3 ms·
Who cares. This is getting ridiculous. Originality counts when buying art, not tools. This is a box with some electronics inside. Does it do the job better
by stickfigure 14y ago
Who cares.
This is getting ridiculous. Originality counts when buying art, not tools. This is a box with some electronics inside. Does it do the job better than other computing devices?
This is like complaining when Craftsman came out with polished metal wrenches that look just like Snap-On. Stop trying to make computing into a fashion statement.
- gavinlynch 14y agoWhile your viewpoint is in a way logical, that's just not how the average consumer operates. Design aesthetics absolutely do impact consumer's purchasing decisions, whether or not they are explicitly aware of it or not. Poor design can undersell a great working product. And vis versa.
- veemjeem 14y agoDesign matters even when it's not art. There's a great little documentary called "Objectified". It's worth watching if you want to see a rebuttal for your opinion.
- stickfigure 14y agoYou misread my point about tools. Design has value. Originality doesn't. Nobody is complaining that HP's new product has bad design; in fact, they seem to be complaining that it follows Apple's good design. This is petty vanity.
- dagw 14y agoHe said originality doesn't matter, not that design doesn't matter. Design is very important, in fact it's probably so important that when faced between the choice of good design and original design it's probably best to err towards good design.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jentulman 14y agoI do care what my kit looks like. Part of my consideration of price of the Apple kit I purchased was that it is prettier than a lot of other kit. I spend most of my life looking at it so I'd prefer it to be pleasing to the eye.
- stickfigure 14y agoHP isn't making your kit any uglier. What you're saying is not that you care what your kit looks like, but that you want to make sure that the other person's kit looks uglier than your kit. Ok, I get it. Computers are the new fashion item for the masses, and Apple is the current trendsetter. Don't whine when other companies follow the trend. You really aren't special because your handbag has little LVs printed on them.
- jentulman 14y agoNo I am saying I care what my kit looks like, I don't care what other people's kit looks like or if they care. I was stating that in my case it's slightly more than just a tool, nor did I say that I buy my kit based on what other people will think of it. You're right, fashion is bunk, I made a decision based on a personal aesthetic and an enjoyment of nice design, which at the time Apple best met (and currently still do). I would love it if every computer on the planet was a joy to look at, pretty things make people feel good. To actually give an opinion on the HP machine I do think that what HP have done here is extremely lazy. There is nothing wrong with people taking influence from Apples (or anyone elses) successful design work, look at the Samsung Series 9 for a good example of matching the trend whilst being novel. Design is constantly inspired and influenced by what comes before. Everything is a remix. There is an obvious and often noted influence upon Apple from Dieter Rams work at Braun, but never outright copying.
- notJim 14y ago> This is a box with some electronics inside. Except HP tried this for years, and apparently decided it didn't work. It turns out that aesthetics actually do matter. After all, if they didn't, why would HP copy Apple at all?
- commandar 14y agoI think the reason this gets attention is that it's a symptom of one of the underlying problems with the PC hardware industry. The big guys tend to be, for lack of a better term, lazy. It's not just that they copy, it's that when they copy, they tend to do so poorly and miss a lot of what made the original design good in the first place. PC users have been suffering through bad design and questionable build quality for years, and rather than sit down and think through their designs, the major manufacturers have taken to making superficial copies of Apple's hardware. This is the reason I've been so excited about Vizio getting into the PC market. http://www.vizio.com/all-in-one/overview http://www.vizio.com/all-in-one/overview http://www.vizio.com/thin-light/gallery http://www.vizio.com/thin-light/gallery They've done a decent job of showing that it's possible to design nice-looking, well-built PCs without outright aping Apple. I actually think the AiOs are prettier than the iMac, personally. Which isn't to say they're perfect. I own one of the 14" T+Ls, and while it's very good on the whole, it has some issues like a meh-tastic touchpad. But it's still worlds better than what any of the established PC manufacturers have been doing, and it's kind of sad that a company that had never built a computer before has managed to design one that's better than most of what's being built by companies with decades of experience.
- da_n 14y agoSorry, but this is pathetic, are you saying there is no application of human creative skill, no imagination, no expression involved when Ive (and team) designed the iMac? How is it not copying to take all these creative ideas and slavishly copy them? To dismiss industrial design as only valuable as a tool, never to be considered art, is completely close-minded. Art is in the eye of the beholder, what is art is subjective, and last time I checked nobody made you in charge of what art is. Edit: Expanding on my point, why not think of this instead as an art movement? A group of artists have agreed on general principles, but this does not give license to slavishly copy each other to the finest details, to make exactly the same paintings. They can use the same materials, the same paint, the same brushes, the same techniques, but not paint exactly the same picture. What HP has essentially done here is said "I like the Mona Lisa, let's make one exactly like that".