These two things are contradictory: 1. "He can generally write very solid code that's readable and handles edge cases beautifully." 2. "you can't get a clear

These two things are contradictory: 1. "He can generally write very solid code that's readable and handles edge cases beautifully." 2. "you can't get a clear thought out of him without rambling incoherence surrounding it" It would be better to talk from actual experience than to invent things that don't exist, in support of a point that must necessarily therefore be bogus.