7 ms·
I didn't feel bad for Timothy Treadwell when he got eaten by a grizzly bear as covered in the film, Grizzly Man. It was almost expected given his actions.
by dmix 14y ago
I didn't feel bad for Timothy Treadwell when he got eaten by a grizzly bear as covered in the film, Grizzly Man. It was almost expected given his actions.
- ktizo 14y agoI felt bad for him, but not surprised at the outcome. But when grizzly bears ate Timothy Treadwell, they were not deliberately trying to be malicious, at least as far as we know.
- 3143 14y agoWho's to say that 4chan users, too, are not simply motivated by instinct, knowing neither malice or conscience?
- andreasvc 14y agoNo, because it's bloody obvious that they're doing things specifically to hurt people. Humans don't desecrate graves by instinct, that requires malice, I'd say.
- 3143 14y agoHurting other people is an instinct.
- andreasvc 14y agoCitation? I was under the impression that humans do not have instincts.
- davyjones 14y agoThe suckling action of infants is an instinct; not learned.
- andreasvc 14y agoThat's a reflex, which is different from an instinct. In any case, I think the rather creative behaviors of hurting people in this case are obviously learned.
- xyzzyz 14y agoHumans are just another species of animals, why wouldn't they have an instinct? The only difference is the cultural conditioning, which suppresses instinct behavior.
- andreasvc 14y agoBecause humans have such a capacity for learning, instincts would serve no purpose. Instincts are rigid and humans on the contrary are very adaptable. It appears to me that the scientific consensus is that there are no human instincts, but if you believe otherwise why don't you cite an example?
- Radix_ 14y agoMating. The route to get there becomes more flexible due to our adaptability but the desire to have sex is instinctual.
- andreasvc 14y agoWell again I'd say that's not an instinct, just like hunger it's a desire. An instinct is a very specific pre-programmed behavior that can't be overridden, a desire or reflex doesn't fit that description.
- andrewfelix 14y agoBullshit, we're social animals. That's what makes primates so distinct. Obviously there are exceptions, which these 4chan numbnuts have exemplified, but generally we're good at socialising and being friendly with another.
- 3143 14y agoAn effective way to be friendly with another person is by collaborating to hurt a third party.
- andreasvc 14y agoThat's a pretty callous thing to say. How do you get from a person was being misguided to they deserved their horrible fate?
- dmix 14y agoI try to evaluate things rationally. Just as I give both Timothy (who had spent 13 summer living among bears) and this girl (who as the article says was an old time /b/ user) the benefit of the doubt, that they rationally knew the extreme dangers that existed. There's already enough tragedy that happens in this world - due to pure circumstance and things out of our control. I only have a limited amount of energy and time on this planet. My empathy is better spent on the latter individuals than on those who knowingly put themselves in direct danger of being harmed.
- ktizo 14y agoI think empathy is more of an experience you feel when confronted with a situation or story, rather than something you grant to people after a process of logical judgement.
- dmix 14y agoI disagree that empathy can only be the result of an emotional response and not rational thought.
- andreasvc 14y agoBut that's how it's generally defined, e.g. wikipedia: "Empathy is the capacity to recognize feelings that are being experienced by another sentient [...] being." -- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empathy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empathy
- dmix 14y agoAlthough tempting, debating the meaning of empathy is probably not a beneficial contribution to this HN thread. But I will say, the initial emotional response (for ex. feeling sad someone was harmed) is largely out of our control. But spending time feeling bad after the fact is a controllable state, and is the basis of a large amount of psychological and behavioral therapy.