexandria University in Egypt ranked ahead of Georgetown and Delft. It also beat out Harvard and Stanford in the subcategory that measured the impact of research (1). Here's what happened:
Phil Baty, deputy editor of Times Higher Education, acknowledged that Alexandria’s surprising prominence was actually due to “the high output from one scholar in one journal” — soon identified on various blogs as Mohamed El Naschie, an Egyptian academic who published over 320 of his own articles in a scientific journal of which he was also the editor.
In 2009, an administrator at Clemson University in the U.S. revealed that the college had "... manipulated class sizes, artificially boosted faculty salary data and gave rival schools low grades in the rankings' peer reputation survey" with the goal of improving its U.S. News & World Report college ranking. This helped the university rise from #38 to #22 over a seven-year period (2). A few weeks ago, Emory University admitted it had also manipulated data/lied over a period of more than 10 years in order to improve its U.S. News & World Report ranking (3).
My takeaway from these incidents: Not only are university ranking systems imperfect to begin with, but it's also possible to game the system ... and it happens every year.
1. New York Times: "Questionable Science Behind Academic Rankings"
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/11/15/education/15iht-educLede15.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2010/11/15/education/15iht-educLede15...
2. USA Today: "Clemson official: School manipulated rankings "
http://www.usatoday.com/news/education/2009-06-04-clemson-rankings_N.htm http://www.usatoday.com/news/education/2009-06-04-clemson-ra...
3. Reuters: "Emory gave incorrect data to publications that rank U.S. colleges"
in.reuters.com/article/2012/08/17/usa-emory-ranking-idINL2E8JHNG320120817
- sb 14y agoThanks so much for all the data! I was just about to write a "well, hopefully nobody on HN cares about these rankings" post, trying to remember some of the facts I read about, but your post summarizes these data so well, no need to post at all. Just for the record: I recently read (presumably on HN, too) about a ranking where somebody asked lawyers to rank schools according to their prestige. Penn-State always got ranked in the middle, even though it didn't have a law school at all. So, in a sense it doesn't even matter if administrators are cheating or not...
- flexie 14y agoAbsolutely. I do hope pedigree will matter even less in the future as formal education hopefully matters less as well. The important thing shouldn't be education, but what is done with it. Here is a messy and incomplete list of cool things created by people from lower ranking universities: Python: University of Amsterdam. Ruby: University of Tsukuba. PHP: University of Waterloo. Javascript: University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign Rails: Copenhagen Business School Django: University of Bath and Missouri School of Journalism Drupal: Ghent University Linux: University of Helsinki MySQL: Helsinki University of Technology and ?? Perl: Seattle Pacific University Java: University of Calgary Objective C: Furman University and ?? C++: University of Aarhus C#: Technical University of Denmark
- reinhardt 14y agoUIUC is not exactly lower ranking: http://colleges.usnews.rankingsandreviews.com/best-colleges/university-of-illinois-urbana-champaign-145637/overall-rankings http://colleges.usnews.rankingsandreviews.com/best-colleges/...
- flexie 14y agoI agree :-) But it ranks way below the schools discussed in the link in the usual rankings.
- stephenhuey 14y agoI've been reading through all the comments, many of which complain about bias. That's only part of the problem. Often students applying to graduate school have a better idea of what they're looking for, but for undergraduates the metrics that they're weighing with other factors such as campus life are much murkier, and these rankings don't analyze the questions that deeply. For example, Stanford and Rice University have the same student-to-faculty ratio, and their endowments are proportional, but Stanford has 2 graduate students for every undergraduate student, whereas Rice is one of the smallest Division 1 schools AND has fewer graduate students. So when Rice claims undergraduates interested in interacting closely with faculty in cutting-edge research will have ample opportunity to do so, one could argue they may be more likely to provide that to undergrads than even Stanford. Because I've compared experiences with Stanford folks, I don't think Stanford is behind Rice in that category, but the fact is, I'm comparing against one of the very top schools. So perhaps my argument holds for most universities that are ahead of Rice in the rankings, but a student is going to have to really dig to figure that out, and perhaps speak with students and faculty at each university to grasp the differences that matter to him or her. And that's only in the category of undergraduate participation in research--there are many other questions students face that these rankings can't properly answer.