3 ms·
What pyrotechnics are you referring to? In HCF? My complaint about this show is sort of the opposite --- that it's basically Six Feet Under, but replace the fun
by tptacek 1y ago
What pyrotechnics are you referring to? In HCF? My complaint about this show is sort of the opposite --- that it's basically Six Feet Under, but replace the funeral home with a series of tech startups.
(I think it's a solid B-tier prestige series; I don't hate it).
- aspenmayer 1y agoThat's what I'm asking! It's like, did we even watch the same show?
- chipt4 1y agoNot to mention, HoC had a major gimmick driving it (spacey breaking the 4th wall).
- hnlmorg 1y agoThat’s one gimmick and it was weaved throughout the show. It was also used to further the story telling. HCF created drama in places it wasn’t earned. And did so just so that episodes could have cliffhangers. Think of it like a shower scene in a movie. More often than not, it has literally no relevance to the movie. It doesn’t further the plot. It’s not even part of the story. It’s just there so that it can be used as a clip in the movie trailer. Well HCF was full of stuff that, admittedly wasn’t there for trailers (or at least I don’t think they were), but they also added nothing to the story. They were just there to artificially add some drama. But that drama wasn’t earned. For example, the suicide was very poorly handled. It was used as vehicle for discussing open source vs proprietary code. But you could have easily done that without the death. Instead you ended up with interesting plot themes being overshadowed by this one lazy plot device. The show was absolutely full of stuff like that. Things that were completely out of the blue and if it made it to the cutting room flow then the show would have flowed just the same without it.
- aspenmayer 1y ago> Think of it like a shower scene in a movie. More often than not, it has literally no relevance to the movie. It doesn’t further the plot. It’s not even part of the story. It’s just there so that it can be used as a clip in the movie trailer. Depends on the movie. Once I studied films and film theory (just in undergrad, not trying to claim any special authority on the subject), I appreciated more how these interstitial scenes are meaningful. It's all part of mise-en-scène. It lets the scenes feel alive and lived in, and not just a 2D image flying by at 24ish FPS. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mise-en-sc%C3%A8ne https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mise-en-sc%C3%A8ne > Mise-en-scène has been called film criticism's "grand undefined term". Ed Sikov has attempted to define it as "the totality of expressive content within the image". It has been criticized for its focus on the dramatic design aspects rather than the plot itself, as those who utilize mise-en-scène tend to look at what is "put before the camera" rather than the story. The use of mise-en-scène is significant as it allows the director to convey messages to the viewer through what is placed in the scene, not just the scripted lines spoken and acted in the scene. Mise-en-scène allows the director to not only convey their message but also implement their aesthetic; as such, each director has their own unique mise-en-scène. Mise-en-scène refers to everything in front of the camera, including the set design, lighting, and actors, and the ultimate way that this influences how the scene comes together for the audience. If you've seen many horror movies, you know to expect a jump scare, but because the actual original scare in a shower scene[0] is so played-out by now, audiences expect it, so it has to be subverted. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psycho_(1960_film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psycho_(1960_film) Edit: Just was going over the thread again to see if there were any new posts, and I glanced over your comment again and wanted to reply to this point, because I agree with you and I think I didn't acknowledge this, and it really brings your point upthread home and validates it. > For example, the suicide was very poorly handled. I completely forgot about that part. Good call-out. Mental health issues and self-harm, especially imagery of it, are not plot devices to be used carelessly. Representation matters, and yet it's so hard to do well because those being represented need understanding also, not just seeing triggering stuff on TV and movies. That definitely didn't feel earned, and it didn't land well. I don't know how else it was supposed to feel though, considering the seriousness of the issue. It's a hard topic to put to film. Thanks for mentioning it.
- Mountain_Skies 1y agoJoe setting the truck full of computers on fire is the only thing that comes to mind. That was somewhat over the top and they did settle the character down somewhat in later seasons (though not completely).
- hnlmorg 1y agoI mean “pyrotechnics” in the metaphorical sense. A big flash of drama from nowhere and then nothing afterwards. But that was a poor choice of words on my part. (It was late and I was tired, sorry). I’ve discussed my thinking in the other responses so won’t go in-depth here. But to summarise: The general story had real potential but was marred (in my opinion at least) with cliffhangers that felt jarring and unnecessary to the underlying story.
- jjmarr 1y agoDidn't Kevin Spacey directly kill multiple people over the course of House of Cards to suddenly end a plot thread?
- aspenmayer 1y agoYeah, there was at least the one lady he pushed onto the tracks right as the subway came in that I remember distinctly. Ice cold. I think their point was that in HCF, the off the wall dramatic swings felt more like jumping the shark. In HoC, it felt totally in character for Spacey to do that. It was just better written and acted, despite the intensity of the violence being much higher, because it made sense in the context of the story, and it didn’t in HCF, at least not to me. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jumping_the_shark https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jumping_the_shark