8 ms·
Hundreds lose water source in Colorado's poorest county with no notice
- mooreds 1y agoSaw this on a social network with a mention of Paolo Bacigalupi's "The water knife", which is a great scifi book about a future with water wars.
- bozhark 1y agoWe are already in the current water wars in some places around the globe
- black6 1y agoI haven't read The Water Knife, but I have read The Tamarisk Hunter, which I believe is related and paints a picture of the future of the American West with it's messed up water rights.
- mooreds 1y agoYeah, the Tamarisk Hunter ( https://windupstories.com/books/pump-six-and-other-stories/the-tamarisk-hunter/ https://windupstories.com/books/pump-six-and-other-stories/t... ) is fantastic and set in the same world.
- CodingJeebus 1y ago> The fight over the water has pitted residents of Fort Garland who have plumbing and pay for metered water against those living outside the city limits with cisterns. The board of the Fort Garland Water and Sanitation District — which cut off water sales to rural residents Aug. 1 in a 3-2 vote that wasn’t even on its meeting agenda — has devolved into shouting matches and dysfunction. I don't begrudge people who choose to live outside of municipalities in order to avoid taxes, but it's hard to empathize with them when the municipality they're not paying into makes a decision on behalf of their own voters/taxpayers. Hopefully the county/private sector resolves it soon.
- culverv 1y agoI can help a lot with this situation… My product “Sink Twice” was specifically designed for water crisis and helps both on and off grid. It takes about 5 minutes to install and saves tremendous amounts of water for more than a decade… and it is made in Dacono, Colorado.
- Kapura 1y agothey do pay into it, every time they buy the water. exchanging currency for valuable goods is a pretty well-established process.
- jasonlotito 1y agoThey paid for the water that the municipality could afford to sell. They didn't pay into the municipality. If the municipality doesn't have excess water, why should they be forced to sell it?
- nyeah 1y agoThey paid the municipality for the water, but they didn't pay the municipality. Got it.
- lokar 1y agoThere is a very real legal and practical difference between paying for 100G of water, and paying for the right to buy 100G per week for the next N years. Both have a price in the American west, and they did not pay the latter price.
- nyeah 1y agoNobody is arguing otherwise, including the people interviewed in the article. The claim was that these people didn't pay. That claim turns out to be incorrect.
- 1y ago
- Kapura 1y agoit is absolutely wild that a 3-to-2 vote that wasn't announced beforehand could put so many people at risk. obviously governments haven't acted to serve the people since at least Citizen's United, but this is like, society breaking down shit.
- VWWHFSfQ 1y ago> governments haven't acted to serve the people The government in question here is the one representing the tax-paying residents of the town of Fort Garland. They voted to stop selling their scarce water supply to the non-tax-paying residents of unincoporated Costilla County. So it seems to me that the "government" served the interest of their constituents fairly.
- jimnotgym 1y ago'Fairly'. I would love to see them argue that with St Peter at the pearly gates. 'Well we drew this arbitrary line on the ground, and refused to sell water to people in the other side of the line so they could drink and survive. We did it so we could water our ornamental lawns'
- troyvit 1y agoHow well does it serve those constituents? Shutting off the water cut off 15% of Fort Garland's water revenue (while reallocating 1% of its water). That's a big dent in a budget that was probably directly keeping those tax payers' taxes lower and providing them valuable services. The water board didn't have to put it up to an immediate, unplanned vote that day, but they were inexperienced in dealing with "hollering" and waffled under a little pressure. Add to it that they executed the short-term interests of their constituents with such ... alacrity that it put people in physical risk. So who came out ahead here? I don't disagree that all those folks living off-grid really aren't living off-grid, and reality checks are healthy, but even a 2 week warning would have served everybody's interests, served the same FAFO lesson and maybe kept the animosity down a little.
- bluGill 1y agoI don't know Coloraeo laws but I suspect a state judge will issue an injunction on the city to sell water. Courts tend to look poorly on such things.
- darth_avocado 1y agoSeems like an everyone sucks here situation. People who bought houses and chose an off grid life in a water stressed area and did nothing to alleviate the situation, only add consumption. People who want to water their lawns and are unable to adjust their personal behavior in times of need. People with “I got mine” mentality who don’t want to share the space because they got there first and were able to exploit the resources to their desire. The town governance and realtors who keep allowing the sale of properties when there’s no water.
- nyeah 1y ago"People who bought houses and chose an off grid life in a water stressed area and did nothing to alleviate the situation, only add consumption." They paid money for the water.
- lokar 1y agoThey paid (over and over) for one time water allotments. The price of guaranteed access to water is much much higher, and they did not pay for it. It was probably not even for sale, and they should have known that. They are not entitled to anything.
- tshaddox 1y agoDo ordinary homeowners ever pay for guaranteed access to water? Surely not, right?
- lokar 1y agoYes, in a way. They live within the bounds of a water district, which itself has water rights. These districts limit use (or the growth in use) by passing rules on the use (limiting the watering of grass, for example), or (fairly often in some places) limiting new service hookups. They won't let you connect if they don't think they can secure the supply long term.
- barbazoo 1y ago
- potato3732842 1y agoI can't speak to this particular county but the vibe I get from friends of mine who live in this part of Colorado is that the municipalities/counties will do anything/everything they can to stick it to the off grid crowd who are seen as poor and trashy in the best case and evil dangerous sov-cits, anarchists or other anti-government types in the worst case when in reality many/most of them simply wanted to live in BFE and it's not a money or ideological thing and they just want to do whatever works. They buy water from someone who trucks it in no different and with no more thought than they buy propane or pay for their septic to be pumped and trucked out. Like every small town/county, I bet if you follow the trail of financial and ideological interests of the parties involved you'll find that the personalities involved are motivated by more than just whatever their oath of office is. Seeing as there's only one water hauler I'd look into who he pissed off.
- munchler 1y agoBFE = Butt f!ck Egypt, which means “in the middle of nowhere”. I had to google it.
- Bender 1y agoBum not butt. [1] I know, it seems like it's the same but it really isn't [1] - https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=BFE https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=BFE
- pavel_lishin 1y agoWhat's the difference?
- Bender 1y agoSlang history. In the US BFE is well established as Bum-Fuck-Egypt to mean in the middle of nowhere. Explicitly stating Butt-Fuck-Egypt leans towards sexual imagery and is not part of the slang. I completely understand the confusion as bum is commonly used in the UK to mean butt. Someone on the linked site even got it wrong. As an example of communication differences, in the US it is not uncommon for someone to say "Pardon me" when they are getting the way whereas people in England might assume they farted. Or another example where communications go wrong, someone in the US or the UK might give a thumbs-up when they agree with results or an idea but in some parts of Africa that is a death threat.
- louwrentius 1y agoAfter reading the article I come to the conclusion that this was never really about water. There wasn't even a water shortage, only a technical issue that would be resolved. This was about some people on the waterboard not being able to manage angry - semi-aggressive- people properly. And now those people can irrigate their lawns while others can't even drink, wash or cook.
- lokar 1y agoI agree, none of this was really necessary. The board/city was broadly within their rights not to sell (and down the road, as water supplies become more strained they may in fact not have extra water to sell). But the board handled the situation very poorly. The job of being on a board like this is often to sit patiently while people complain and perhaps yell. Try to keep things calm and moving along, let everyone make their statement. They should have just accepted the feedback and then scheduled discussion on various options for some future meeting, with a final vote even further out.
- duxup 1y agoSounds like the water pump failed, and while it was being fixed restrictions were put in place for everyone. Some folks didn't like the restrictions and they blamed the folks who came to buy water because they live off the grid nearby, even if it does not appear those sales would change any of the restrictions. Sad situation. Fear of outsiders and other people often pop up when people are stressed.
- bluGill 1y agoThose folks cut off used 1% of the water but paid 15% of the costs. They were paying far more than their share, but got the blame.
- duxup 1y agoI went home to a somewhat rural area recently. They're very upset about a local hospital is closing, meanwhile they vote solidly for politicians who want to cut people's health insurance off. Human nature is disheartening at times.
- ahmeneeroe-v2 1y agoHealthcare and medical insurance (private or government) are absolutely not the same thing. The ACA married them, probably to our detriment, but I think we'll eventually remember that they're actually separate concepts. I bet these rural people are actually huge supporters of healthcare.
- duxup 1y agoThe hospital closing in this case is largely propped up by the county who effectively pays operating costs that can't be recouped from people who go to the hospital. Insurance coverage is a direct impact on their ability to operate. It's no mystery. Their personal views on healthcare doesn't really matter if their voting pattern doesn't fit.
- 1y ago
- dfsegoat 1y agoColorado Water access law is truly crazy and arcane in some cases (such as this, it would seem). Source: Had a friend in college that interned for a group of attorneys in Western, CO whose entire practice was around water access rights. She explained to me some of the ridiculous things that neighbors requiring common water access could do to each other - based purely on who was using the water first.
- vondur 1y agoI remember reading in Colorado you aren't allowed to collect rainfall for your own use.
- mooreds 1y agoI don't think it is just Colorado. The water law in the west (of the USA) is all messed up. Or at least was created in a different time with different needs and different rainfall. https://extension.unr.edu/publication.aspx?PubID=3750 https://extension.unr.edu/publication.aspx?PubID=3750 has more details.
- lazide 1y agoIt’s messed up anywhere there are periods of sufficiency and insufficiency, no matter what the rules are. Either ‘first user wins’, like here, or ‘all users get allotment’ - in which case you can be screwed by someone building a new subdivision, or ‘gov’t entity allocates’ in which case corruption/payoffs become the norm, etc, etc. At least it’s better than ‘shoot anyone using your well without permission’ like used to be the middle eastern standard eh?
- amanaplanacanal 1y agoI'm sure it made sense at the time. It was essentially homesteading. Just like you could grab a chuck of untamed land and fence it, plow it, build on it, and then you owned it. Water worked the same way. Of course this ignored the people who were already living there, but they had the wrong skin color and religion.
- masklinn 1y ago
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- jibal 1y agoMassive amounts of groundwater are being sucked out of Colorado by Chinese and ME companies that, for instance, grow alfalfa crops and then ship them to their home countries.
- os2warpman 1y agoOne of my favorite genres of non-fiction is when people who claim they value independence and off-griddyness are forced to be independently off-grid. "No no we meant off-grid in every aspect save one!" I know these people, half my family is these people. I've listened to them rail against the man for decades and decades and decades. When you tell them that the invisible hands of the free market will gladly sell them the bootstraps they require, they get mighty angry.
- hollywood_court 1y agoReminds me of people who hate 'socialism' but spend their entire lives in the military.
- petralithic 1y agoDo workers in the military control their means of production? If not, there's no relation to socialism.
- lokar 1y agoIn modern US politics, "socialism" is the Government giving people anything for free.
- vondur 1y agoThat still doesn't make sense, the Government is paying people to be in the military.
- asacrowflies 1y agoYou have to very dense or bordering on disingenuous to not see the subsidized healthcare, subsidized childcare and spouses, subsidized moving costs, etc etc etc as "socialism" in the colloquial sense..... You can't get even 10% those benefits in the private sector without the same chuds screeching about communism.
- abullinan 1y agoIf you want to LARP as a pioneer maybe do some research about their mortality rates. But cynicism aside, this is just the beginning. This will scale to a lot of the US. Even folks in the burbs.
- tharmas 1y agoEven though we know its coming, when it does come, the suddenness of it will still take many of us by surprise, despite all the warnings.
- ramesh31 1y agoThe land is cheap in the San Luis for a reason. It can't support much life. Ultimately these are not multi-generational folks being driven out. They are newcomers who have overwhelmed the existing infrastructure.
- lokar 1y agoAnd access to utilities is on of the only tools that counties have to discourage unsustainable development. Not every part of the continent should be covered with homes.
- scythe 1y ago>the pump broke Saved you a click. Fort Garland sits just below Blanca Peak, the highest in the Sangre de Cristo, which receives a ton of precipitation. So what's the problem? The pump broke. There are water issues in the San Luis Valley. It's a cold desert which happens to be the best place in the United States to grow a recently popular cash crop: quinoa. About 77% of water use in the region is for agriculture, not weird prepper cisterns. This supply is strained, but the current drought status is only D1. TFA is really more of a closing-frontier issue than a drought issue. The states northeast of Pennsylvania manage all of their land via townships. Everywhere else you can get these weird municipal-unincorporated disputes. See also: Walmart locating outside city limits to avoid taxes.
- superdisk 1y agoKind of funny that this warrants a news article. I've been living in South Africa for the last couple years and this is basically just normal. The municipality just doesn't pay the water bill, so we don't have water half the time. What everyone does is install a giant tank and pump at their house so they can shower when the water is out. How quickly you get used to it...
- wahnfrieden 1y agoThis is the standard of the richest country in the world
- superdisk 1y agoThis was the standard of South Africa as well not too long ago. I was just musing that it's funny how quick you get acclimated to complete dysfunction.
- 0xbadcafebee 1y ago> Others are wondering whether to scrap plans to build on their property, leaving home for showers and limiting their toilet flushes. > The pump failed in June, before the system’s planned overhaul. Townspeople were asked to use the “bare minimum” of water — flush the toilets, but don’t water the lawn. It blows my mind they are using flushing toilets in the desert. Composting toilets are not some new-fangled technology, and require zero water. You live in a desert! Come on! > “These men were brought in because I had put them on a water restriction schedule,” Pacheco said in an interview. “They are upset they can’t water their lawns while people can’t have water to actually live.” Watering lawns? In the desert? How is this not illegal? This feels like the entire climate change "controversy" in a nutshell: people so brazenly into the abuse of their own resources that they will fight to continue wasting them until they no longer exist.
- ytrt54e 1y agoI thought it would be MAGA but no, apparently it is a Democratic stronghold
- jimnotgym 1y agoThey think they were an angry mob before, now they have cut off one of their essentials for life. I suspect they could get rather angrier...
- jerlam 1y ago> poorest county > multistory homes with sweeping decks facing Blanca Peak > The water crisis has forced older residents to contemplate selling their dream homes, where they had planned to retire The article's framing seems to waver between "how dare you do this to the poor and starving" and "how dare you do this to the older, richer retirees". I'm sure there are people of all kinds affected by the water issue but it's not as simple as the clickbaity title suggests.
- ChrisMarshallNY 1y agoIt’s definitely an article with a personal PoV. But, as an older person, I am not interested in living somewhere that I can’t get an ambulance or quick access to medical treatment.
- pavel_lishin 1y agoAnyone immediately think of Pump Six, by Paolo Bacigalupi, when they got to this part of the story? > Salina Pacheco, who is the manager of the town water district and training to become a water system operator, knew it was coming. She had been talking to the five-member water board about it for two years and had helped secure a $105,000 grant from the Colorado Department of Local Affairs to upgrade the water system, which was suffering from “extreme water hammer” because water traveling through the pipes in opposite directions was colliding. > The pump failed in June, before the system’s planned overhaul.*
- AnotherGoodName 1y agoThis thread is getting weird and with a lack of understanding; There's absolutely no reason to have a negative attitude to people wanting to buy water. I grew up 5mins from the largest shopping center in the southern hemisphere and we still had to occasionally buy water when there was a drought since we were on a rural stretch of road just off the main highway. You don't have to live far out of town to have no town water. The pipes don't go far out of city/town limits at all. You always get periods of prolonged drought even in otherwise perfectly reasonable self-sustainable properties. This isn't some "HAHAHA suck it libertarians" attitude. This is a "anyone who lives slightly outside of town wanting to buy water and being told no" type of situation.
- lokar 1y agoI don't have a negative attitude towards people who live off wells, or local surface water, or some place that sells it to tank back. What I have a negative attitude towards is developing housing in an area of the arid western US without access to water. Water rights (the right to buy water) has controlled development here since before statehood. It's very simple: you don't develop without water rights, it's irresponsible and puts an unfair social burden on others.
- paulnpace 1y agoScrolling throug the comments here, one could conclude the HN community finds it to be justified to remove water access without warning to people they find disageeable.
- HankStallone 1y agoIt's pretty weird, since I'm used to seeing people here arguing that the basic essentials of life like food and water should be provided to everyone without question, with the details of where they come from to be worked out later. Now all of a sudden in this case it's "Let them drink Perrier."
- rbanffy 1y agoI’ll just leave this here: https://www.unwater.org/water-facts/human-rights-water-and-sanitation https://www.unwater.org/water-facts/human-rights-water-and-s... It’s distressing to see human rights violations in the richest country on earth.
- rpcope1 1y agoI don't know what people expect moving to south central Colorado, maybe they're taken in by the "cheap land" posts that flood everything like craigslist for Costilla and Alamosa counties. If you've never been there, it's amazing anything grows on that land at all (it's just high desert) and like the article says the people are really poor there; it's an entirely different world than the front range that people seem to extrapolate to the rest of Colorado. Everybody feels entitled to live in Colorado, but our problems are going to come to a head sooner or later when we face the reality that even the front range doesn't frankly have enough water for all of it's citizens or it's ag activies (and we keep building more and more crazy dam and pipeline projects). I personally believe we're going to see a major crisis level drought in the front range in the next 20-30 years that ends up potentially causing a significant population shrinkage in our metros, and it will likely be even more acute elsewhere in the state (as the front range metro basically gets preferential treatment to everywhere else).
- jamiek88 1y ago“ Agriculture uses approximately 80% of the Colorado River's water, with irrigation for crops like alfalfa and hay being the largest consumers.” Alfalfa takes a massive 33% of that water. Most of that alfalfa goes to the Middle East. But sure, yeah metro areas getting the blame, as is tradition.
- 0b110907 1y agoA book with stories about different people that have settled in that area https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/60206504-cheap-land-colorado https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/60206504-cheap-land-colo... Overall it seems tough living around there, large parcels of land were divided and sold 30+ years ago via mail order and land values haven' tracked inflation in a lot of cases. A lot of people moving there for a second chance or fresh start.
- rfwhyte 1y agoSome context it seems a lot of folks in these comments have missed is that the off grid folks apparently use 1/120th of the town's water, yet contribute 15% of the town's water revenue. So effectively they are subsidizing the towns water system while using an insubstantially tiny fraction of the towns water, and even then the townies shut them out for reasons.
- joshuaissac 1y agoCan't they at least get together, hire some tanker lorries and bring in water from somewhere else? Sure, it may be more expensive than the $43k they currently pay, due to transport costs, but at least they will have water. > A more immediate solution is a potential plan to have a private company bring a water tanker to county-owned property in Fort Garland. It seems like the residents are waiting for the local government to take care of this problem (with a potential plan), when they could instead address it directly by co-ordinating with their neighbours, who also need water, to take action.