4 ms·
Allow me to say, as a regular user of a tiling window manager, that they have more than a few shortcomings. Shortcomings which go beyond defaults and shortcuts.
by sliverstorm 14y ago
Allow me to say, as a regular user of a tiling window manager, that they have more than a few shortcomings. Shortcomings which go beyond defaults and shortcuts.
- Many applications are designed with a floating environment in mind, and as a result simply translate very poorly to a tiling environment.
- If I'm working with more than three or four windows (which is common) I've basically got my active window and a stack of non-active, tiny, non-useable windows. In other words, it becomes difficult to combine even a medium-size set of windows with a usage model wherein I wish to interact with 2-3 medium size windows simultaneously.
- Often in a floating environment, I can overlap windows, maximizing utilized screen space by covering up unimportant parts of a certain window.
There are basically two reasons I keep using a tiling WM. First, it does pretty well with term emulators. Second, the existence of tabbed term emulators. The ability to spawn and destroy tabs on a whim without changing the screen layout really helps with my thought flow. If I was really a purist I'd be using GNU screen for that, but at that point what am I doing in X11 anyway?
- willholloway 14y ago> If I'm working with more than three or four windows (which is common) I've basically got my active window and a stack of non-active, tiny, non-useable windows. In other words, it becomes difficult to combine even a medium-size set of windows with a usage model wherein I wish to interact with 2-3 windows simultaneously. This is my biggest issue as well. I would like a way to hide these windows and take them out of my next/previous stack. Out of all the tiling WMs out there I feel one has to have this feature but I've been so happy with ratpoison otherwise I haven't looked.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- sliverstorm 14y agoI feel like a tiling WM could really benefit from a taskbar-like metaphor. It doesn't have to be precisely a taskbar, but the ability to make this or that application completely invisible without sending it to another virtual desktop is often useful. Perhaps, to stay in keeping with the ability to do everything from the keyboard, treat the "taskbar" like a second stack, only reduced to names instead of shrunken windows.
- aerique 14y agoCheck out i3. It can do what you want (if I get what you're writing). I never liked tiling window managers using the master-slave paradigm (like xmonad does) precisely because of the problems you both described. http://i3wm.org/screenshots/ http://i3wm.org/screenshots/ (check the screencast and skip to 2:55 for examples of the different layouts)
- sliverstorm 14y agoArgh. It looks interesting, but the dependencies are killing me; we use an unusual system for managing libraries, and i3 doesn't have a very intelligent config engine...
- aerique 14y agoAh too bad, I wasn't aware of that since I just get it through my package manager.