7 ms·
Why you can’t read 9to5Mac on Instapaper
- jser 14y agoAs a long time Instapaper user, I've been slowly migrating to Pocket since they released multi-page saving, but now plan to move completely. The Instapaper error message should at least be more truthful, or the opt-out list made public so you know restrictions before purchasing the application.
- jedc 14y agoI just started using Pocket, and have found it a much nicer experience than Instapaper all around. This reminds me to take the Instapaper button off my bookmarks bar...
- dpearson 14y agoNeither side especially comes off well in all of this. 9to5mac misspelled his name? I don't see how that's especially funny (and it is childish), but Arment needs to lighten up about that. I also don't see how even the accusations regarding the servers the FBI seized hold water, but there is a polite way to deal with it (read: not blocking a site and making it look like anyone but you is at fault). Ultimately, I'll still use Instapaper as long as Arment keeps making a quality app and keeps his personal choices out of what I see in the app.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Avenger42 14y agoMarco's response on Twitter seemed to indicate that people had, in fact, already begun to blame him for the UDID leak. At the very least, that's a foreseeable reaction to publishing a story claiming a potential link.
- prawn 14y agoSomething Marco did himself, even calling that app "a likely culprit" - which is pretty strong wording.
- shinratdr 14y agoDevelopers don't like being branded as scrapers, as it carries the implication that the service in question is stealing content from others to provide its service. The absolute worst thing Instapaper can be accused of is implementing an old-Readability style function that strips pages of non-article content, most frequently ads. By that definition Safari Reader is a scraper, so is AdBlock, Reeder, or any other app that tries to improve on the average abysmal reading environment most websites provide.
- kmfrk 14y agoDoes Safari Reader allow storing articles as the re-formatted version rather than as an original bookmark? I think the new-Readability style is contentious, wherein the content is stored re-formatted, whereas the old style was just basic JavaScript, no different from a downloaded GreaseMonkey userstyle.
- Kylekramer 14y agoI am a major fan and paying user of Instapaper and similar services. But how are they not stealing content from others to provide their services? Read it later apps are useless without content. Websites may provide an abysmal reading experience, but it is their property and they can present it as they please. Even if I don't like it and prefer to use Instapaper, it is still theft of a certain kind. So, yes, Instapaper/Safari Reader/Adblock/Reeder are scrapers in my estimation.
- icebraining 14y agoCopying, not stealing.
- Kylekramer 14y agoEh, I hate arguing this point cause I find myself doing it a lot and never really getting anywhere interesting, but here goes. I believe copyright infringement is a subset of stealing. The common definition of stealing is taking something you don't own without permission. The fact that the owner still has a copy is immaterial. Acting like depriving the owner of their copy is a necessary component of stealing is just a remnant of a time where it was much harder to make perfect copy of valuable property. I know the copy vs. steal debate is touchy, but I also feel it is just a distraction from the larger issue.
- Avenger42 14y agoIn an email to Buzzfeed, Marco stated (as he posted on Twitter) that it was 9to5Mac's willingness to write potentially libelous statements that he didn't want to deal with: ...I really don't foresee doing this for any other site unless they explicitly request it. What 9to5 has consistently written about me and Instapaper goes far beyond what's acceptable, is potentially libelous, and could cause potential legal issues. This has never happened to this degree from any other site, and would certainly never happen from a professionally run publication. I will not tolerate their behavior or the potential legal risks of interacting with 9to5 or Seth at all, so I removed the ability for Instapaper to interact with their site. [edit] Marco's tweet: https://twitter.com/marcoarment/status/245163432758878208 https://twitter.com/marcoarment/status/245163432758878208
- MisterBastahrd 14y agoSounds like someone wants to be a big shot but doesn't have a thick enough skin to deal with criticism. His app is completely worthless without other people's content.
- lrei 14y agoYou know what else is worthless without other people's content? Google. Does it make Google's achievements any less noteworthy? Any less useful? No. Your point s invalid. Content is worthless without a means to access it. That's what Instapaper is at its core.
- kmfrk 14y agoI think, trying to read through the pettiness and petulance of it all, that Marco has a fine point to be argued. He just makes it in a really insufferable way.
- dasil003 14y agoHe had a fine point to be argued until he brought it into his app functionality. Seriously, not only is that is ridiculously childish, but it's totally unnecessary—he has the audience to make his point in full editorial glory. If it's libel then sic a lawyer on them, don't play games with your user base, most of whom don't and shouldn't give a fuck.
- dmishe 14y agoWhat's the point of the service, if its author can selectively disable functionality for his own reasons, whatever they be?
- azar1 14y agoLooks like today is International Fuck Marco Arment day. (no disrespect meant to Marco)
- runjake 14y agoTo be fair, he's mostly instigating it himself with incendiary posts and tweets. I can't keep up with how many people he's told to f--- off in the past 48 hours.
- zachinglis 14y agoMarco has a history of doing this. He's a developer, and an opinionated one at that (which is saying something for us guys.) His actions here stink of foul play rather than any genuine worry. Maybe he has another side to this – but if he does, telling people to fuck off isn't the way around it.
- TillE 14y ago> He's a developer, and an opinionated one at that Too often this is a euphemism for "he's a jerk who's unwilling to consider anyone else's perspective or requirements". You can kinda get away with that in software development if you're incredibly smart, but it's an awful attitude to bring to any other part of your life.
- JoeAcchino 14y agoI just canceled my Instapaper paying subscription. I don't care about this story, I just care about the provider of a service that decides to block me for his personal matters. Sorry but it just feels like an insult to me.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- julian25 14y agoMarco has actually been quite influential in my growth as a developer, I have nothing against him personally. That being said, I do not want to pay for a service that limits my access to content when there are other similar services that do not.
- da_n 14y agoI do agree that if a developer has some personal beef with a website that should not allow him/her to think they have the right to block it from their users. Apple wouldn't dream to go as far as to block google.com or samsung.com on their OS's for example just because they have some serious business disagreements. The fact is though we only really have one side of the story here, so hopefully Marco will explain his side of the story (perhaps on his podcast http://5by5.tv/buildanalyze http://5by5.tv/buildanalyze). To be honest though I simply cannot believe he would think such a thing acceptable, he seems like a pretty clued-in guy this would be a blunder of epic proportions if true, there's something more to this story.
- nc 14y agoFor the record. Apple has pushed Google Maps off the iPhone in iOS 6. Not sure they'll allow it either as it would 'duplicate core OS functionality'
- da_n 14y agoGuess I should have said more clearly, meant blocking in the browser. With Google Maps, I thought this was down to their license agreement expiring, and that Google reportedly have their own App Store version in the works. I suppose if the app is rejected by Apple on frivalous grounds this would be cause for concern.
- crisnoble 14y agoArgh, why do I waste my time reading about famous devs vs. blogs vs. bloggers vs. journalists? It's like a car crash. I guess it is time to turn the minaway setting up... edit: Actually it's more like watching Jersey shore. A fantasy world where people have problems that everyone should listen to.
- kmfrk 14y agoFWIW, pg blocks BuzzFeed articles, which prevented me and other people from submitting a more unbiased article on the subject. The whole he-said-she-said minutiae of it all are pretty dull, unless people want to get on some kind of tired free speech horse.
- crisnoble 14y agoIt's not that it's dull, it's just that (today in particular) I am wasting time reading about X famous dev vs. Y popular tech blog. I'm just lamenting that I should be developing code because reading about X vs. Y is not helping me to someday become an X. None of this is anyone's fault but my own.
- kemayo 14y agoAdding editorial opinions to Instapaper seems like a Bad Idea. People using it just want to read content, and being told "I disagree with this site" is only going to piss them off.
- ojiikun 14y agoWorse yet, how many users will write it off as a technical error, shrug, close the window, and move on to read other things? Instapaper has found a way to stifle the readership and mindshare of whomever they choose, that, for non-HN readers could have it's cause masked from view.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- hctilg 14y agoWow. Why is he acting so childish. He shouldn't be taking personal matters and forcing them on users.
- achompas 14y agoThis really, really sucks. I like Marco's take on development (both software and career) and entrepreneurship, and he has a "no bullshit" approach to technology. But what the heck is going on today? He questions The Verge's integrity (despite having nothing more than the absence of a iMac/HP Spectre One comment), tries to backpedal on it, then starts blocking sites he's feuding with? Lame. He's normally the most level-headed of the popular Mac bloggers.
- w1ntermute 14y agoThe Verge's "integrity" has now been questioned by both Marco and Gruber[0], both of whom appeared On The Verge[1,2]. In both cases, they demonstrated a veneer of level-headedness for the sake of their own "integrity", but it was obvious from the subtext what their real feelings on the matters discussed were. I wouldn't take either of their opinions seriously. The Verge is the best tech website out there period, and there's no reason to believe that its journalists are biased. They are doing some amazing reporting and really trying to revolutionize online journalism. And fuck Instapaper - Marco was such a douchebag about Android support. Use Pocket[3], they have beautiful apps for all platforms and don't inject their personal opinions and biases into their software. You can export your articles from Instapaper and import them into Pocket, so there's no excuse for not switching. 0: http://joshuatopolsky.com/post/31285353423/integrity-and-bullies-with-blogs http://joshuatopolsky.com/post/31285353423/integrity-and-bul... 1: http://www.theverge.com/2011/12/12/2630911/on-the-verge-episode-002-john-gruber http://www.theverge.com/2011/12/12/2630911/on-the-verge-epis... 2: http://www.theverge.com/2012/5/21/3033481/on-the-verge-episode-006-damon-lindelof-masi-oka-and-marco-arment http://www.theverge.com/2012/5/21/3033481/on-the-verge-episo... 3: http://getpocket.com/ http://getpocket.com/
- kmfrk 14y agoThere is a very important distinction with regards to integrity, though. Marco imputes an incentive to appease manufacturers to keep review copies coming; Gruber speculates that they don't want to rile up the eternal "other side" of the Apple vs. the World debate. The former is an attack on their journalistic integrity, Gruber's much less so - although still an attack, nevertheless. Gruber knows to temper his rhetoric, being a guy with journalistic sentibilities himself. Marco is just a guy with a blog.
- meritt 14y agoMarco is exhibiting exactly how not to act. If you want people to use your product, you don't censor things on their behalf. That's an incredible example of crossing the line.
- aneth4 14y agoTruly shameful behavior that permanently destroys the huge amount of trust Instapaper has built up with users. Instapaper, as any such product, is a service to its users, not a bludgeon for political battles. That is a hard line in the sand that once crossed reveals a lack of integrity from the operators.
- tptacek 14y agoMarco Arment made a mistake here. I know the feeling well. He will get over it, and so will all of you. Is there much more to say about it than that? I will never understand why people personalize so much what what Arment says. He's an independent developer; he's one of us. He happens to like iOS more than a lot of HN'ers. "Liking the wrong operating system" seems like a much smaller sin than "shitting all over an indie developer".
- danilocampos 14y ago> I will never understand why people personalize so much what what Arment says. Perhaps because his writing, frequently obnoxious and bereft of charm, makes him very easy to dislike. Even for people like myself who might otherwise agree with his positions.
- SCdF 14y agoI'm honestly not sure what you're saying. Yes he made a mistake, that's why this thread exists. But making a mistake is not the punishment for making a mistake. Until he comes around, apologises and reverts what is arguably censorship, all that is being said needs to be said.
- spindritf 14y ago> I will never understand why people personalize so much what what Arment says. The point is not in what he said, that's folklore more than anything, the point is that he crippled his software over some Twitter feud.
- melvinmt 14y agoSo Mr. Marco is upset by some blog and that's why I can't use it in Instapaper? I don't even read 9to5mac but it's reason enough for me to cancel my Instapaper account. Are there any alternatives I should know about?
- SCdF 14y agoPocket is fairly popular: http://getpocket.com/ http://getpocket.com/
- michaelhoffman 14y agoI came here to recommend Pocket. Free. Natively supports iOS, Android, Firefox, Chrome (and has bookmarklet and other web app support for anything else). No ideological baggage or jerkiness.
- wyclif 14y agoPocket, because it's bullshit-free.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tvladeck 14y agoIt's also worth noting that the popup is still a lie. Instapaper can save articles from 9to5Mac, but chooses not to. It's an important distinction for the user, who probably will think that it is something wrong with 9to5Mac.
- donohoe 14y agoI can completely understand Marcos reaction here. 9to5/Seth seems to have been persistently badgering him. For example (Seth's words): But in updating, I spelled his name wrong —”Marcus Armento”—as a laugh. and.. I also linked to his Tweet above about spelling his name wrong and the funny replies it received. and more... I (also jokingly) called his app “Instascraper,” which publishers often call the app because it removes ads from the websites it views. “Scraping” is what publishers call bots and other robot services that strip content from a site and republish it without any financial payment That was in addition to the stories of Instapaper as a source of the leaked UDIDs and previous unflattering commentary. Marco isn't completely blameless, however I completely understand why he was upset. Banning 9to5 was a step too far however he realized his mistake and owned up to it. Dare I ask - what else do you want?
- macrael 14y agoMarco has posted an apology: http://blog.instapaper.com/post/31303984531 http://blog.instapaper.com/post/31303984531
- aneth4 14y agoThe apology doesn't reflect an understanding of the gravity of what he did. He mostly apologizes for using the wrong mechanism and generally overreacting, not for the betrayal of his users and the abuse of power for personal reasons.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- cjensen 14y ago9to5Mac, a notoriously unreliable rag, claims Marco is censoring them. I should believe them... why? There are sites Instapaper does not scrape. For example, ArsTechnica does not allow scraping of full articles. Instapaper respects this whereas other scrapers ignore ArsTechnica and scrape anyway. My point is, just because Instapaper refuses to scrape a site does not automatically mean censorship has occurred.
- Semiapies 14y agoYou realize he's already admitted he did this and apologized for having done so?
- FrankBooth 14y agoC'mon, do some basic research before posting. This has already been well covered in this very thread. https://twitter.com/marcoarment/status/245163180479885312 https://twitter.com/marcoarment/status/245163180479885312 https://twitter.com/marcoarment/status/245165731120033792 https://twitter.com/marcoarment/status/245165731120033792
- cjensen 14y agoI read the link at the top of the article, which failed to explain it. Should I have realized that since the linked article is 9to5, it would of course have failed to present the basic facts underlying it's own article?
- commandar 14y ago>9to5Mac, a notoriously unreliable rag, claims Marco is censoring them. I should believe them... why? Marco more or less admits to as much in an email to Buzzfeed. >What 9to5 has consistently written about me and Instapaper goes far beyond what's acceptable, is potentially libelous, and could cause potential legal issues. This has never happened to this degree from any other site, and would certainly never happen from a professionally run publication. >I will not tolerate their behavior or the potential legal risks of interacting with 9to5 or Seth at all, so I removed the ability for Instapaper to interact with their site. http://www.buzzfeed.com/mattbuchanan/how-to-get-banned-from-instapaper http://www.buzzfeed.com/mattbuchanan/how-to-get-banned-from-... Now, there's room to debate whether this should be called censorship, but it's clear that 9to5Mac is blocked on InstaPaper as a direct result of what they've published on their site.