12 ms·
The Relativity of Wrong (1988)
- lionkor 1y agoThis was a very fun read. Any other recommendations similar to this?
- gradschool 1y agoLockhart's Lament
- glenstein 1y agoFor a second I thought this was an invocation of one of those informal "laws" (like a Murphys Law or Sturgeons Law), describing the feeling of finding one great thing and lamenting that there's no more like it. So the hope of it being your discovery of a rich genre turns into the lament that it's one of one (how I feel about the Three Body Problem). But no, it's a real book. And looks like a great suggestion from what I can tell on wiki.
- business_liveit 1y agoYes, This was a very very very fun read.........
- jebarker 1y agoHe’s not wrong
- pearlsontheroad 1y ago"...when I say I am glad that I live in a century when the Universe is essentially understood, I think I am justified." Funny how we don't even fully understand what happens when we crack our joints but are certain about how the Universe "essentially" works.
- nathan_compton 1y agoWell, let me ask you: when your joints crack do you think the process involves something other than physics at its most basic level? You may take it from my posing the question that I think its obvious that joint cracking is determined by physics, and I do tend to think this, but I think a compelling argument can at least be made that joint cracking might not actually be fundamentally determined by physics.
- MangoToupe 1y agoWe don't even know if the laws of physics are constant. In fact, it is literally unknowable. > a compelling argument can at least be made Absolutely! But it takes a good deal of hubris to call this knowledge.
- jibal 1y agoIt takes a good deal of hubris to deny it.
- sophacles 1y agoWe don't even know if the gods are real... in fact it is literally unknowable. An yet... you're claiming to know what the gods like and don't like. Strange.
- pixl97 1y agoA better way I like to say it is. Everything prove able by religion is not unique to religion. Everything unique to religion is not proveable.
- glenstein 1y agoApologies in advance if I'm missing your point (I might be!) but... If it turns out that the laws are not constant, our present understanding would be retained as a special case of a broader theory and the local predictive capabilities would still be real in their scope. And leveraging a "we don't know" to cash out as affirmative skepticism tries to make the absence of data do more than it can. As you noted, the degree of uncertainty we're currently wrestling with is also what we would see if it was true that the laws were constant. Kind of like an anthropic principle but on behalf of the constancy of the universe's laws. This may all be restating what you said in a different way, but for me the important upshot is that I don't come out of it with an attitude that our current physical understanding is a tenuous house of cards and that I need to watch my step because, who knows, the strong nuclear force could change at any moment.
- nathan_compton 1y agoAll I can say about this as a dude with a doctorate in physics and an interest in foundations is: I guess, dude, if this is how you want to live your life. It isn't that I agree with the person who wrote Asimov the letter (in fact, based on his description, I frankly wonder if the letter writer wasn't my father). Its just that there is something subtly wrong with Asimov's view of the progress of scientific knowledge. At least its extremely instrumentalist. If we think of knowledge as a sort of temporary mental state which lives between setting up a physical state and making a measurement, then, yes, knowledge has progressed in exactly the way that Asimov is saying. And that is nothing to sneeze at. But like consider quantum mechanics. People still cannot make heads or tails of what the ontology of quantum mechanics is, despite some compelling stories. And that makes perfect sense since QM is not compatible with special or general relativity! So its dumb to try and make sense of what QM tells us about what is. So why not try to understand what the ontology of QFT is? This seems reasonable, since QFT is capable of making correct predictions (at least in the scattering regime) and is invariant. But no one on earth can write down a coherent mathematical theory of QFT, so interpretation is even more difficult than QM. And this is yet to even try to tackle with conceptual gap between GR and QM/QFT, where we genuinely are perplexed but at least have good reason to think that the final interpretation of QM or spacetime has to have something to do with the way that the two theories interact. From this point of view as our ability to connect experiment with outcome has increased our ability to actually say what it is we are even talking about outside of the purely instrumental has decreased since the 19th Century. Back then we though we knew that there were atoms or electrons or whatever. Light waves or photons. Now, I would argue very strenuously, we genuinely have no understanding at all of what those things are outside of a set of purely instrumental definitions which leave a lot to be desired. My personal understanding here is that really there are no electrons, photons, quantum fields, masses, gravity. There is just the single substance of the universe which we have learned to manipulate and predict with ever improving precision (in limited cases). Maybe that is knowledge? Doesn't always feel like it.
- kitchi 1y agoAs another dude with a doctorate in Physics, I have to disagree with you (at least somewhat). > From this point of view as our ability to connect experiment with outcome has increased our ability to actually say what it is we are even talking about outside of the purely instrumental has decreased since the 19th Century. Back then we though we knew that there were atoms or electrons or whatever. Light waves or photons. Now, I would argue very strenuously, we genuinely have no understanding at all of what those things are outside of a set of purely instrumental definitions which leave a lot to be desired. I disagree with this entirely. The existence of QFT, and our knowledge of the inconsistency between say GR and the quantum realm does not negate the idea of photons and electrons as real, measurable quantities. The fact that we have GR does not negate the fact that we still use Newtonian gravity in regimes where it is sufficiently accurate. All the new knowledge we have learned still is (and absolutely must be) consistent with our old knowledge that has been proven correct in the regimes that they were proven correct. This is effectively what Asimov is saying (as I understand anyway) - the knowledge that the Earth is a sphere does not invalidate the assumption that the Earth is flat approximately and locally. I would also argue that the only things we can "know" are what you call the instrumental definitions. We only know what we measure. The rest is interpretation, and self-consistent understanding. String theory can tell me that we have several dimensions etc but until we have a way to measure and check it remains a conceptual framework to make predictions, rather than a description of how things really are. GR is much closer to a description. It told us about the precession of mercury, it told us to account for time dilation so we can use GPS satellites. It also predicted black holes, which were conceptually consistent but it's only been in the last ~ 5 years that we have the closest thing yet to experimental verification with the Event Horizon Telescope and gravitational wave measurements. If another theory comes along and explains all of GR with a different explanation for black holes, we will need still more accurate measurements to discriminate between the two theories. Knowledge is only as accurate as we can measure.
- ta2112 1y ago> It is the mark of the marvelous toleration of the Athenians that they let this continue for decades and that it wasn't till Socrates turned seventy that they broke down and forced him to drink poison. Savage.
- glitchc 1y agoSounds like he finally pissed off the wrong guy.
- lcuff 1y agoA philosophy professor I had when I was an undergrad, asked the question "Why did Socrates deliver the Apology in such a way that was clearly unapologetic and designed to annoy the Athenians"? His answer was that he thought Socrates was old and wanted to go out with a bang. I thought his answer had merit, and also that it was an answer I, at 19, would never have come up with. At 70, I go "oh, yeah, baby".
- timerol 1y ago"All models are wrong. Some models are useful." is the way that I have heard this thesis quipped. I suppose "All models are wrong. Some models are more wrong than others." would fit Asimov's points better, but I've never actually heard that one
- nyrikki 1y agoThe map-territory relation is possibly a better fit? More specifically how Alfred Korzybski put it: "The map is not the territory". The map will never be the territory, and we are just looking for better maps.
- procaryote 1y agoAlso, some models aren't even wrong, because they fail to make testable predictions
- toolslive 1y ago"not even wrong" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_even_wrong https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_even_wrong
- nemosaltat 1y agoMy father-in-law, something of a renaissance man, and also a long-time successful commodities trader, regularly uses your latter expression. The first time I heard him say it, I attempted to correct him (“some are useful”) and he confidently brushed me aside. As I’ve matured, I’ve grown confident that his (your) version is less wrong.
- helle253 1y agoIf nothing else, I'm glad one of the great agrees with me that Socrates was a twat. My wife and I always argue about that, she loves Socrates and I find him utterly insufferable. Plato didn't do him any favors.
- lapcat 1y agoIn fairness, I don't think Socrates went around Athens quizzing people chosen randomly on the street. He was having conversations with the wealthy and/or powerful who were also arrogant and considered themselves wise. Making fools of these people is of course what got him into big trouble eventually.
- IAmBroom 1y agoWhich doesn't mean he wasn't an insufferable douche.
- MontyCarloHall 1y ago>In his discussions of such matters as "What is justice?" or "What is virtue?" he took the attitude that he knew nothing and had to be instructed by others. By pretending ignorance, Socrates lured others into propounding their views on such abstractions. Socrates then, by a series of ignorant-sounding questions, forced the others into such a mélange of self-contradictions that they would finally break down and admit they didn't know what they were talking about. See also: Jordan Peterson et al. Our tendency to favor logical correctness over empirical correctness is one of our most dangerous cognitive biases. It's very easy to convince people to believe arguments that are perfectly logically consistent in their own self-constructed reality but have no bearing on empirical reality, over arguments that conform to empirical reality but may not have perfect logical consistency. Empirical reality is messy and it's difficult to construct a perfectly consistent set of axioms around it; constructed reality is neat and thus trivial to construct sets of perfectly consistent axioms around it.
- lapcat 1y agoThis wonderful essay explicitly criticizes one genre of philosophy popular in academic English literature departments, but I think it also implicitly undermines another genre popular in academic English-speaking philosophy departments. The latter frequently propound something like the so-called correspondence theory of truth, yet they also treat truth and falsity as absolutes, mutually exclusive. There's no room for approximation and degrees of accuracy. > The basic trouble, you see, is that people think that "right" and "wrong" are absolute; that everything that isn't perfectly and completely right is totally and equally wrong. However, I don't think that's so. It seems to me that right and wrong are fuzzy concepts > Theories are not so much wrong as incomplete.
- NoSalt 1y agoI wonder if this is where the writers of The Big Bang Theory came up with this conversation: Stuart: Oh, Sheldon, I'm afraid you couldn't be more wrong. Sheldon: More wrong? Wrong is an absolute state and not subject to gradation. Stuart: Of course it is. It's a little wrong to say a tomato is a vegetable, it's very wrong to say it's a suspension bridge.
- nineplay 1y agoWhen my daughter was in middle school we were discussing some concept she learned in Biology that wasn't precisely wrong but wasn't right in all use cases. I told her that a model didn't have to be true to be useful. She said "that's a good way of thinking about it" and since that is such a rare complement from a teenager I have remembered it ever since. I think it's true though. I think a good science teacher can say from the outset that we don't know it all and science is always growing and changing.
- accidentallfact 1y agoIt isn't only about the degree of wrongness, but its type: 1. Vacuous, which provide no useful insight beyond what is obviously deducible. Such as "nearsightedness is caused by the wrong shape of the eye". 2. Vanity, which provide useless elaboration of something that is very well understood in a much simpler form, with no realistic hope of any future insight. Such as most of linguistics. 3. Pointless. Explain something that is difficult to get to know, because it matters so little. While technically correct, the actual facts matter so little that they result in no realistic improvement of any kind, and no decisions are changed as the result of the new knowledge. Such as the age of Earth. 4. Theoretically wrong, those that the article is talking about. Even though theoretically wrong, the are so nearly equivalent to the actual truth, that the difference doesn't matter in practice. 5. Practically wrong. Those that "sound good" so that people stick to them, in spite of massive evidence to the contrary. Such as that obesity is caused by overeating, in spite of the near universal failure in practice, in the last instance of Ozempic making people look like walking corpses, rather than anything like a healthy body. This is the kind of errors meant by those who write to people like Asimov.
- procaryote 1y agoObesity is caused by overeating though, at the very least in the same sense that nearsightedness is caused by the wrong shape of the eye.
- b_e_n_t_o_n 1y agoEnergy intake > energy expenditure, but both intake and expenditure can vary for a variety of reasons uncorrelated with eating habits. Sorry for being pedantic but I think that's what the above commentator meant.
- procaryote 1y ago> Energy intake > energy expenditure Isn't that technically overeating though?
- 1y ago
- wavemode 1y agoThis is an article where I agree with its statements yet disagree with its spirit. Everything written is true, but has to be put in context - the writer he's responding to was challenging these specific claims: > what I meant was that we now know the basic rules governing the Universe ... We also know the basic rules governing the subatomic particles and their interrelationships ... What's more, we have found that the galaxies and clusters of galaxies are the basic units of the physical Universe ... I don't think there's anything wrong with making casual statements of this sort, but I also don't think there's anything wrong with pointing out (in response) that these statements are philosophically unrigorous. I mean, what makes something a "basic rule", and how can you tell that we have apprehended all such rules in existence?
- the_af 1y agoI don't think this is right. The English Lit professor was effectively arguing we cannot know anything; that any certainty is bound to be as false as any debunked theories of the past; that people of the past were also sure of their silly notions and look where they are now; etc. This is what Asimov is essentially rejecting (in a humorous manner; it's important to know Asimov's claims that he's "never wrong" were to be taken with humor. He was quite the comedian). Essentially, Asimov is saying to the professor: - You are wrong in believing nothing can be known. - You are not saying anything new or unknown to people of science. We've thought of this and have ways of testing our ideas and of evaluating their relative merits. - Even if two theories are wrong, it's misleading to conclude "everything is equally wrong, therefore assertions about the universe are reckless", because there are degrees of wrongness, and some knowledge that is wrong is nevertheless more useful than other knowledge that is also wrong. We can never know if this English Lit professor ever existed or is just a rhetorical device by Asimov, but we do know one thing for certain: He/she was wrong. The wrong kind of wrong, too!
- b_e_n_t_o_n 1y agoAllow me to defend the professor here. Asimov is making a couple different claims and attempts to equivocate them, perhaps incorrectly. It's fairly obvious that spelling "sugar" as "sugur" is less wrong compared to spelling it as "afjkdsfk". This is because we have an objectively correct value for "sugar" that we can compare it to. This is different from refining theories and observations over time and declaring that they are less wrong! Take stomach ulcers for example - before modern medicine people didn't know their cause, but were able to somewhat treat them using bismuth compounds. Doctors and scientists refined their theories over the years based on the concept that they are caused by stress, spicy food, and excess stomach acid, developing various cures, until Barry James Marshall discovered that they were actually caused by H. pylori. Before this discovery it would seem reasonable to think we were "less wrong", that because our theories became more refined that we were closer to the truth. As theories of the universe become more uh, theoretical, we cannot accurately measure and gain a sense of if we are moving closer or farther from the truth. Perhaps this was the point the professor was getting at, or maybe it's just some postmodern "knowledge doesn't exist" thing - we can't really tell because Asimov only paraphrases the professor. But I increasingly get the idea that we don't actually know much of anything about the universe based on the seemingly insane theories coming out (eg string theory, infinite worlds).
- Jun8 1y ago"The young man then quoted with approval what Socrates had said on learning that the Delphic oracle had proclaimed him the wisest man in Greece. "If I am the wisest man," said Socrates, "it is because I alone know that I know nothing." This is a common misquote with similar frequency to perhaps "Play it again, Sam." In his Apology (not meaning apology, from apo-logia, speaking for oneself, i.e. defense) Socrates says: "... ἔοικα γοῦν τούτου γε σμικρῷ τινι αὐτῷ τούτῳ σοφώτερος εἶναι, ὅτι ἃ μὴ οἶδα οὐδὲ οἴομαι εἰδέναι." "Although I do not suppose that either of us knows anything really beautiful and good, I am better off than he is – for he knows nothing, and thinks he knows. I neither know nor think I know" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_know_that_I_know_nothing?utm_source=chatgpt.com https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_know_that_I_know_nothing?utm...). The context is that Socrates was puzzled by the Delphic Oracle's declaration that he is the wisest man. The man mentioned is an unnamed politician who was known to be wise.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- sdwr 1y agoIs a punched-up version really a misquote? He said basically the same thing, just in a more meandering way.
- glenstein 1y agoAgreed, I think there's a culture of overzealous "correction" with respect to historical quotations. It's not completely irrelevant that it's a conversation with an oracle or that his attitude was puzzlement in response to being regarded wisest, as contrasted with him just declaring it unprovoked. But still, they are expressions of intellectual humility that come from not knowing and contrasting it to the attitude of claiming to know without really knowing, that essence is the same even with the "correction" and complements Asimov's essay either way. So I think "misquote" is a little strong here.
- moomin 1y agoSo is this essay the source of “Less Wrong”?
- dang 1y agoRelated: The Relativity of Wrong (1989) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37481166 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37481166 - Sept 2023 (124 comments) The Relativity of Wrong (1989) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29811788 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29811788 - Jan 2022 (5 comments) The Relativity of Wrong (1989) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24055125 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24055125 - Aug 2020 (2 comments) The Relativity of Wrong (1989) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17818069 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17818069 - Aug 2018 (11 comments) The Relativity of Wrong (1989) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13082585 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13082585 - Dec 2016 (16 comments) The Relativity of Wrong by Isaac Asimov (1989) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11654774 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11654774 - May 2016 (60 comments) Isaac Asimov: The Relativity of Wrong (1989) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9629797 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9629797 - May 2015 (138 comments) Isaac Asimov - The Relativity of Wrong (1989) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1147968 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1147968 - Feb 2010 (32 comments)
- Martin_Silenus 1y agoYes. People like to think in terms of 100% or 0%. Never anything in between. Even though almost everything falls somewhere in between. That's why I like bits and dislike q-bits, for example. The irony of my own statement dawned on me when I discovered that some people suggest that 2 + 2 does not necessarily equal 4, but could also equal 22. There is no doubt that the exact sciences have something more than philosophy. It's always a pleasure to read Isaac. Well, almost, I should say.
- thanatropism 1y agoI grew up fascinated by these essays from maybe age 8 onward. Now I realize the pervasive bad faith in them, e.g. dismissing Murray (The Bell Curve) and enthronizing the in-retrospect-irrelevant Jay Gould. I knew his novels were kind of silly, but he was supposed to be a Scientist educating us in the scientific view of the world, goddamn it.
- the_af 1y ago> enthronizing the in-retrospect-irrelevant Jay Gould What? Stephen Jay Gould is not irrelevant. > I knew his novels were kind of silly They are not silly. They belong to a different era of Science Fiction, sure. But silly? (He did engage in intentionally goofy humor, of course, but I don't think that's what you meant). > he was supposed to be a Scientist educating us in the scientific view of the world, goddamn it. Asimov? He was!
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]