3 ms·
This seems like just an attempt to change the news cycle, because there's no rule anywhere saying Wikipedia needs to be unbiased, any more than does Fox News or
by tptacek 1y ago
This seems like just an attempt to change the news cycle, because there's no rule anywhere saying Wikipedia needs to be unbiased, any more than does Fox News or PragerU.
- strathmeyer 1y agoEverything is projection. They're upset they can't insert their own bias into Wikipedia and want that bias codified by law or at least by corrupt lawmakers.
- schoen 1y agoYes, the proper response is that the government isn't supposed to oversee Wikipedia's editorial policy (or other organizations' editorial policy). Wikipedia should clearly have a right to choose its policies without government interference.
- ASalazarMX 1y agoProbably an attempt at capturing Wikipedia, in preparation for censorship or historic revisionism. I feel like a cosnpiracy theorist, but such things seem less implausible these days.
- tptacek 1y agoHow exactly is that supposed to work?
- pjc50 1y agoIt's not complicated, same process as has been applied to government agencies and private universities: remove "DEI", that is any mention of anti racism. How it's enforced is a detail. They have the Supreme Court to issue whatever verdict is required.
- tptacek 1y agoNo, it must be complicated. Wikipedia isn't grant-funded (they have money coming out of their ears) and it isn't a government agency subject to regulation. Most private publications are proudly biased. In fact, the most likely outcome to the House trying to play hardball with Wikipedia is a double-digit percentage increase in their donations. Which I don't think House Republicans mind, because none of this is actually about Wikipedia. So, again, how is this supposed to work?
- dashundchen 1y agoHow has it worked already? Dragging people for public spectacles in Congress, lawfare through frivolous lawsuits, frivolous investigation through a variety of agencies, wasting the orgs time in court, allies doxxing org members to intimidate them with stochastic terrorism. If you haven't been paying attention to how Trump and Co have been weapoinzing government to silence critics or pressure private orgs, you haven't been paying attention. What happened to Harvard? What happened to CBS/Paramount? What happened with 60 Minutes? What about ActBlue?
- tptacek 1y agoHarvard is extensively grant funded; that was the administration's leverage. CBS's owners were existentially dependent on DOJ approval of an impending merger. 60 Minutes is a CBS property. Nothing has happened to ActBlue. So again I ask: how exactly is the House supposed to accomplish anything with Wikipedia?
- kiitos 1y agomaybe step back and think about what this targeted, repeated, deeply meticulous sequence of challenges to this very narrow topic of conversation is communicating about you, and is achieving in the net sense is this the right application of your time and energy? perhaps that time and energy is more usefully spent fighting against the actively malicious current US political administration, than deconstructing arguments in that same vein?
- mdhb 1y agoThey are *already* retroactively rewriting reports and documents to align with the dear leaders brain farts. https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20250807-us-to-rewrite-its-past-national-climate-reports https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20250807-us-to-rewrite...
- tptacek 1y agoAnd? They can rewrite their own reports as much as they want. They don't get to rewrite Jacobin articles.
- mdhb 1y agoI’m just establishing that they have been in power for 5 minutes and haven’t hesitated to try and literally rewrite history already. You should expect them to continue to do so wherever they think they can get leverage.
- tptacek 1y agoNothing I'm saying has anything whatsoever to do with thinking that the GOP is operating in good faith.
- grover_board 1y agoYou're right, it's probably just a distraction, like sending the army into D.C. and Chicago is a distraction, like trying to illegally fire Fed governors is a distraction, like ordering the prosecution and persecution of political enemies is a distraction, like every blatant power-grab, attempt at intimidating the opposition, and obvious effort to establish a de facto hybrid authoritarian regime is just a distraction from...something. After all, the administration and its cronies are nothing but scrupulous about their adherence to The Rules.
- tptacek 1y agoSending the National Guard into DC is in fact a distraction. Trying to fire the Fed governors is not a distraction. Prosecuting political enemies is not a distraction. See? Both kinds of things happen. It's important to distinguish.
- xpe 1y ago> Sending the National Guard into DC is in fact a distraction. Depends what you mean. It also plays in to Trump's "tough on crime" message, which appeals to a fairly broad group of voters. It also appeals to MAGA fanatics who seem to delight in most things that anger "libs".
- tptacek 1y agoI can't wind myself up solely on the prospect that a political action Trump takes might benefit him; that's just how politics work. But to your latter point: catastrophizing the National Guard deployments is precisely what MAGA people want you to do.