7 ms·
Ask HN: The Downvote
At a certain threshold of Karma (~500), A new HN user will receive the ability to Downvote. Athough per-user Karma is visible, it is so only for your own account and on a net-basis. Meanwhile, the reaction to other user's comments is only visible indirectly, via page rank. Having now a more than theoretical interest, I ask you for your Advice.
Ask HN:
What "Applied Philosophy" do you live by on Downvoting?
How do you use it?
How have you seen it being used? Against you or Others. Etc.
The end goal being a reference:
(1) Increase the data available to any given user from 1 experience (his own) to N experiences; and
(2) Articulate as appropriate best practices and/or debate areas of contention, etc.
Look forward to your thoughts.
- mparlane 14y agoI only really downvote people who set out to be dicks. And no that doesn't mean I downvote people who give constructive criticism or a differing opinion.
- erichocean 14y agoI've adopted the policy for my own comments to delete (immediately) any comment that gets a downvote. I wonder how many other people do that. I do find it discouraging how quick people are to downvote things they don't personally agree with, rather than simply downvoting noise, spam, or low-quality comments. :( (I cannot downvote people myself.)
- masterzora 14y agoI've adopted the policy for my own comments to delete (immediately) any comment that gets a downvote. I wonder how many other people do that. Despite believing downvotes exist as a means of labeling content as not belonging here I hate when people delete their comments in response to any number of downvotes. Generally speaking, once you've added your comment it's become a part of the history of the discussion and I don't like said history being removed. Further, while I could see a certain nobility in people removing a comment because they see the community says it doesn't belong, most people doing so just don't want to harm their Imaginary Internet Point total and I have a strong distaste for people who put too much stock into that number.
- jcr 14y agoI'm fairly lenient. I can't read minds, so if someone is technically wrong (or wrong in my opinion), I will never down-vote them. My reason is simple; they might be entirely sincere and believe they're contributing even though they're unknowingly wrong and unfortunately spreading misinformation. If I have better information, I post it, politely, and with references if at all possible. If it's a matter of differing opinions (not facts), then it's best to just quietly let it slide. I didn't come here for an argument, or lessons in getting hit over the head (sorry for the Monte Python reference). Additionally, I don't need to agree with someone to appreciate the time they took to share and post their views. Even if I never agree with them, I benefit from knowing how the other side(s) sees things. If someone is being rude or intentionally insulting, that's good for at least a down-vote, and possibly a flag if it's egregious. Both flagging too much, and down-voting too much does have effects on your account. The precise mechanics including the value of "too much" have never been made public. I can't prove this in code that's actually running on HN (no public), but there's an ancient post by pg that mentions it. I could probably dig it up from my notes if anyone needs further confirmation... But, who's to say pg hasn't changed things in the years between that old post and now? It makes sense that there's a price to pay for abusive flagging and down-voting. If you spend a lot of time on the 'new' page (/newest queue) and flag the spam as it happens, you could very well trip the abusive flagging threshold. On the other hand, if you do trip the threshold, and pg/mods see that you're actually trying to help out with the spam, they'll be thankful rather than upset. Some down-votes are entirely unintentional. The voting UI/UX has issues in mobile environments where small screens and large fingers result in miscast votes. It wasn't so long ago that I saw Joey Flores (YC funded - earbits.com) apologize to pg for accidentally down-voting him, so it indeed happens to the very best of HN users. As you might expect, the result of miscast votes is some voting patterns you see are actually somewhat random. Adding to the randomness are language barriers causing misinterpretations. Also adding to the randomness are quickly written and poorly communicated comments. Even when you mean well, others might not understand what you wrote. Off the top of my head, I think it was you (001sky) who recently replied to one of my posts, and I didn't really understand your comment... Yep, it was you: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4493615 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4493615 Maybe it's written perfectly and I'm the sole cause of my failure to understand? ;-) But anyhow, the point is, miscommunication happens constantly and it is one of the causes of down-votes. My ability to type comes and goes due to my health, so I don't post or contribute very much. When I do post, I rarely get down-voted. I might get one down-vote in fifty posts or so. I do keep a very close eye on the score of my posts, and if I notice a down-vote, I'll dig in my comments to see where it occurred. Since I know about the randomness problems in voting patterns, I never take a down-vote personally. For all I know, it could have been an intended up-vote that went wrong, or someone in the habit of down-voting for mere disagreement of opinions. Even if someone down-votes me out of mere disagreement, it's still useful feedback. The best practice for debates on matters of contention is simple; be certain to give the other person both polite respect and the benefit of the doubt on their intentions. Some people will still react in rude and insulting ways if you politely pose a tough question, or dare to offer an opposing view to their imaginary authority. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4489017 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4489017 It's just one of the risks to open forums. Some people think being rude and insulting (i.e. "mean" in pg-speak) will somehow make their point more convincing and help them "win" --whatever that means. It's very unfortunate, but it's just part of life when interacting with others.
- kevinconroy 14y agoAs a user who's been around for over a year, I've recently decided to get more active in the commenting community here on HN as I've found it to be incredibly valuable and wanted to make meaningful contributions. I quickly learned that comments based solely on humor tend to fall flat and get downvoted. Also, being overly negative and not offering something productive to the conversation will get you downvoted quickly. Overall I've found the feedback of downvotes to be helpful and it's directly responsible for me raising the caliber of my comments rather than writing the funny responses that I initially think of. I tend now to just write them in the comment box, chuckle to myself, delete them, and then (try to) add something worthwhile to the conversation. Everyone wins!
- jasonkester 14y agoSimple: I never downvote for disagreement. If somebody's wrong, people will tell him (or I will). If he's wrong repeatedly you can tell by looking at how deep he's getting in a thread. Downvotes, in my opinion, are to indicate things that don't belong here. Usually because of tone, sometimes because it's a one-line throwaway comment that doesn't add anything or is a joke (that also doesn't add anything). I think this is sort of the consensus way of downvoting here. Sure, there are people just arrived from other forums with different norms who still downvote for disagreement, but they're the minority and they tend to change their ways once they realize it. The end result is that if you find yourself being downvoted, it's usually because of the way you made your point rather than the point itself. The exception being certain contentious topics that to be honest don't belong here anyway (global warming debate, apple vs. android, etc.) that are more likely to attract the newly arrived "downvote for disagreement" crowd.
- dholowiski 14y agoI downvote something when it's really stupid or not useful. I very rarely downvote, and I really don't care if I get downvoted. I'm not here to earn karama, I'm here to discuss hacker stuff. If I have 10 karma or 100,000 I'm going to have just as much fun.