8 ms·
The Democratic Party has completely removed civil liberties policies from their platform for 2012, even though it was one of the main things they ran on in 2008
by mtgx 14y ago
The Democratic Party has completely removed civil liberties policies from their platform for 2012, even though it was one of the main things they ran on in 2008.
http://www.motherjones.com/mojo/2012/09/democrats-retreat-civil-liberties-2012-platform http://www.motherjones.com/mojo/2012/09/democrats-retreat-ci...
Romney would obviously be even worse for this, but yeah - this is what you get with a 2 party system. It just gets worse and worse. My only hope is that once Republicans lose this one, then by 2014 or even 2016 they reform the party, and the libertarians inside the party get to heavily influence the platform towards more civil liberties, and attack the Democrat Party on it at the next elections, so they can win on it. Other than that, I'm not sure how you'll get either the Democratic Party or the Republican one to start caring about this again.
- tptacek 14y agoCivil liberties weren't one of the main things Obama ran on in 2008. Obama ran on the economy and on a fixed timetable for ending the Iraq war. To make the argument that civil liberties were a key focus of the Obama 2008 campaign, you should be able to provide a Google News search query from (say) July-October '08 that demonstrates that fact. I just tried to find one and couldn't. We are (mostly, and myself included) social liberals on HN, and Obama was the liberal mainstream candidate in 2008, so I think we tend to project things onto him that aren't really there. Obama is first and foremost a pragmatist. Closing Gitmo was worth less to Obama than getting health care passed.
- cpher 14y agoI agree that both parties (save Ron Paul, if you'd call him a Republican) aren't running on civil liberties, but don't pretend that social "justice" wasn't a theme of Obama in '08. And to Obama, the two are conflated. And to call Obama a pragmatist is laughable, at best. I know you're from Chi-town...so am I. In his neighborhood, no less. But pragmatism is an unknown word to Obama because he doesn't know how to govern. You brought up Gitmo...any candidate with half a brain wouldn't go around spouting nonsense about closing it as a campaign issue. A 15 minute conversation with anyone in that arena would tell you not to make that promise...yet he did. Also, I'm here to provide a counter-point to your assertion that most people on HN are social liberals. I'm not, yet I live in one of the most socially liberal neighborhoods in the country (save SF neighborhoods?). I agree with you that closing Gitmo wasn't a priority for him in office, and that health care was the priority. Unfortunately, that's why we're 2+ years behind in fixing this economy. He is so fixated on ideology than pragmatism (in his words) that the economy just slipped his mind. *edit: pronoun change
- arthurrr 14y agoHe doesn't understand how the economy works. Neither do nearly everyone in government. They are all basically academics without practical experience. You can't fix something you don't understand. You'd have better luck asking a virgin about sex.
- mbell 14y agoCalling them academics is a serious stretch outside anything but the field of political science.
- shirederby 14y agoIt is reasonable to question whether civil liberties were among the "main things" Obama ran on; however, they it is clear that they were present. Beyond the aforementioned platform changes, you can see, for instance, the last section of the following: http://web.archive.org/web/20080710165621/http://www.barackobama.com/issues/pdf/HomelandSecurityFactSheet.pdf http://web.archive.org/web/20080710165621/http://www.baracko... or perhaps the section "2008 Campaign Event" on this page: http://www.thepoliticalguide.com/Profiles/President/US/Barack_Obama/Views/Homeland_Security/ http://www.thepoliticalguide.com/Profiles/President/US/Barac... Of course those are just two sources, but it's a pain to search Lexis-Nexis. Google News, AFAICT, has a much less comprehensive archive available to search.
- zachalexander 14y agoHow about Obama's own 2008 campaign promises? From the "Security" section of his main "Blueprint for Change" (http://blatantreality.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/obamablueprintforchange.pdf http://blatantreality.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/obamabl... p. 71): >Reaffirm our Values: Obama and Biden will restore respect for the rule of law and America’s values. They will: reject torture with- out exception or equivocation, including so-called “enhanced interrogation techniques” like waterboarding; restore the Rule of Law by closing Guantanamo and restoring habeas corpus; and provide our intelligence and law enforcement agencies with the tools they need to track down terrorists without undermining our Constitution or civil liberties. Similar statements are made in other 2008 campaign documents, and with more detail. Before you object, I do realize you're saying two different things here: (a) that it wasn't one of the "main" things he ran on, and (b) that promises to restore civil liberties "weren't really there" except in liberal imaginations. I can accept the first, but the second is completely untrue.
- tptacek 14y agoObama tried and failed to close Guantanamo Bay, losing a great deal of political capital in the process. Do you think the Obama administration is writing memos encouraging the use of waterboarding, like David Addington and John Yoo did in 2003? I don't. I don't object to this on a technicality. I object to it on the substance.
- zachalexander 14y agoIn descending order of fullfilling-his-promises (all promises from his "Obama's Plan to Defeat Terrorists Worldwide" 2008 campaign document, pp. 5-6): * He promised to end torture and rendition, and did so, AFAIK. +1 * He made a good faith effort to close Guantanamo, and failed. Let's call this a wash. 0 * He promised to revist the Patriot Act and implement "real and robust" oversight of the new powers it granted. This one's complicated, but PolitiFact seems to call it a wash. 0 * He promised to "eliminate" warantless wiretaps specifically, but hasn't done anything to accomplish this. In fact, he's signed reauthorizations of the Patriot Act twice without any change in the wiretapping sections. -1 * He promised to "restore habeas corpus". In reality, he's claimed the right to not only imprison foreigners without that right, but also American citizens. -1 * Not only that, but he claims the right to kill American citizens without trial. This isn't breaking a specific campaign promise, since even Bush didn't claim this (AFAIK), but I'm including it anyway. -1 In sum, aside from torture, he's ranged from a disappointment to a disaster on civil liberties. And I love the guy otherwise.
- cema 14y ago> Romney would obviously be even worse for this I am not sure how you come to this conclusion. Is it something he said, or history of his actions, or a general attitude against the Republican party, or something else?
- mtgx 14y agoRomney and the Republican party in general want to make the Patriot Act "stronger" for example (watch the Republican debates from last fall. The only one arguing against it was Ron Paul. The others were all towards "more security", disregarding any civil liberties that might step on). They would like a war with Iran, and we all know things get even worse during war time, when it comes to to civil liberties. And last but not least, Romney can not be trusted, so it's irrelevant even if he says he is pro-Internet freedom (btw he said recently he wants to ban porn or something like that) or pro-civil liberties.
- lstroud 14y agoWhile you may be able to find attribution of that to some fringe elements of the Republican party, I have not heard Romney or Ryan say anything even close. In fact, they seem to be far more process oriented than the current administration that continues to try to find ways around government process (avoiding votes, expansion of executive orders, use of conference, recess appointments, etc).
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoThere is some evidence that Democratic presidents use EOs more than Republican presidents[1]. What I don't know is whose EOs are "worse". I'd as soon Congress rip much of the EO power back out of the President's hands. 1. http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Executive_Orders_and_Proclamations http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Executive_Orders_and_Proclamat...
- Shivetya 14y agoRomney would be better and I give only one reason. If we start making these guys all one term Presidents maybe, just maybe, they might know who they are beholden too. So anyone is better than the current guy and so and so on. So I am quite willing to put up with four years of Romney if it means a message is being delivered. I am quite willing to get him out as fast too.
- zzzeek 14y agoPlacing unqualified or dangerous individuals (since we're saying, anyone is better) in charge of the entire country in order to "teach the other side a lesson" seems highly reckless at best and intensely malevolent towards humanity at worst (such as, said president starts another war based on lies, killing millions).
- clarky07 14y agothat's what we did in 2008. EDIT: maybe not dangerous per se, but definitely unqualified.
- saraid216 14y agoThat may be what you did, but it's not what I did.
- clarky07 14y agoi definitely did not help him get elected, but we as in the citizens of the United States collectively elected him.
- smokinjoe 14y agoDespite us voting differently then and probably in 2012, I deeply appreciate this sort of sentiment. Despite our differences, we are one Nation. I believe it helps ensure civil debates as well as respect during policy discussion.
- zzzeek 14y agoIt's called the Democratic party. "Democrat party" is a slur used by Republicans, and its usage suggests someone who either views the party in a derogatory way or who is underexposed to non-right-wing news sources. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democrat_Party_%28epithet%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democrat_Party_%28epithet%29
- Uhhrrr 14y agoI am hoping they will be motivated by a Gary Johnson victory.