3 ms·
> And Libre Office or Calligra are decent options as well. I use Linux machines for what they do well, and pretty much all my machines sans the "main" Laptop a
by josteink 14y ago
> And Libre Office or Calligra are decent options as well.
I use Linux machines for what they do well, and pretty much all my machines sans the "main" Laptop are Linux-driven.
That said: This statement cannot be refuted enough.
Libre Office and its forks are merely bad imitations of previous versions of MS Office while offering few to no benefits once you exclude cost. They are not "decent" alternatives. They are free, but noticeably sub-par alternatives. They are in no way drop-in replacements.
If I want to take the cost of working with a low-end Office-suite which covers the bare basics and sticks to a late 90s design-paradigm, I'll go with Google's online-offering because it actually provides some benefits to weigh up for the cost.
And sometimes I do just that. But you'll never find me meddling with the desktop Linux office-suites. They're simply not worth it.
- shmerl 14y agoHow many users use 100% of functionality of MS Office? And what part of functionality most users use? We were not talking about drop in replacements, were were talking about satisfying enough needs of a common user. There always can be cases of some functionality lacking. But for common needs - Libre Office is way more than enough already. Google's options are way too limited comparing to desktop applications, but they work well for some use cases. I find Libre Office more than satisfactory for above average complexity document editing. And while it can lack some obscure functions of MS office, I just probably never needed them in the first place.
- josteink 14y agoYou'll have to read my comment as me talking, as a reasonably capable user, which normally merely access around 5% of what I know MS Office can do. Just basic things like creating sections, chapters, tables, footers, headers and making it all look good and consistent, quickly and easily. MS Office, since the move to the ribbon-system have really excelled at exposing the functionality required to do this. It's always there in your face, just one click away, when you need it and then it gets out of your way. It's fantastic. Libre Office and its forks are still stuck in the last generation of UIs where you have a million toolbars, all just mediocrely capable and insufficient to your full needs, none adapted to your current context and always there taking up space and cluttering the UI wheter you need them or not. There's just no comparison between the user experiences here. MS Office is in a league of its own.
- shmerl 14y agoUI unfamiliarity is not equal to the lack of functionality in the program itself. Comfortable feeling about UI is also a subjective matter to a degree, so what works well for some is irritating for others.
- josteink 14y agoSure. That is a factor. But the reason Microsoft moved from the safe (familiar) UI to the new one was because they realized the old UI-model didn't scale well with expanded functionality. They decided to try to improve the user experience by leaving behind what clearly did not work. For a company which owes most of its legacy to users preferring familiarity, that's very much not a small thing. But they decided it had to be done. More than five years later, Libre Office still haven't done anything at all to fundamentally improve UX. To me that sounds like somebody simply not caring.
- fmoralesc 14y agoI agree. Making a turn like Office did with the ribbon interface was a bold, commendable move. Sadly (Libre/Open)Office can't follow suit unless they design and develop a good alternative to it, which is not an easy task. And because of patents, they couldn't simply build upon the ribbon UX.
- shmerl 14y agoI think they care, but they have their constraints. They'd rather polish and add important functionality first, rather than radically redo the whole design. After the LibreOffice / OpenOffice split it's still probably not at the point of such step. But I'm sure at some point they'll address it.