3 ms·
Within minutes it seems we already have comments claiming that this is pointless because it's already what the law says, and also implying that this is pointles
by zahlman 1y ago
Within minutes it seems we already have comments claiming that this is pointless because it's already what the law says, and also implying that this is pointless because it disagrees with the law and will therefore be reverted by the judicial branch.
These clearly can't both be true... ?
At any rate, for those who wish for this action to be legal, do you feel the same way about the flags of other countries? Why or why not?
- thejazzman 1y agoit's a pretty blatant violation of free speech, but murica doesn't care bout that now that their speech is dominant
- zahlman 1y agoAside from sneering, this does not answer the question.
- dragonwriter 1y ago> Within minutes it seems we already have comments claiming that this is pointless because it's already what the law says, and also implying that this is pointless because it disagrees with the law and will therefore be reverted by the judicial branch. I don't see anyone claiming that the law already provides for this punishment, every post on the existing law says this conflicts with it, explicitly or, in one case, implicitly. Are you perhaps misreading the “settled case law” post which does rely on the reader knowing the existing case law? > These clearly can't both be true... ? It is in conflict with existing Constitutional case law, but those claiming it is a nullity with no significance for that reason are nonetheless incorrect both because quite a lot of damage can be done before courts act and because there is no guarantee of how the current Supreme Court will act just because the existing case law is clear. And, frankly, because the present administration, when it wants to punish without legal basis, doesn't just fold when the courts strike down what it is doing, but shifts theoretical basis and continues applying punishment.
- zahlman 1y ago> Are you perhaps misreading the “settled case law” post which does rely on the reader knowing the existing case law? Apparently.
- amalcon 1y agoThis one kind of smells like Trump throwing a bone to the court and feeding his base's persecution complex. I highly doubt that he actually cares about flag burning. The court can rule against him here (answering the criticism that they always rule in Trump's favor). Then he can tell his people that the court is biased against him. I'm not usually the kind of person to speculate about hidden motives like this. Frankly I think this kind of move is usually too uncertain to make sense. It could always just be one of his frequent semi-random actions like renaming the Gulf of Mexico. If I assume it's a considered action, though, I can't come up with another explanation for it.
- treetalker 1y agoIt consumes finite attention that might otherwise remain on the Epstein files and Trump's involvement with the exploitation of minors.
- dzhiurgis 1y ago> do you feel the same way about the flags of other countries Do I need to be respectful of enemy's flag?
- ndsipa_pomu 1y agoWhy do you feel that other countries are your enemies?
- dzhiurgis 1y agoThey declared it.