4 ms·
Maybe I'm wrong and the recent strange observations (such as the one commented here and the ones linked below) don't stack up and are explained as fast as they
by scotty79 14y ago
Maybe I'm wrong and the recent strange observations (such as the one commented here and the ones linked below) don't stack up and are explained as fast as they appear?
http://www.world-science.net/othernews/101125_galaxies.htm http://www.world-science.net/othernews/101125_galaxies.htm
http://www.universetoday.com/10974/distant-galaxy-is-too-massive-for-current-theories/ http://www.universetoday.com/10974/distant-galaxy-is-too-mas...
http://lsiblog.blogspot.com/2010/11/some-galaxies-look-too-old.html http://lsiblog.blogspot.com/2010/11/some-galaxies-look-too-o...
Or maybe theory of how galaxies form is not the part of big bang theory?
Or maybe I just got downvoted because I triggered some peoples cracpot-filter by using "big bang" and "flawed" in the same sentence?
- lucian1900 14y agoCrackpot filter. Mine's still on. Some findings are slightly surprising, but none so far have had big enough deltas to call the big bang theory "flawed". There's way too much data confirming it.
- Craiggybear 14y agoBut, it is flawed -- simply because its so incomplete. There's simply too much we have absolutely no clue about and we have a lot of gaps that don't neatly add up. Our ignorance is vast. This is partly to do with our limited nature. What we don't know about the origin of the universe far outweighs what we think we do. This won't ever stop being the case no matter how clever we may become. Take exoplanets. According to everything we thought we knew about planetary formation by looking at our own solar system led us to believe every other star system that had planets would follow a similar configuration (rocky planets close their parent star gassy giants further away). That turned out to be spectacularly wrong. We've never seen any star systems with planetary distributions even remotely like ours. The formation of galaxies is even more full of contradictory evidence and we only have the sketchiest picture. Modesty is a feature of good scientists. Know-it-all attitudes get us nowhere.
- mhurron 14y agoYou do know that flawed is not a synonym for wrong? You do also have the reading comprehension to see that 'the big bang theory is wrong' and 'there are flaws with our current understanding of the big bang theory' are in no way saying the same thing?
- andrewcooke 14y agoi suspect that you're being downvoted because people are so eager to "defend" science against religious crackpottery that they forget how big the problems are facing astrophysics. hn readers these days are a bit gung-ho in that respect, while not being that bright, frankly. we really do have serious problems in cosmology and it really does look like some new surprising physics is needed to make sense of it all. we can't explain most of the mass of the universe. we can't even see most of it. this is all standard, accepted wisdom in astronomy (i may not be phrasing it very well, but any/all/most astronomers admit that things are really messed up at the moment - and this is from direct knowledge, as i have a phd in astronomy, although i know longer work in it, and my partner is an astronomy prof doing active research). so much that i would be more inclined to downvote you because what you're saying is not new and interesting, but what everyone already thinks...! having said that, the general idea of a "big bang" at a very broad level - something dynamic and changing, as opposed to the old "steady state" - seems reasonably secure. although it could easily become cyclical or chaotic or...
- andrewcooke 14y agojeez. forgive "know" -> "no" when claiming others not bright...
- lmm 14y agoGalaxy formation is not part of the big bang theory. That we can't predict or model the behaviour of galaxies does not indicate that the big bang theory is flawed, any more than our inability to predict or model turbulent fluid flows indicates that quantum mechanics is flawed (and the reasons for both issues are quite similar).
- JackC 14y agoI wouldn't downvote you, but (purely because you asked) you did trigger my noise filter. Not a big deal, but it sounds like you're interested in how to avoid doing that, so here goes. The reason you set off my noise filter is that "there is growing body of clues indicating that our current understanding of [something] is flawed" makes it sound like you're way overstating your competence in the field. I mean, if you were an expert in the field, and you said (1) I'm familiar with what big bang theory is and why we believe it, and (2) there are enough observations that seem inconsistent with the theory that I'm starting to think it has basic flaws, then that would be really interesting, especially if you went into detail. But if you're not an expert, reading a couple of popular science articles about particular observations that haven't been explained yet tells you absolutely nothing about whether there's a "growing" body of clues, or whether there are any clues at all, that the big bang theory is flawed. It just tells you that there are some observations that we can't explain yet. It's like (no offense) a creationist saying "there is a growing body of clues that our current understanding of evolution is flawed," when all they really mean is that they've read a few articles about particular fossil evidence that isn't explained yet. So basically I would encourage you to write something off the bat more like your follow-up. Say, "I've seen a number of articles about strange observations like this one that don't fit in with our idea of how the universe was formed. Does that indicate actual problems with the theory, or does it just take time to figure out how new observations fit in?" And then I think people would upvote you instead of downvote you. Hope this helps.
- scotty79 14y agoThank you for this advice.