4 ms·
Whoa. Backup. This whole thread commentary is off point. You: I don't understand, therfore I'm right What kind of logic is this? Its a non-falsifiable hypo
by 001sky 14y ago
Whoa. Backup.
This whole thread commentary is off point.
You: I don't understand, therfore I'm right
What kind of logic is this?
Its a non-falsifiable hypothesis.
I cannot prove you understand, if you don't.
I'm not here to hypothesize on why thats the case.
I'm not here to lecture you on art history
I'm not here to demonstrate digital image editing
I'm not here to make you understand
I'm here to share information for those that can put it to use.
If you have no need for this, just find another topic.
At a basic level, you don't have a very good understanding of this subject matter. You can admit that, or you can argue. Nobody cares.
Its useful for HN, though, to answer some of the questions you pose. Because, whether or not you are worthy or capable of understanding things, other people might be.
So, don't flatter yourself too much. I don't have the time to explain or reply to all the stupid shit in these posts. I've tried to skip over most of it and make lemonade out of lemons.
Example 1: Quantify the use of XYZ digital editing technique
The fact that you (1) asked this in the first place; and (2) attempt to use it as a "gotcha" to prove how smart you are is truly a great example of Irony.
How can one quantify these effects? I don't think a histogram will do it, since that's global. How can I use digital tools to determine whether these procedures have been used on an image?...What I see is the most direct interpretation and insubstantial modification of the source material. Could you direct me to what I'm missing?
Again, we need to rethink this...
Translation: And when I say "we" I mean "you" and when I say "re-think" I mean "think" of something useful to say.
So, consider I am not trying to answer your question.
Instead, I put forth a simple way for someone with the right skillset, to make some progress. If you fail, you fail. In essence, my only job I'm taking on her is to put a framework in place that migh be useful to someone that has the potential to understand, and the need.
If you don't understand this, no worries.
I think you may have overstated your case. Instead of letting it drop, you have dug in deeper and deeper, as if you could convince without evidence.
I'm not making a case. The images are "photoshopped". You asked to tell how to see artifacts of this. The way to do that is to compare and do an A/B test. I set that up for you. In 30 minutes I found a contemporary image to use. You're missing the point of why I did this.
The image is an obvious photoshop-orama. Its an award winning press photo. Exhibition quality. But--and this is important--its editorial quality. Than means, that its "interpretive" and true to scene. It could go in the NY times front page or whatever.
The point is this: So, even if they were exactly photoshopped exactly alike, they still are "objective" or whatever. If that's something important to you.
So, who cares if you want to make another one yourself? There are an infinite number of possible prints? You're not adding anything to the conversation. You're also skipping over that the digital scanning process. Which is not a neutral process. That nuetral image has been heavily edited. Atc etc....
The purpose is to understand this: We can make these images in photoshop. The original photgrapher could not. He could never see an sRGB colour output space, on an OLED calibrated LCD screen. None of those colours that went into 16 bit ProPhoto RGB and got moved all over the place, he would have never seen. The N-space images of gursky he could never have imagined. The localized N-space sharpening and color contraste every rookie with photoshop does, he could never have imagined. Simple, stupid shit that is in every WorldPressPhotoIntenatinoal photo, he would have never even imaginged, much less ever saw. Is that good or bad? Neither. It just is the way it is.
His images would have been made in a colour space available to him in 1910. His colour-filtered lanterns would define the colors he saw. It was likely a modest colour space, but I have no idea how efficient his gels were. Etc. and to be honest, I sort of don't care. It would have been cool as shit, for him. As history, its genius that he made the seperations.
But, lifelike or not. The stuff on that webpage, the stuff HB is/was commenting on, what modern photoshop. Its art, but its a different medium. I won't tell you if that is good or bad. But its different, that's for sure. Its not really a debate. Its not like kodachrome or whatever. Its a different ballgame.
The only purpose of this sub-thread was to note this as a relevant consideration. And furthermore, to explain some of this to intellectually interested HN readers. 99.99 percent of the world might be clueless to this. I'm still sorta surprised that the HN crowd may or may not be any better.
- michrassena 14y agoI simply asked for an objective demonstration of this process, this dazzling that Photoshop is capable of that tilts our senses on their side and takes us over with rapture. The fact is, the images were made in the color space of nature. The limitation was precisely the latitude of the plates when exposed to light which had been band-pass filtered to allow red, green and blue light to pass. What the precise details of those filters and the respective sensitivity of the plates to those spectra are, I can't say. Obviously it was panchromatic or we wouldn't have a red channel. Here's an image which shows how snugly the sRGB color space fits within the real of visual perception. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Colorspace.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Colorspace.png It sure is cozy in there. What we have in front of us is still an approximation of the colors of nature and that we can perceive. Here's some samples of fluorescent paint http://www.goldenpaints.com/products/color/fluorescent/fluor.php http://www.goldenpaints.com/products/color/fluorescent/fluor... Now I don't know anything the history of fluorescent paint and whether it was around in Prokudin-Gorksy's lifetime. But I know for certain he could have seen it if it had and noticed its intensity. I hope you notice that the photographs of the paint on the website are not themselves fluorescent. This is because we can perceive colors that the screen can't show, even if you have the latest Cinema Display. Also, go online and look up some gold or copper. Then look at the real thing. Good luck getting the computer to produce that color. Fact is, producing these colors is hard, and done with spot color when printing. That doesn't make it outside the realm of perception. What you're basically arguing is that the film couldn't have possibly captured the colors we see here, and that they were invented by the restoration process. So, I'll ask again for quantification. This is the digital realm we're discussing. What I'm not asking for is the quantification of taste or feeling, or even of perception, in spite of this discussion. There are so hard numbers underneath all of this. It would be interesting to see a side-by-side comparison of the same image with the pixels that are impossible in this alleged early 20th century color space highlighted. However, I think you've successfully moved the goalposts past what we are capable of knowing directly. By alleging that these 16-bit TIFF grayscale images created in the scanning process are themselves heavily manipulated, we have come to a stopping point. There's no way I can get my hands on the originals in order to ascertain whether you are correct. (However note that the images were scanned is grayscale, perhaps using sGray as the color model, is it the fact that you also assert that sGray contains more colors than Prokudin-Gorksy could have perceived or captured on his plates?) Aside from your clever dismissal of the "original" as far as we are able to obtain it, the 16-bit color-separated TIFFs, is it possible at all to bring these images into a computer and respect their original "limited" nature and bring that presentation to a computer screen? Because if it is not, then what is the point? Your assertion that we are in love with Photoshop, not the work itself is basically moot. What you are offering up as an explanation of the compelling content of the work is in fact so commonplace as to encompass all of digital media. The powers granted Photoshop in this discussion to smudge the original color working space into realms impossible in the original are in fact so pervasive that to draw them out in this discussion is merely an excuse to talk about your pet theories about digital media and have nothing whatever to do with this work under discussion.