3 ms·
> You can't try to refute only some of my points and not others. Of course I can. I chose only those points where your logical errors were most obvious. > If
by lutusp 14y ago
> You can't try to refute only some of my points and not others.
Of course I can. I chose only those points where your logical errors were most obvious.
> If your treatment is indeed correlated with a cold sufferer getting better, significantly enough, then yes, your treatment does in fact predicts it, even though it might not have been the cure. This is consistent with the definition of prediction being only related to correlation.
No, that is false. Shall I list the definitions for "predict" again, or will you read them again on your own?
> You also did not address my two examples of use of predict in laymen sentences showing the word "predict" did not have anything to do with causation.
You quoted some laymen who suited your purpose, while I listed the dictionary definitions for the word, the definitions that show that "predict" means to assert an effect based on a cause.
> Neither of those definitions have any semblance of implying causation.
Oh, really?
"to declare or indicate in advance; especially : foretell on the basis of observation, experience, or scientific reason"
A prediction is therefore the use of observations of A to predict B, to show a cause-effect relationship. I see the disappearance of the middle class (A), and on that basis I predict the fall of civilization (B). I see gathering clouds (A), and on that basis I predict rain (B) -- and puddles (C).
> Observation, experience, or scientific reason can all be instances of correlation.
Yes, but it's a false analogy with no bearing on this topic. A prediction forges a link between an observation (A) and an outcome (B). It assumes a cause-effect relationship, one that may not be real, but a word isn't responsible for how people misuse it.
> Indeed, one description of statistics is that it provides a means of transferring knowledge about a sample of a population to the whole population
Yes -- an observation of a small sample (A) is used as the basis for a prediction about the population as a whole (B). Also, remember that "prediction" commonly refers to an assertion about the future (B) based on present observations (A).
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/predict http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/predict
"(Verb) to foretell the future; make a prediction."
> Yes it did, correlation means you can use the statistics to predict it, even if it wasn't the cause.
Nonsense. Marijuana use doesn't predict an IQ drop, the study doesn't support that prediction, as the authors were careful to point out, and as the journalists were at pains to ignore.
The marijuana use, and the IQ drop, are only correlated -- one does not predict the other.
- meric 14y ago>> A prediction is therefore the use of observations of A to predict B, to show a cause-effect relationship. I see the disappearance of the middle class (A), and on that basis I predict the fall of civilization (B). I see gathering clouds (A), and on that basis I predict rain (B) -- and puddles (C). You are using the temporal sense of the word "predict", not the cross-sectional sense. Just because you can use the word predict when there is a cause-effect relationship doesn't mean you can't if there isn't. Here is an example illustrating this: I see lots of graffiti in the town (A) and on that basis, predict this town has a high crime rate (B). Notice this prediction was made independent of time. >> A prediction forges a link between an observation (A) and an outcome (B). It assumes a cause-effect relationship, one that may not be real, but a word isn't responsible for how people misuse it. A prediction forges a link between an observation (A) and an outcome (B) to explain a correlation relationship, which may or may not be because of a cause-effect relationship. >> Yes -- an observation of a small sample (A) is used as the basis for a prediction about the population as a whole (B). Also, remember that "prediction" commonly refers to an assertion about the future (B) based on present observations (A). Let's say I am a statistician and after surveying 10% of the population, found out lower income earners are correlated with a lower IQ. I use this observation as a basis for a prediction about the population as a whole - that lower income earners can predict a lower IQ. Notice again, time is irrelevant. >> Also, remember that "prediction" commonly refers to an assertion about the future (B) based on present observations (A). A word may have more than one sense. I am talking about the word prediction as used in statistics. >> The marijuana use, and the IQ drop, are only correlated -- one does not predict the other. If they are correlated then you can use the evidence in the sample to make general predictions in the population (independent of time), provided your experiment methodology was valid.
- lutusp 14y ago> You are using the temporal sense of the word "predict" ... Yes -- that's because that's how the word is defined. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prediction http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prediction "A prediction (Latin præ-, "before," and dicere, "to say") or forecast is a statement about the way things will happen in the future, often but not always based on experience or knowledge." (Emphasis added.) > A word may have more than one sense. I am talking about the word prediction as used in statistics. Yes, all right. Statistics uses the word in the same way, for the same purpose -- as a description of a forecasting method, a statement about the future based on past and present data. Consider the various regression-based prediction methods that are, by definition, statements about the future, based on the past. http://www.isixsigma.com/tools-templates/risk-management/use-forecasting-basics-predict-future-conditions/ http://www.isixsigma.com/tools-templates/risk-management/use... "Forecasting is a business and communicative process and not merely a statistical tool. Basic forecasting methods serve to predict future events and conditions and should be key decision-making elements for management in service organizations." Shall I list ten more references that make the same point about statistical prediction? How about just one: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regression_analysis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regression_analysis "Regression analysis is widely used for prediction and forecasting, where its use has substantial overlap with the field of machine learning." > If they are correlated then you can use the evidence in the sample to make general predictions in the population ... Only if you don't understand science. Correlation is not causation.