3 ms·
Double-blind is needed when the prejudices of the experimenter and the subject may influence the outcome. In this case, it's safe to assume that the subjects ca
by scott_s 18y ago
Double-blind is needed when the prejudices of the experimenter and the subject may influence the outcome. In this case, it's safe to assume that the subjects care more about winning than they do about the study itself.
Further, what you're testing is their reaction to this new thing. It's inherently impossible to not let the subjects know if they're in the control or experimental group. Good experimental design is not synonymous with double-blind.
- evilneanderthal 18y agoI don't think that's a very safe assumption at all. Lots of athletes do strange things for no good reason. See: Patrick Roy stepping over the blue lines compulsively throughout his entire career. I wonder if he still does it now that he's a coach. I know I play differently if I think something's different with my equipment, even if I have little evidence to support that.
- scott_s 18y agoThose examples have nothing to do with wanting to, consciously or inadvertently, influence the outcome of the experiment. Double-blind only helps in that situation.
- evilneanderthal 18y agoNobody cares if the players want to influence the experiment. The point is to determine whether camouflage pads are more effective than regular pads, which isn't possible. There are simply way too many variables that you can't control.
- scott_s 18y agoAs has been pointed out by others, with enough data, we can infer causality with reasonable confidence. It's not as good as being able to design the experiments ourselves, but it's all we have. The alternative is to throw up our hands and declare that everything outside the lab is outside of science.
- evilneanderthal 18y agoAnd as I keep pointing out, you'll never have the quantities of data required to make that kind of statement with any confidence. For instance, why do the Leafs get halfway through the season and then start sucking? It's been the same story 15 years running now. You'd like to be able to point to one factor that was constant, but every element of the team and the league has changed at every level, from the coaching to the management to the players to the rules to the rink they play in. The only thing that hasn't changed is the size of the puck, but nobody's claiming that that's why the Leafs can't win. Moronic tangent over! I shouldn't post after midnight.
- gravitycop 18y agoIn this case, it's safe to assume that the subjects care more about winning than they do about the study itself. What about the 500 lb deadlift barrier that was only broken when an athlete was tricked into thinking he was only lifting 499.5 lbs?
- evilneanderthal 18y agoThis is precisely my point, which is that the athlete's state of mind has much more to do with their performance than their equipment does (unless it's completely malfunctioned, of course). Put 30 other athletes and coaches and so on in the mix and you have a total mess. Even if the markings made a positive difference it would likely be so small you couldn't distinguish it from the noise.
- scott_s 18y agoYou don't need to know the weight of a barbell before stepping up to it. This is a circumstance where it's impossible to not hide from the subjects that something is different.
- mseebach 18y agoUnless you tell them that they're testing a new hockey-stick design. It's made from a nano-aluminium InnoStrength 2000 alloy, boys! If anyone asks about the odd-looking pad, tell them it's fitted with sensors.