11 ms·
Obama has been shameful on civil liberties. The sad thing is that it has traditionally been the Republicans who push against the limits of civil liberties and t
by guelo 14y ago
Obama has been shameful on civil liberties. The sad thing is that it has traditionally been the Republicans who push against the limits of civil liberties and the Dems who at least pretend to care. Thanks to Obama, the Dems have flipped over so completely against civil liberties that there really is no remaining government interest protecting us. It's a Nixon goes to China moment, Obama has done more to destroy civil liberties than any Republican ever could have dreamed.
- tptacek 14y agoObama has done more to destroy civil liberties than any Republican ever could have dreamed. Ridiculous. I understand the perspective that civil liberties online are under a constant assault by the government, but no reading of the actual facts could lead someone to the informed belief that Obama's DOJ and NSA are worse than Bush's, or, for that matter, Clinton's or Bush I's.
- vl 14y agoYour statement is ridiculous - by your own logic Obama took it from them and then assault is continued by his government.
- tptacek 14y agoDid you read the bill?
- vl 14y agoI haven't read this specific bill, but parent's comment was a meta-comment about policy and is not specifically about this bill. I was strong Obama supporter, but my opinion has changed.
- tptacek 14y agoDo you have an opinion about this bill as it pertains to civil liberties, or are you just commenting because of an ambient concern about Obama's handling of civil liberties? If you do have an opinion about the bill, will you consider reading it?
- vl 14y agoI'm commenting because of a well-defined concern about current goverment's handling of civil liberties in a comment thread not specific to this bill.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- crisnoble 14y agoEverybody, let's just read the bills together: Lieberman-Collins “Cybersecurity Act of 2012: http://www.opencongress.org/bill/112-s3414/text http://www.opencongress.org/bill/112-s3414/text "Cyber Intelligence Sharing and Protection Act of 2011" aka CISPA: http://www.opencongress.org/bill/112-h3523/text http://www.opencongress.org/bill/112-h3523/text This link is about an Executive Order, which I cannot find a link to the text, but this is getting there: http://www.federalnewsradio.com/241/3026867/White-House-draft-cyber-order-promotes-voluntary-critical-infrastructure-protections http://www.federalnewsradio.com/241/3026867/White-House-draf... Now that we are all on the same page, let's debate it.
- tptacek 14y agoIf you're going to actually read these (and you should, if you care about computer security regulation, but maybe not otherwise since these really aren't far-reaching bills), note that the final CISPA bill the house voted on had several amendments not in the base text; for instance, the final version explicitly struck mention of "intellectual property protection" (not because the House caved, but because the House meant something different by IP protection than what everyone took the text to mean)
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jlarocco 14y agoThe thing is, I don't think Obama has cut any of the stuff Bush added. So if he's made things even a little bit worse than it's the worst ever...
- tptacek 14y agoI think you think wrong. For instance, look up what ACLU said about executive branch restrictions on PATRIOT Act surveillance mechanisms.
- white_devil 14y agono reading of the actual facts could lead someone to the informed belief that Obama's DOJ and NSA are worse than Bush's, or, for that matter, Clinton's or Bush I's. Oh? What about everything related to civil liberties going severely downhill since Bush? Take the NSA "spy center" in Utah we're all aware of by now. How's that for Change You Can Believe In? Now, why is it that whenever there's a post about the US government being up to no good, you are all over the place defending the government or making things seem less serious, or like this time, just mixing things up? Are you some kind of perception management agent or what? Last time there was a post that um.. required your intervention, the thread was like half-full of your posts. Seriously. What the fuck? What are you doing? Everyone who lives in reality knows you've got quite a police state going on over there. Everyone knows your government is totally owned by Wall Street and other elites [1]. Everyone knows your police force is full of thugs that tase people to death for fun. Countless Americans have had their houses fraudulently foreclosed on by the banks. America is swirling down the drain. What the hell are you trying to accomplish here on Hacker News by trying to polish the turd of reality? [1] Well, except for Ron Paul and a couple of other people.
- culturestate 14y ago> Oh? What about everything related to civil liberties going severely downhill since Bush? Can you please provide some citations/examples? I'm not sure a new NSA datacenter is enough evidence of "everything related to civil liberties going severely downhill."
- sophacles 14y agoFurther it is merely the next logical step from the "get all the data" boxes put at AT&T and other teleco POPs under Bush, which was a logical extension of ECHELON from Bush Sr. and Clinton.
- white_devil 14y agoHow about the NDAA, which allows for treating American citizens as "enemy combatants"?
- nateabele 14y agoQoTD: "America is swirling down the drain. What the hell are you trying to accomplish here on Hacker News by trying to polish the turd of reality?" See also: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/iraq-war-on-terror/topsecretamerica/top-cia-official-obama-changed-virtually-none-of-bushs-controversial-programs/ http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/iraq-war-on-terror/t...
- joshuahedlund 14y agoThe Patriot Act alone is a decent case that Bush and Obama (by passing and reauthorizing, respectively) have been worse than their predecessors. And Obama has taken many transgressions farther than Bush, both in direct actions and in attempts to hide information about actions, including government immunity for surveillance violations [1], citing exceptions to open record laws [2], ignoring FOIA requests [3], prosecuting whistleblowers [4], use of national security letters, saying that they can't tell us how many Americans they've spied on[5], etc, etc. The TSA seems to gotten more annoying, too. [1] http://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2009/04/obama-doj-worse-than-bush http://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2009/04/obama-doj-worse-than-bu... [2] http://www.sunjournal.com/node/815552 http://www.sunjournal.com/node/815552 [3] http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0312/73606.html http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0312/73606.html [4] http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/12/sunday-review/a-high-tech-war-on-leaks.html http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/12/sunday-review/a-high-tech-... [5] http://www.wired.com/dangerroom/2012/06/nsa-spied/ http://www.wired.com/dangerroom/2012/06/nsa-spied/
- roc 14y agoHow does the Patriot Act hold up to the HUAC or interment of citizens during WWII? The Patriot Act is bad. But it's not unprecedented. And, personally, I don't find it notably worse than the war on drugs.
- tptacek 14y agoThis pretty much sums up my take on PATRIOT, with the addendum that Obama had basically zero chance of rolling PATRIOT back given the political hand he was dealt.
- cobrausn 14y agoI cannot count the number of times I have heard 'Well he would have done X except for Y' from Obama supporters. I no longer believe it - actions speak louder, and all that.
- 14y ago
- mtgx 14y agoThe Democratic Party has completely removed civil liberties policies from their platform for 2012, even though it was one of the main things they ran on in 2008. http://www.motherjones.com/mojo/2012/09/democrats-retreat-civil-liberties-2012-platform http://www.motherjones.com/mojo/2012/09/democrats-retreat-ci... Romney would obviously be even worse for this, but yeah - this is what you get with a 2 party system. It just gets worse and worse. My only hope is that once Republicans lose this one, then by 2014 or even 2016 they reform the party, and the libertarians inside the party get to heavily influence the platform towards more civil liberties, and attack the Democrat Party on it at the next elections, so they can win on it. Other than that, I'm not sure how you'll get either the Democratic Party or the Republican one to start caring about this again.
- tptacek 14y agoCivil liberties weren't one of the main things Obama ran on in 2008. Obama ran on the economy and on a fixed timetable for ending the Iraq war. To make the argument that civil liberties were a key focus of the Obama 2008 campaign, you should be able to provide a Google News search query from (say) July-October '08 that demonstrates that fact. I just tried to find one and couldn't. We are (mostly, and myself included) social liberals on HN, and Obama was the liberal mainstream candidate in 2008, so I think we tend to project things onto him that aren't really there. Obama is first and foremost a pragmatist. Closing Gitmo was worth less to Obama than getting health care passed.
- cpher 14y agoI agree that both parties (save Ron Paul, if you'd call him a Republican) aren't running on civil liberties, but don't pretend that social "justice" wasn't a theme of Obama in '08. And to Obama, the two are conflated. And to call Obama a pragmatist is laughable, at best. I know you're from Chi-town...so am I. In his neighborhood, no less. But pragmatism is an unknown word to Obama because he doesn't know how to govern. You brought up Gitmo...any candidate with half a brain wouldn't go around spouting nonsense about closing it as a campaign issue. A 15 minute conversation with anyone in that arena would tell you not to make that promise...yet he did. Also, I'm here to provide a counter-point to your assertion that most people on HN are social liberals. I'm not, yet I live in one of the most socially liberal neighborhoods in the country (save SF neighborhoods?). I agree with you that closing Gitmo wasn't a priority for him in office, and that health care was the priority. Unfortunately, that's why we're 2+ years behind in fixing this economy. He is so fixated on ideology than pragmatism (in his words) that the economy just slipped his mind. *edit: pronoun change
- vl 14y agoInterestingly, since Obama is "democrat" he can easily push right-wing changes and get away with it. His supporters then go "he is a good guy, but evil republicans forced him to". If any republican would try it, there would be strong outcry. There is a good article at Political Compass: http://www.politicalcompass.org/uselection2012 http://www.politicalcompass.org/uselection2012 (Also, take the test, you'll be surprised.)
- tptacek 14y agoHave you guys read Lieberman-Collins? It's linked from the story. You should, if this EO is truly an indicator of Obama's retreat on civil liberties, easily be able to point out clauses from the bill that make that point. I've read it. I don't think it'll be as easy as these comments make it sound.
- vl 14y agoHave you read linked Political Comapass article? It provides enough other indicators. First sentence is priceless though: This is a US election that defies logic and brings the nation closer towards a one-party state masquerading as a two-party state.
- tptacek 14y agoI do not understand what that "Political Compass" article has to do with computer security legislation in general, let alone with the Lieberman-Collins bill in particular. That doesn't mean they have nothing to do with each other, but you probably need to explain the connection a little bit more.
- iskander 14y agoThat was a terrible quiz for several reasons. 1) Some of the questions simply don't make sense, i.e. "Multinational companies are unethically exploiting the plant genetic resources of developing countries." The what resources? 2) It completely conflates personal beliefs with those I would want to see forced upon society at large. 3) Some of the questions have totally ambiguous interpretations in terms of the two given axes. If I agree with "An eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth", does that make me more or less authoritarian? What about "Abstract art that doesn't represent anything shouldn't be considered art at all"? Also, the points assigned to famous political figures are totally arbitrary. Neither Hitler nor Hu Jintao have taken this quiz, so the author is simply making up answers for them.
- kaonashi 14y agoIt's more of a 'Wilson pushes for WWI despite having campaigned against it' moment.
- cpher 14y agoI agree that Obama has been shameful re: civil liberties...so have recent Republicans. But please hold your denigration from the Democrats. They don't care. At all. 95% of Congress doesn't care. At all. Regarding Nixon in China, you need to read up on your history. For all of Nixon's faults (and they could build a mighty big Five Guys burger's worth)...the fact is that he opened up China for the first time ever for this country. That is the big deal. So, your implication is that Obama has done the same for our civil liberties? Are you implying that Nixon sacrificed our civil liberties in order to dialogue with the Chinese? I'm not even sure what you're implying. Please enlighten me.
- guelo 14y agoIn political circles it is thought that a Democrat president could never have been the first to go to China because they would have been accused of supporting communists. Only a Republican president could do it because he was insulated from attacks from the right. The idea I was trying to express in my comment is that Obama can go further to attack civil liberties because the left won't criticize him. When Bush was president liberals would frequently criticize civil liberties issues, nowadays they are silent.
- bobwaycott 14y agoIn political circles, throughout the whole history of the word's existence, we don't say "Democrat president" -- it's Democratic. As in the Democratic Party. The opponent of the Republican Party. Why? Democratic is an adjective. Thus, it modifies nouns like president, party, congressperson, senator, carl-the-carpenter ... they're all democratic [insert noun], not democrat [insert noun]. When using the noun form, it is democrat. But nouns do not modify nouns. So we never, ever, ever say "democrat president". We say Democratic president. It's apparently confusing because republican is both a noun and an adjective. But democratic and democrat are distinct. Mr. Obama is a Democrat. [noun] Mr. Obama is a Democratic president. [adjective] Suggested corrections: > In political circles it is thought that a Democratic president could never have been the first to go to China because they would have been accused of supporting communists. Only a Republican president could do it because he was insulated from attacks from the right. or > In political circles it is thought that a Democrat could never have been the first to go to China because they would have been accused of supporting communists. Only a Republican could do it because he was insulated from attacks from the right.
- SeanDav 14y agoThere is that somewhat famous quote by Joseph de Maistre that translates to "every nation gets the government it deserves". Judging on the government that America currently has, and recently had, I am starting to wonder if the American People really are so bad as to truly deserve that....