4 ms·
> Creativity Predicts a Longer Life False! Creativity is correlated with a longer life. > A large body of research links neuroticism with poorer health and co
by lutusp 14y ago
> Creativity Predicts a Longer Life
False! Creativity is correlated with a longer life.
> A large body of research links neuroticism with poorer health and conscientiousness with superior health. [Emphasis added.]
There's that word again -- "links". Neuroticism is not linked with poorer health, it is correlated with poorer health.
And so forth -- frankly, the linked article is a piece of pseudoscientific trash.
Psychologists would be so much happier if there simply wasn't any science at all, rather than the kind they practice -- the kind that avoids control groups, experimental discipline, can't seem to express correlations accurately, and draw nonsense conclusions like this:
"...the results suggest that practicing creative-thinking techniques could improve anyone's health by lowering stress and exercising the brain."
Without a control group, without a disciplined, prospective, double-blind, replicated study, the "results" suggest no such thing. Isn't obvious that creative thinking may be an effect, not a cause, of good physical and mental health?
Reading articles like this, I begin to suspect that in school, psychologists are told, "say the word 'science' a lot -- that's how you do science."
- meric 14y agoPredict is something you can do if something is "correlated"! Having creativity is highly correlated with a longer life, therefore, creativity can be used as a factor to predict whether a person has longer life. It doesn't mean that if you get more creative you live longer, just that if you look at the existing population, the more creative people are likely to live longer also. See? Search for this phrase in this paper "We show how simple image statistics can be used to predict the presence and absence of objects in the scene before exploring the image." http://cvcl.mit.edu/papers/TorralbaOliva03.pdf http://cvcl.mit.edu/papers/TorralbaOliva03.pdf You can see how "predict" is a word for an action you can take if something is correlated.
- lutusp 14y ago> Predict is something you can do if something is "correlated"! This is false. I saw a puddle, so I predict that the puddle will cause rain. See the problem? You can't "predict" until you have a cause-effect relationship. A correlation is not a cause-effect relationship: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Correlation_does_not_imply_causation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Correlation_does_not_imply_caus... A quote: "The opposite belief, correlation proves causation, is a logical fallacy by which two events that occur together are claimed to have a cause-and-effect relationship. The fallacy is also known as cum hoc ergo propter hoc (Latin for "with this, therefore because of this") and false cause. It is a common fallacy in which it is assumed that, because two things or events occur together, one must be the cause of the other." > You can see how "predict" is a word for an action you can take if something is correlated. You may be able to do that. Scientists require evidence.
- dllthomas 14y agoEvidence of a correlation is all that's necessary to do that, scientist or not. What a correlation tells me is that if I observe A, I am likely to observe B. In the case of rain and puddles, there is a temporal component that seems to be confusing you. Rain now is correlated with puddles for a while in the future. Puddles now may not be correlated with rain now or in the future[1]. Observing puddles now, I can't tell you anything about rain in the future because there is no correlation, not because there is no causation. [1] If the weather in the area tends to be the same day to day, then I can absolutely predict rain tomorrow based on puddles today, to occasionally be frustrated by weather change or sprinklers.
- lutusp 14y ago> there is a temporal component that seems to be confusing you. I am not confused. Confusing correlation with causation is a very common logical error -- you are not alone.
- dllthomas 14y agoPlease respond to the point of my post, if you are going to respond. "I'm not confused, you are" adds nothing to the discussion - obviously, we both think that. And yes, confusing correlation with causation is a common logical error - one that, I believe, you have become oversensitive to such that you are spotting it where it doesn't exist. This, I thought, was already established before your post here.
- lutusp 14y ago> "I'm not confused, you are" adds nothing to the discussion That might be true if anyone had said it (avoid rhetorical escalation). > And yes, confusing correlation with causation is a common logical error - one that, I believe, you have become oversensitive to such that you are spotting it where it doesn't exist. The post that started this thread correctly identifies a case of touting a correlation as though it represents a cause-effect relationship. This is very common in popular science journalism, where data sets that barely represent a correlation are described as though they were cause-effect relationships, and begin to shape public policy well in advance of, and sometimes in the perpetual absence of, any effort to establish a cause-effect link between some A and some B.