6 ms·
My Failures Onboarding at Splunk
- subpixel 1y agoAll other things aside this author is not a good enough communicator to be a director where I work. That this is an ad actually makes the grammar issues worse.
- mhedgpeth 1y agoFrom the author: yeah the failures I outlined were ... failures for sure! I'm not in the market for a director position at your company, but if I were I'd hope to find a place wanting people to have an honest assessment of what worked and what didn't and how they grew from it. If that's disqualifying I worry that you'll get people who are lying to you. I'm sorry it came across as an ad, I'm full-time in a bootstrapped company working to try to solve this problem without any VC funding. It was a problem for me and for many people I know so I thought I'd share it in hopes to help people. Also the grammar part here is interesting, I purposely write without AI because I think that's important, but I'd love your help in making it better - reach out on LinkedIn if you can. Thanks :)
- GOD_Over_Djinn 1y agoYeah, the writing and overall narrative are lacking. I got to the end of the piece and thought to myself: “wait, that’s it?”
- tjolu 1y agoDoes it make you happy to be so rude and condescending?
- subpixel 1y agoI just call em like I see em.
- firesteelrain 1y agoI am really disappointed. On one hand this was settling in as a good lesson learned blog post but ended up looking like the stuff you see on LinkedIn every day wrapped up as an ad.
- gafotech 1y agoSame here. I honestly enjoyed reading it and didn't expect an ad to slap me in the face.
- sethammons 1y agoAnd what a slap, right out of left field. Drop that one, final paragraph and the post is fantastic. The paragraph only barely, tangentially links to the conclusion paragraph above it. No lead up or reference in the post. And you are left dazed. I don't even know what this supposed tool would do even slightly. A hard souring of trust built up in the article.
- dasil003 1y agoYes there is a common theme of not “bringing people along”.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- chihuahua 1y agoYeah I'm not sure what an onboarding tool is going to do for a guy who gets hired, decides from day 1 that he must be promoted immediately, makes other peoples' lives miserable by showing to his manager that he's "aggressively" doing something before he even understands what's going on, and whines constantly about not being promoted within a few months.
- fijiaarone 1y agoIt’s like the lesson told in the paragraph above “this is what my team did” and imply “and I am their manager”. This is what I learned and imply “and I can help you learn too”
- dsr_ 1y agoWhen I was in big corps, I understood but really disliked the idea that people would do work in order to get a promotion. That's the only incentive structure they've set up, so that's what you do. What I like about well-run small companies is that there is essentially no chance of a promotion: all we can do is do our work better, improve processes and make our customers (internal and external) happier. If you hook monetary rewards to title and responsibility treadmills, you lose all that. Hypergrowth is a trap.
- wahnfrieden 1y agoIt’s because owners hoard the equity so workers have minimal stake in outcomes (usually the chance of the company tanking resulting in job loss is not a primary motivator or perceived risk either). Small companies that aren’t worker-owned and without promotion ladders aren’t immune to this. They get workers who strive toward promotion via job switching. You can debate the fairness of equity hoarding by those who invest money into the business but it doesn’t change the worker dynamics
- sokoloff 1y agoEmployees are often not in a position (financially or sometimes legally) to take a reduction in cash in order to take an increased proportion of their value in equity.
- wahnfrieden 1y agoWho decides that tradeoff? You are only reinforcing why workers have no stake in outcomes. Worker-owned organizations afford both
- alemanek 1y agoThat is an interesting point. Co-ops seem like they should out perform from a worker incentive point of view. But, why are co-ops basically non-existent in Big Tech. WinCo, groceries, and REI, expensive outdoor stuff, in the US are both big co-ops but are retailers. Maybe VC money warps the economics so that every company needs to be winner takes all lotto tickets for the investors. Having it be worker owned gets rid of the extreme ROÍ VCs expect. If you know any papers on the subject I would be interested though.
- MrDarcy 1y agoSplunk has been around nearly 20 years. I’d hardly call them a high growth tech company.
- firesteelrain 1y agoNot all certainly but many enterprises use them and it feels like Splunk is printing money. The cost for log ingestion is high. But, it’s highly trusted and other Splunk killers like ELK stacks haven’t caught on everywhere.
- mooreds 1y agoCisco saw enough value to buy it for $28 B as part of their security portfolio: https://strategyofsecurity.com/p/ciscos-cybersecurity-shopping-spree-part-1 https://strategyofsecurity.com/p/ciscos-cybersecurity-shoppi...
- firesteelrain 1y agoRight that’s my point. Licenses for log ingestion with Splunk are $$$$. As opposed to rolling your own (and probably not passing an audit)
- betaby 1y ago> and probably not passing an audit What kind of audit one might not pass? People use all kind of log solution all the time without any problems.
- firesteelrain 1y agoAnything have to do with RMF
- lelanthran 1y agoWhat's RMF?
- zug_zug 1y agoWeird to have a bit of a window into the cryptic world of directorial promotions. Sounds like it’s mostly about self promotion sadly and perhaps unsurprisingly.
- mhedgpeth 1y agoFrom the author of the post: it looks that way at first, but it's honestly about aligning people all around you. The true self promoters don't keep their eye on the ball of universal success. I think I didn't study the actions of the people enough, a point I was trying to make in the post. If I would have I would have made better decisions.
- 46Bit 1y agoI agree, it's an interesting view. I found it quite positive about the culture in that part of Splunk. The writer parachuted in, threw their weight around, bruised a bunch of people, but lost out to another manager who openly acknowledged the contributions of their people.
- hariwb 1y agoI think many readers here have had a pretty negative experience with a new manager parachuting in (usually as a referral from other senior leadership), immediately deciding that the team is underperforming without knowing much about the business context, technical constraints, and company culture that led to the current environment, and making big structural changes without consulting the boots-on-the-ground folks. Usually we hear stories from the engineers who are disaffected. This feels like an anecdote from the other side. It's not wrong to wonder about your career trajectory, but it's telling to see someone pretty nakedly talk about optimizing for changing their level at a company, before they've even landed there and evaluated if they can help / how they are helping their team. I'm not naive, and I recognize those people exist and can acknowledge that they can do good work. But if someone came into my workplace with the mindset of "aggressively [seeking] to showcase my leadership within the first few weeks" and their goal was going "from Senior Manager to Director in ... 12 months", I'd be skeptical that they weren't going to damage peer relationships and optimize for being recognized at the expense of their direct reports, even if I thought they could be a valuable asset in the short term.
- mhedgpeth 1y agoI'm the author of the post. Yeah you got it right, I think the hiring process got me into that mindset, i.e. "This is a step back from you title-wise but you'll get back there quickly". So the hiring process made all that look too easy and in retrospect got me into the wrong state of mind. What I should have done, at the point of being hired, is to drop all that, and focus patiently on what I needed to do. And I'm sharing it because not enough people share this side of it, and because I am working on elements that would have made it better. Thanks for reading! :)
- fijiaarone 1y agoI definitely thought like the first commenter at first but the realization that you admitted what you did wrong and accepted responsibility for it really won my over by the end of your post.
- senkora 1y ago
- theptip 1y ago> and therefore aggressively sought to showcase my leadership within the first few weeks I feel this is as close to “Management 101” as it gets, or even “employee-ing 101”, as it applies to technical roles too. Don’t do it! Just write down your list of gripes for the first month; use them as your list of things to ramp up on. If something seems odd or wrong, it may be actually broken, but it’s unlikely to be so urgent that you have to go out on a limb like this. It’s more likely that there is some context you are missing. By Chesterton’s Fence you need to spend some energy to understand why the thing was put there, before you tear it down. Even if you are right - you will face an uphill battle because you haven’t built trust yet. So pick your battles carefully!
- philjohn 1y agoThe "WTF" list technique is great for this. Every time you see, or encounter, something that makes you go "WTF?!??" you write it down. Chances are you don't have NEARLY enough context yet to figure out why it's like that, and so barelling in to "fix" it is just going to lead to frustration and bruised ego's all around. After a few months you'll either have crossed off things "Oh, THAT's WTF" or you have a list of things to start chipping away at, now that you have the FULL context.
- mhedgpeth 1y agoFrom the author of the post: 100% I knew this advice but didn't follow it. Being patient early on is SO important! I think the hard thing is as on engineer you're paid to have the "right" answer, but as a manager you're paid not to be right but to bring all the "right answers" together. That's a subtle but important shift.
- rhyperior 1y agoRelationships drive business success and recognition. The author seemingly didn’t know how to establish critical relationships as the new kid on the block. Common mistake in the technical world, one I’ve made myself.
- nwride 1y agoJust a quick bit of feedback for the author: your website loads really poorly, at least on mobile. All the content loads immediately but the hamburger menu sits over the screen and won't go away until the final 25% is done. It does this for every page I tried. Takes almost a minute.
- mhedgpeth 1y ago[dead]
- afro88 1y ago> Another Director at Splunk told me his process: he wrote down everything good that his teams did in a doc, and then every Friday sent that out on Slack celebrating their achievements. Implied in the whole exercise was "and I am leading this group of people", but he never said that because he didn't need to. This person got promoted to Sr. Director. He had a process that he regularly followed to a T that was borne out of a deep understanding of the culture around him. Without knowing this Sr Director, I have to wonder if this is actually the take away they were trying to offer. If a senior engineering manager isn't regularly celebrating their team's wins, being proud if their achievements and recognising the smart and hard work, providing exposure to the rest of the company, then there's something amiss. If the take away really was "do this and you will make yourself look good for a promotion" then, yuuuuuck.
- ajkjk 1y agothis person's whole worldview seems really gross. Like they have swallowed the entire framework of growth-oriented capitalism uncritically and reorganized themselves completely around maximizing their returns. Fortunately the world is still somewhat human, so they failed catastrophically---but they're trying. Even their attempt at reflection is a shameful ad.
- fijiaarone 1y agoNCR maintains legacy POS systems with a mostly outsourced labor force. Splunk maintains a logging aggregator with a mostly San Francisco staff. A manager’s job at NCR is mostly about cracking the whip to try to get your team to solve boring enterprise client technical problems, but they usually don’t have enough context to understand the problem. A manager’s job at Splunk is to motivate a team that used to work at a hip, fast growing startup who just got their payout from an Cisco acquisition and feel like the product is getting sidelined.