3 ms·
All regulation is hard to enforce. Have to start somewhere, and then you keep pulling the ratchet via policy.
by toomuchtodo 1y ago
All regulation is hard to enforce. Have to start somewhere, and then you keep pulling the ratchet via policy.
- mothballed 1y agoIf you create regulation you can't effectively enforce it can actually make things worse. This is why you can buy fentanyl on every corner, but now the people supplying it have small nation-state tier armies of guys in hiluxes with machine guns and truck mounted .50 cal anti-armor guns. Not saying that will happen with ghost jobs, but it's not a given things will improve.
- pessimizer 1y agoI have absolutely no idea why you think this regulation would be any harder to implement than any other regulation other than a hand-wavy brief first sentence in your first comment. I have no idea what sort of juggling of job titles you're predicting that will deceive anyone for more than 10 seconds. I have no idea what 1st amendment issue you see in advertising for an employment contract that isn't backed by employment; if you advertise asthma medicine that doesn't have any effect on asthma, people understand that it's fraud. Also, it seems that you're making a parallel case that it makes no difference to the fentanyl market that there is a law against fentanyl, which makes me think that you apply the Law of Averages to every change that you hear anyone suggest. e.g. if you make a law against fentanyl, some people will stop selling fentanyl, while other people will be more attracted to selling an illegal drug, therefore a law against fentanyl will have no effect on fentanyl use or sales. The Law of Averages is not real.
- mothballed 1y agoI haven't argued a single thing in the straw man you've attacked. I haven't even speculated whether regulation against ghost jobs would be effective. The thing about the 1A and law of averages is totally out of left field and seem like you're taking up issues with some other comment.
- terminalshort 1y agoWhich is why it should not be used to prevent minor annoyances like wasting a few minutes applying for a job that isn't there.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoThis is not a minor annoyance, this consumes time and resources both for candidates at scale and diminishes the integrity of data from a labor economics perspective ("open jobs"). It is arguably fraud and should be prosecuted as such (and I'm fairly confident this case can be made to an electorate who isn't going to shrug off even more corporate malfeasance in a softening labor market).