5 ms·
Let's say that most people learn about families only through watching 1950s live-action TV; Ozzie and Harriet, The Donna Reed Show, Leave It To Beaver, and even
by dalke 14y ago
Let's say that most people learn about families only through watching 1950s live-action TV; Ozzie and Harriet, The Donna Reed Show, Leave It To Beaver, and even I Love Lucy. Can I not say that those portray an idealized version of family life, rather than a real one? And that they should not be use as a guide for how a real family should interact?
Yet your logic would be that "the moment you try to judge what 'real' families are, you have stopped being reasonable." I do no think I am being unreasonable to say that Ozzie and Harriet does not portray a real family. Yes it was very popular, and that show is still used as short-hand expressing a longing for an idyllic bygone American life, but the situations and reactions were only valid for a very small percentage of the US. It took another 15 years, with shows like All in the Family, for more realistic themes like miscarriage, impotence, and racism to be included as part of the issues that families might deal with. Roseanne would also fit into that category, as Barr included a lesbian main character because Barr sought "to portray various slices of real life, and homosexuals are a reality."
Why can't I also say that most pornography does as good a job of portraying real sex as Leave It To Beaver does at portraying a real family with husband, wife, and two sons?
Our disagreement could be a simple as a difference in what 'real' means. I use it as "more likely to be characteristic of the general culture practice." You seem to interpret it as "whatever can happen in the physical world."
In which case, sure, I Love Lucy could be a perfectly accurate portrayal of a real family - unlikely, but it could. And it misses the point. That being: “The issue I’m tackling is not porn,” she said. “It’s the complete lack of open, healthy dialogue around porn and sex.”
- Swizec 14y agoBut is porn "not real" in that regard? Okay, the stories definitely don't happen (pizza boy/girl etc.) but nobody knows why those are a part of porn anyway, everyone just skips over them. And I'm guessing the logistic problems make three+somes less frequent than in porn, the tabooness of it all as well I guess. But the sex itself, is it that much different than "real" sex? Are there really that many people having boring sex to make the amount of people coming close to and/or surpassing porn a statistical anomaly? If I recall the movie correctly (yes, I only watched the movie), Kinsey found out people are a lot kinkier than they let others believe once you really get down to finding out their true behind-the-scenes actions. With the shifting social mores, has that changed? Do we now let others think we are far kinkier than we really are?
- doktrin 14y agoPorn is generally quite fake and it has almost nothing to do with the amount of kink involved. The most obvious "tells" are the poses which are used for their telegenic qualities above all else. Also notable are the buildup times, which are routinely trimmed to a minimum.
- aes256 14y agoIt's not just the pizza delivery story lines. Almost everything about porn is fake. The settings are fake, the lighting is fake, the actors' physical appearance is fake (make-up, post-processing, etc.), the emotions are fake. Often the actors lie about their age, their sexual experience, etc.
- hollerith 14y agoSomeone on 4chan, a forum with many devoted experts on porn, said that most of the big penises are fake (i.e., prosthetics), too. (No one further down the thread contested the assertion).
- bitwize 14y agoI've seen prosthetic pussies in porn too (most notably in a movie where a man purportedly inserts nearly his entire head in a woman; the plastic prosthetic female sex bits were glaringly obvious).
- icebraining 14y agoAgreed. And most porn is not even made to resemble reality, like sex scenes in most other movies usually are. It's crudely, unabashedly fake.
- dalke 14y agoI don't understand your comments vis-à-vis Cindy Gallop's views. Her position, which I gather from her TED talk, is that it's increasingly easy to get access to hardcore pornography, which gets more people to believe that what happens in hardcore pornography is the way to have sex. Moreover, we live in a puritanical society where parents and schools don't talk with children about sex. As a result, she believes that hard-core pornography has become de-facto sex education. As a specific example, many of the 20-year-olds she has had sex with believe that coming on a woman's face is part of normal sex. She's fine with telling them that she does not want that. Her concern is that a young woman who does not want that, but where her boyfriend does, and where "hardcore porn has taught her that all men love coming on women's faces, that all women love having their faces come on, and therefore she must let him come on her face and she must pretend to like it." She explicitly states that this is not a good and bad sex view, and indeed asserts that sex "embraces the vastest possible range of proclivities." Instead, she says that hardcore porn presents a "one-world view" and she wants to say "not necessarily." Which means that no, porn is "not real" in that regard. The "makelovenotwar.com" site has examples of "porn world", where women have no pubic hair, and "real world", where some do, some don't, some men actually prefer women with hair, and it's a personal choice. In "porn world", "women come all the time ins positions where nothing is going on anywhere near the clit." In "real world", there needs to be something. In porn world, "all women love anal sex." In the real world, a lot of women are not. In the porn world, camera angles are important. In the real world, one of the pleasures of sex is the full body skin-on-skin contact - which would make it hard for the camera. And so on. (Yes, porn is vast, and there are niches with all of these examples. That's not part of mainstream porn.) So yes, the sex shown in hardcore porn is real sex. But so is a lot of other things which makes for great sex but boring porn. Do you really want to watch the foreplay of a couple, naked but under a warm blanket, talking about how their day went or the frustrations at work while enjoying the nearness of each other? And then stopping for a moment to look something up in the dictionary? No, no more than you want to watch video of most real families going about their lives. There are many other ways to learn how families work than by watching TV. Where does one learn about how sex - and I of course mean more than the mechanics - works? Her argument seems to be that porn is not diverse enough, and that instead viewers are channeled into a certain set of ideas of what sex is. This is nothing to do with kinky. This is nothing to do with boring sex. Hence I don't see how any of your comments apply.
- konstruktor 14y agoAt no point did I advocate using porn as a model of your sex life, and much less using bad porn. Because of that, I absolutely agree with many of your points about TV drama and family life. However, I actually am using "real" very similarly to your definition. If porn has an impact on cultural practice, sex that is influenced by porn is real in that way, and so is sex influenced by romantic novels. We probably are less aware of the latter, though, since the ubiquity of porn on the internet is a newer phenomenon. The quote you use sounds quite sex-positive. But please also note that the article uses "real" in quotes (sometimes even capitalized), so it is fair to assume that Gallop uses that term extensively as well, and probably in a judgmental fashion. Also, her site is called "make love, not porn". I find both quite hypocritical, since, after all, she is operating a porn site.
- dalke 14y agoHer view is that many people do use porn as a model for their sex life, and that mainstream hardcore porn - which she things has a limited world-view - should not be the de-facto source of sex education. All that is in her TED presentation. Perhaps watching that video would give you a different sense of the person than that NYT article about the person? I think you are right to argue that she's advocating for more of the variant of reality pornography which is a higher quality of amateur pornography, or for more erotica. However, I think her real goal is that pornography is not where people should be learning about sex, and she's using this as a way to advocate that goal. Framed your way, she thinks porn's impact on cultural practice is too constricting, and detrimental to the type of society she wants there to be.