3 ms·
Private companies have no obligations to honor freedom of speech. Google has every right to say that your content must get a passing grade from [insert black bo
by gizmo686 14y ago
Private companies have no obligations to honor freedom of speech. Google has every right to say that your content must get a passing grade from [insert black box]. If the black box happens to be designed to filter out copyright violations, it gets no special treatment from the law.
Having said that, the main reason for many of the oversensitive, automated bots, is that big companies like Google (who have user generated content), still need to be incredibly careful in the area of copyright to ensure that they are protected. I suspect that strengthening safe harbor would largely solve this problem.
I would also like a system where sites were highly incentivised to promote free speach on their platforms, but other than public pressure, I do not see how to do this.
- ubernostrum 14y agoActually, this has nothing to do with freedom of speech, and even Google's terms of service are irrelevant. Here's a very simple scenario that results in hauling Google and/or Google's partners into court: 1. Alice produces a video consisting of 100% original creative content, and registers copyright to it. 2. Alice licenses the video to Bob for distribution, under terms which allow uploading to YouTube. 3. Bob uploads a copy of the video to YouTube. 4. YouTube flags the video and declares the copyright to be held by someone other than Alice. 5. Alice, who is not bound in any way by Google's terms, heads down to the courthouse with a copy of her registration papers and files suit over the misrepresentation of her copyright.